[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/vt/ - Virtual Youtubers

View post   
  [?]In ghost mode, only threads with non-archived posts will be shown
File: 345 KB, 1360x680, 018c05d1f95c3294709bea3a4609a3b4.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9855914 No.9855914 [Reply] [Original]

Gura = Raw talent, no work ethic
Suisei = No talent, high work ethic
Ame = No Talent, no work ethic

>> No.9855994

no soul
no soul
soul

>> No.9856011

>suisei
>no talent
I get that you're trying to make a point about how shit Ame's singing is and I agree with you, but that's just blatantly not true.

>> No.9856129

>>9855914
>Ame = No Talent, no work ethic
https://youtu.be/8PiKQFNMAvc?t=82

>> No.9856201

>>9855994
/thread

>> No.9856315

>>9855914
Me=Negative Talent, work ethic would make it worse

>> No.9856393

>>9856315
Hi Mori.

>> No.9856430

anon you posted this in global already

>> No.9856701

>>9855994
My honest opinion is that Ame has no soul in her music, and also no talent. But since the soul or emotion to the music is hard to pinpoint, people use it to point to the talentless.

Also you need some talent for soul to become meaningful

>> No.9857336

>>9855914
>Ame = no work ethic
seriously nigger

>> No.9857408

Best gura singing stream ever. Highly expiramental

>> No.9857722
File: 149 KB, 1056x1024, 1629417846077.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9857722

>>9855914
the actual non troll answer is
Gura: Talent and soul but no training
Suisei: Talent and training but no soul
Ame: Soul but no talent or training

>> No.9858139

gura doesnt have talent. she isnt musical. the tone of voice is just a purposeful affectation that gullible incel males think "sounds good". but has nothing to do with music.

>> No.9858143

>>9857722
(You)

>> No.9858262

>>9855914
Mori = Talent and work ethic

>> No.9858392

>>9855914
Gura = western whore
Amelia = western whore
Suisei = based and eastern goddess

>> No.9858533

>>9858139
Chumfaggots will defend her because they like little girls.

>> No.9858737

>>9857722
So who has none of them?
Because I know the one with all of them is Marine

>> No.9858893

>every single time, the actual singers are slated to have “no soul”
You might as well just admit your bias has deafened you.

>> No.9859060

>>9855914
ame didn't sign up for holo-EN to be a singer, and anyway boiling things down like this makes you look a rampant autist OP

>> No.9859147

>>9855914
what a stupid take

>> No.9859183

>>9855914
>Suisei
>No talent
Anon that's just bullshit. You could have used Nene since she worked hard to the level where she could get her voice to have higher pitch

>> No.9859200

>>9857722
I'd argue that Ame has talent, its just unpolished due to no training. Her "I Dreamed A Dream" is proof enough.

>> No.9859479

>>9857722
*strokes chin*
The . . . geometry. . .
It is very satisfying. . . hmm.

>> No.9859502

>>9859200
Definitely some talent hiding there, but she easily has an insane amount of soul

>> No.9859510

>>9858893
I think the issue is that most of the girls are singers, not composers. There is a lot of skill involved but not necessarily creativity.
It's like watching a bunch of artists competing to make the best photorealistic painting.
Might be technically impressive but some guy doing a shitty impressionist or abstract might be more appealing to people.

>> No.9859569

>>9859479
it would be satisfying if there was soul and training but no talent.
I'm not sure that makes any sense though.
Oh well.

>> No.9859634
File: 245 KB, 465x485, ameface.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9859634

How you guys feel if Ame learned to sing? i like her more the way she is but eventually this covid bullshit will have to end and the holo EN girls will have to perform a live concert and i dont think cover will let her on the stage without having her learn the basics.

>> No.9859653
File: 2.88 MB, 842x708, 1607561943585.webm [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9859653

>>9857722
>Suisei
>no soul

>> No.9859716
File: 534 KB, 571x720, IMG_20210829_052938.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9859716

>>9859634
If even Noel gets to perform she gets her chance dumb teamate

>> No.9859793

>>9857722
unique singing technique and good singing voice matter the most

soul and talent? not so much

>> No.9859813

>>9858139
>Gura is not good at singing she just hits the notes
What?

>> No.9859815

>Suisei = No talent
Please do us ALL a favour and kys

>> No.9859882

>>9856129
Now THIS is soul

>> No.9860222

>>9859716
Is noel bad at signing?

>> No.9860291

>>9859510
what is this soul cope?
According to you Bob Dylan is a better singer than Freddie Mercury since the latter is trained and had great technique

>> No.9860389

>>9855994
fpbp

>> No.9860492

>>9860291
I have no musical training so I really don't know.
But I can tell you that most of the originals that are put out don't interest me at all.
They just sound like basic jpop.

But some I like.

>> No.9860636

>>9860222
Weeell, good singing is an objective opinion and all
https://youtu.be/2T7Ql4D1UnQ

>> No.9860714

>>9860636
But being objectively good at singing does not mean they are intriguing or enjoyable to listen to.

>> No.9860801

>>9855914
thanks for the feedback lol

>> No.9860874

>>9855994
fpbp

>> No.9860930

>>9857722
>Gura: Talent and soul but no training
This is the only thing I disagree with. Gura has a lot of experience streaming and as a vtuber no less. That’s not to say Ame hasn’t streamed before but what her roommate did is somewhat different from what Ame does right now.
That said, I fucking hate Suisei

>> No.9860980

>>9858139
What the fuck does this post even mean?

>> No.9861005

>>9855914
didn't get enough attention in global so you had to make a thread? how much of a faggot are you OP?

