[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/vt/ - Virtual Youtubers


View post   

File: 304 KB, 870x720, idol アイドル.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
50889537 No.50889537 [Reply] [Original]

Did any chuuba actually do this song justice?

>> No.50889668

Later tonight
https://youtu.be/JmZRrKEqG2M

>> No.50889737

Yeah the indie that did the Getter Robo mashup

>> No.50889831

>>50889668
kek

>> No.50889955 [SPOILER] 
File: 788 KB, 839x1224, 1661218983971597.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
50889955

>>50889537
https://youtu.be/ZiDbbf3aMxg
this is the best version btw

>> No.50890063

>>50889537
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vLjOXsgkvPU
I love Panko so im probably biased.

>> No.50890200

>>50889537
No holo at least, and I wouldn't expect any outside a few to be able to

>> No.50890345

>>50889537
https://youtu.be/STUdQKJ-_io
I really like hoshikawa's cover desu

>> No.50890414 [DELETED] 

>haha vtubers are so fake haha and we scam losers

so tired of this shitty show.

>> No.50890813

>>50889955
this will be the first time that I will l hear this song, and I know that Noelle will not dissapoint

>> No.50890990 [DELETED] 

>>50890414
Both those things are true tho

>> No.50891177 [DELETED] 

>>50889537
Only way they'd do justice is if they actually followed the premise of the song by heart and were to meet the same fate as that girl.

>>50890414
also this.

>> No.50891222 [DELETED] 

just me or feels like this show fell off a cliff? stop seeing a lot of people talking about talking about it and even ep 6 with the melodramatic suicide hotline at the end didn't really get any attention in the west

>> No.50891379

>>50889537
I agree with >>50890345 , the others either use a shitty base or sound really off to me, hell, even random karaoke ones sound better that some released covers.
I guess you can't really beat Ayase + Ikura

>> No.50891474 [DELETED] 

>>50891222
FOTM cycle is accelerating faster and faster every season

>> No.50891612

>>50889537
I really like this version. She's got that kick to her voice and singing style that I like.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JDWxgsWLWbg

>> No.50891754 [DELETED] 

I think the original song is mid. I want examples of someone sininging it better to make me want to listen to the song

>> No.50891834

I think the original song is mid. I want examples of someone singing it better to make me want to listen to the song

>> No.50891836

>>50891612
Its almost a bit much but you are right, this is really good.

>> No.50892244

>>50889537
I think the song sucks so honestly even if any chuuba did it justice I'd still think it sucks

>> No.50892486

>>50892244
>I think the song sucks
Why are you so wrong, anon?

>> No.50892558

>>50892486
Yoasobi has done way better. I will admit the song fits the show like a glove which is all that matters in the end, but as a standalone listen it's whatever.

>> No.50892685
File: 37 KB, 582x484, 1684631401940519.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
50892685

>>50892558
I think it's pretty catchy

>> No.50892837

Kanata

>> No.50892850

>>50889955
1% idol 100% soul

>> No.50892902

>>50892486
I do agree with that anon it's not that great of a song. But, it is a song that requires changes in singing style. Because of that, I think you can really see the versatility and creativity between different singers for good or bad. There's going to be a lot of variation between covers of this song.

>> No.50893791

>>50892244
This. I think the rap intro is disgusting, and the rest is just generic j-pop. Yuurei Toukyou is way better.

>> No.50893866

>>50889537
I've never heard of this song before but it's probably trash since normalfags and ironic weeaboos seem to love it a lot

>> No.50895518
File: 612 KB, 907x726, 1640514657556.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
50895518

>>50889537
Astel's planning a cover, just wait for his.

>> No.50895800

>>50889537
I don't even like this song but I liked the way this guy did it
https://youtu.be/ww5FLCKPsQw

>> No.50895882

>>50889955
HOLY FUCKING KINOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

>> No.50896023

>>50889537
Kanata

>> No.50896151

>>50889537
Yeah, Fauna, by completely ignoring it and the whole anime.

>> No.50896171

>>50895800
god i hate homos so much

>> No.50896422

>>50889537
It was karaoke streaming, but Machita Chima was the closest to the original song.

>> No.50896437

>>50889955
Ado mogged
Yoasobi mogged
Who next?

>> No.50896710

Mori just did

>> No.50897060
File: 124 KB, 750x965, afb32d5855fe0131ae9122752f6946e5.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
50897060

This is how you do this song justice

>> No.50897299

based

>> No.50897382

>>50889537
>>50890063
This. PANKO MANKO

>> No.50897444

>>50896171
Anon, you need to raise your self-esteem...

>> No.50897679

>>50889668
Best in thread so far

>> No.50897688

https://youtu.be/ZiDbbf3aMxg yaosobi mogged

>> No.50897699

>>50895800
he is screaming more than he is singing

>> No.50897744 [DELETED] 

So basically, /vt/ hates this anime because they are the villain?

>> No.50897771

>>50889537
Hakka's was the best, and I'm not even into the homos.

>> No.50897843 [DELETED] 

>>50897744
Yes, can you even see my villain cape?

>> No.50897856

>>50889955
Svoooooollll

>> No.50897992

>>50889668
I actually winced in pain multiple times, and I'm mostly neutral on Mori. She really needs to just stick to rap, her singing is embarrassing.

>> No.50898248

>>50889537
https://youtu.be/iiHRF95vHdI
https://youtu.be/ajg6QgBCxH8

>> No.50898359

>>50897992
>She really needs to just stick to rap, her singing is embarrassing.
This but the opposite.

>> No.50898465

>>50898359
Her rap is cringe because all rap is cringe, but she's at least pretty good at it. She's an actually terrible singer and her attempts to break into normal singing are embarrassing.

>> No.50898537

>>50889537
>Yoasobi
Sorry, I like songs that don't feel like they were AI generated.

>> No.50898582

The few lines Kobo did were basically perfect.

>> No.50898672

>>50892685
NTA but the chorus is fine, but everything else feels bland. Yoasobi usually can put out reliably good OPs but this felt just disappointing
But then again, I went into OnK thinking that Hackasaka wasn't going to put out gray matter westerner-pandering tripe, so maybe that's on me.

>> No.50898719

Himehina's is the best but my little indie did a decent one.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=va3F0rvPq-o

Ai-chan's VA also did a pretty good one
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Raxc7gHRTow

>> No.50898738

>>50889537
My vsinger wife and numberfag prime.
https://www.youtube.com/live/vBVUCoPN_Xw?feature=share&t=1660

>> No.50898869

>>50898738
Our wife now.

>> No.50898911

>>50889955
>uverworld BTFO
>Creepy Nuts BTFO
What can't this woman do?

>> No.50899322
File: 163 KB, 264x324, kannyagi.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
50899322

>>50898869
Wife with ears.

>> No.50900482

>>50897771
Ehhhhh, the parts where his metal screams were coming out kinda threw the flow off.

>> No.50900613

>>50899322
Excellent.

>> No.50900986

>>50889955
HOLY FUCKING SOOOOOOOOOVVVVVVVVLL!

>> No.50901266

>>50890345
>squeak squeak
meh

>> No.50901425

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=AFQLwKxhfN4

>> No.50901436

>>50891612
this one

>> No.50901494

>>50899322
Tenrisex

>> No.50901625

>>50891612
wish.com ado

>> No.50901697

>>50898465
How is your opinion the complete opposite of being the correct one?

>> No.50901823

>>50889668
Just listened to this
She mogs all the whores listed in this thread
Fuck you if you think otherwise

>> No.50901943

>>50889955
it sounds like she's reciting sutras at a shrine

>> No.50901963

>>50889537
The Pipkin Pippa
https://youtu.be/pWmhAitk1PU

>> No.50902360

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UYEd4pe5IKQ

>> No.50902699

>>50889668
mid

>> No.50904145

>>50889537
https://youtu.be/t_nlrqtMx2E

>> No.50904253

>>50902360
7.22/10

>> No.50904448

>>50889668
6.8/10 a well executed mess

>> No.50904543

>>50889955
8/10 if only I was an old man

>> No.50904778

>>50890063
>>50890345
>>50891612
>>50895800
>>50898248
>>50898719
>>50898738
>>50901425
>>50901963
>>50904145
5.5/10 if I'm being generous

>> No.50905645

>>50889955
true SOVL, how nostalgic

>> No.50905947

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ORJu0rJeJiI
Not as polished, but her voice being kinda raspy while recording this one somehow makes the middle part hit extra hard.

>> No.50906052

>>50889955
10/10 ikura mogged

>> No.50906162

>>50889537
She could drop the best version but, my wife is a contrarianfag who ofthen chose strange melodies over fotm

>> No.50906333

>>50889537
https://youtu.be/mkYA2bdnHTU
Dunno about the best but, this def turns my dick diamond

>> No.50906444

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EcrnVffzhv4

>> No.50906885

I can't put my finger on what it is exactly but this one gives me chills, especially during that middle section https://youtu.be/IB4y7DJ_fXg

>> No.50907128

>>50906444
Karubi's voice is shit.