>> No.9861041

>>9860492
>most of the originals that are put out don't interest me at all.
because they're written by a mediocre songwriter. Cover doesn't have money to pay for a good one nor do good writer want to write for a literally who vtuber

>> No.9861066

>>9855914
When it comes to singing everyone pales in comparison to Chima. I wonder if she's music college grad or simply have been taking vocal lessons for a long time

>> No.9861445

>>9860930
Vocal training you dumb fuck

>> No.9862231

>>9861041
The thing is I have no idea how much input the talent have for a song but I imagine it varies quite a bit.

>> No.9862910

>>9862231
Suisei has a lot of input and is quite involved in the song production.

>> No.9863035

>>9862910
Yeah and her songs don't really do it for me.
Maybe because I don't speak Japanese very well.

>> No.9863253

>>9863035
>Maybe because I don't speak Japanese very well.
Well, no shit.

>> No.9863761

>>9863253
I mean it doesn't stop me from enjoying the shit out of Unison, Ahoy and Pallet.

>> No.9865074

>>9863035
She has like 12 songs. Every single one of them sounds different, go pick up one randomly and listen to it. Do what you want though, I don't care enough about the opinion of some anon to try to convince you.

>> No.9865306

>>9863761
>doesn't speak Japanese very well
>enjoys this type of Jpop music better than that type of Jpop music
Not that guy, but anon, you have discovered you have your own musical taste, but no general knowledge of music. There's no accounting for taste, but that doesn't automatically disqualify the talented from having soul. But produced music isn't the place where you find it normally unless it was a live recording.

You can tell who has or doesn't have soul in music by how they sing. There is, after all, a difference between singing right and singing correctly.

>> No.9865526
File: 607 KB, 824x790, 1631077215498.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9865526

>>9855914
Why do you need to drag Suisei into your dumb arguments? Use Mori or someone else from EN

>> No.9865586

>>9865306
That's fair.

>> No.9865711

Gura has no range, she can sign soft softs perfectly but flounders on anything else.

>> No.9865909

Suisei
>Album coming this month
>Solo concert next month
Your shit oshi
>……

>> No.9866202

My dick has soul

>> No.9866522

>>9857722
Here your free (You), enjoy!

>> No.9866566

Oh look, another singer thread, what a joy!

Now consider kys tonight OP

>> No.9867068

>>9856129
i love her voice it's so cute

>> No.9867162

>>9855994
Shitty thing I like: soul
Thing I dislike: no soul

>> No.9867170

>>9855914
The rat could be the best singer from Holo if she keeps the soul and talent from her debut.

>> No.9867638

>>9855994
watch gura's campfire karaoke and tell me again she has no soul you fuck

>> No.9868217

>>9857722
Suisei has no fucking training shes mediocre most of the time

>> No.9868506

>>9865526
>drag suisei into your dumb arguments
anon, the original purpose of this thread was to compare the polar opposites of gura and suisei, i originally didn't want to include ame but i'll be completely honest with you, i couldn't find art of just suisei and gura, suisei gura and ame was the closest i could find so i went with that

>> No.9868542

>>9868217
Yeah she’s pretty shite and generic

>> No.9870732

>>9868506
Just use any of the Suisei vs Gura clips' thumbnail you tard

>> No.9871253

>>9868217
still miles better than the talentless gura

>> No.9871604

>>9870732
i didn't even know there were clips for that, not a clipfag

>> No.9873094
File: 1.08 MB, 919x1201, IMG_20210123_184750.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9873094

>>9871604
You dont have to be a clipfag to know that people pit them against each even outside this containtment because they have some equivalent strong points, mainly rhymth games, singing and Amogus. Said meme for example is posted in Reddit a day before the Amogus collab

>> No.9874924

I’m honestly disappointed this didn’t just turn into a Suityan image dump thread.

>> No.9876024

Gura = Raw talent, no work ethic
Suisei = high talent, high work ethic
Ame = No Talent, medium work ethic

FIFY

>> No.9877036

>>9867162
yes

>> No.9877110

>>9867162
Those are the definitions used on /vt/. You might as well say boring, it's equally meaningless.

>> No.9877413

>>9858392
you will never be japanese

>> No.9879562

>>9877413
My son will be

>> No.9879821

>>9860636
>cute claps
love my menhara

>> No.9880698

>>9874924
We are watching her playing Wariowe

>> No.9882755

OP = Faggot

>> No.9883309
File: 313 KB, 753x424, 16277265436892.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9883309

What I want to know, is who is this magical vtuber that makes people think Sui is mediocre?

Does she actually exist? or is it just Nijis being tribal again?

>> No.9888155

>>9857722
Sharks, like dogs, do not have souls.

>> No.9888339
File: 492 KB, 631x852, d05e774784167ef606ae5e0ba2c13379.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9888339

>>9883309
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JCr3gbTQtsI&t=572s

>> No.9888453

>>9883309
HimeHina dancing around her is a public mogging. I'm saying this as a gazer

>> No.9888698

>>9888453
>as a gazer
no hoshiyomi calls himself like that, falseflagger

>> No.9889297
File: 91 KB, 1080x965, IMG_20210917_011813.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9889297

>>9888698
I can call myself a Yomi if I want to, tard, Sui being a soulful dancer doesnt mean she is a good dancer.

>> No.9889390

>>9889297
but this thread was about singing not dancing

>> No.9891175

>>9889390
HimeHina does music too, but I won't say theyre better than Sui

>>
Reply to thread [?]Don't expect anything heroic. Your post will not be uploaded to the original board.
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action