>> No.50907498

>>50889537
There's a song? I don't pay attention to garbage flavor of the month weeb shit that /a/ trannies coom themselves too.

>> No.50907571

>>50895800
Woah it's actually good. The original is easy too flat. I like ikura but she doesn't shine enough in these higher energy songs and gets drowned by the bass and heavy noise. Then again my opinion of the song wasn't high because it's such a big departure from the usual cozy Ayase cozy city pop songs with the nice piano. It's interesting and chaotic which fits the show but gets tiresome as a standalone to loop over and over again and is not as fun to listen to with ikura's vocals. (Ikura's vocals are good for relaxing and sleeping)

>> No.50907993

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-4-RDScpYsM

>> No.50908297

>>50889955
Its not fair, how can the EN even compete with this

>> No.50908491

https://youtube.com/watch?v=IB4y7DJ_fXg&pp=ygURQW1pIGFtYW1pIHlvYXNvYmk%3D

I really enjoy her singing and voice overs so far

>> No.50908872

Fuck the haters, I appreciate all the covers.

>> No.50908903

Fuck the fans, I hate all the covers.

>> No.50908910

fotm cuckshit.

>> No.50909040

>>50908903
>>50908910
Speedy bots lmao

>> No.50909128

>>50889537
doing covers of actual top selling singers will always result in them being worse

>> No.50910998
File: 388 KB, 1000x716, 1659114956203993.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
50910998

>>50905947
I agree.

>> No.50912751

>>50893791
>I think the rap intro is disgusting
Why are you black?

>> No.50912793

>>50897992
you've only now realized this ?

>> No.50912975

>>50907571
>The original is easy too flat
The original voice is supposed to be flat because that was literally a part of the Idol's character. She was dead inside and struggling.

>> No.50913022

>>50889668
Mori sings semi-well (better than her ass rap) but she needs to stick to her FUCKING OWN VOCAL RANGE, this high shit does not compliment her.

>> No.50913093
File: 57 KB, 203x149, pippa smol mouth.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
50913093

>>50901963
Aside from it telling you in the title, you can tell it's AI because it can actually hold a pitch

>> No.50913240

>>50912975
She should graduate and kill herself instead of lying to her fans.

>> No.50913256

Only Koyori the based GOD coyote

>> No.50913437

>>50895800
Yeah, I'm not that crazy about the song, but I like Hakka's version. His energy and the raspiness of his voice give it a refreshing twist.

>> No.50913618

>>50913093
Why would you say this

>> No.50913823
File: 33 KB, 128x128, pippa bonk.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
50913823

>>50913618
Because it's true
I love Pippa but goddamn if she isn't near tone deaf sometimes.
Love to hear her sing, but boy she needs singing lessons, and imho she needs idol reps in general, she gets real tired real fast in 3D, regarless of the fact that 99% of her 3D time is not spent dancing.

>> No.50913899

>>50891379
>even random karaoke ones sound better that some released covers
This happens way too often lately, or at least it feels like that. Either the recording quality is garbage, or volume levels are all over the places. What the hell.

>> No.50913926

>>50913240
>He doesn't know

>> No.50913938

>>50889537
I still haven't listened to any of them, or even the original because fuck dramashit

>> No.50914079

>>50913022
More like singing doesn't compliment her

>> No.50914115

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FDaRmdSRbMM
embrace the future old man

>> No.50914314

>>50914079
eh, kinda
I really liked her singing in end of a life tho, that one's nice.
but then again that one has pointless rap as well, and overall is a needle in a haystack, so I have no real defence.

>> No.50915558

>>50913022
desu Mori should cover Stan if she wants to own le haters, both parts would actually fit her

>> No.50915577

>>50889537
Mori did

>> No.50915597

>>50889537
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=udHfWiWluko

>> No.50916037

>>50905947
I agree that her raspy singing still sounds really good, but I just might be a bit biased here, because she is my oshi and I'm hopelessly her hooman.

>> No.50916197
File: 3.85 MB, 2508x3541, 4E0D971C-DBF2-4F6C-A9E3-9B9E090422A9.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
50916197

>>50890345

>> No.50916232

>>50889668
nigger rap suits nigger like people

>> No.50918306

>>50916197
Based and Abepilled

>> No.50918562

>>50889537
Of-fucking-course not. The vocals in that song belong to Ikura and Ikura only.

>> No.50918969

>>50889537
No, none can match. But vtubers are jack of all trades so its very unlikely for anyone to match Ikura-san anyway.
>>50890345
the best version I heard so far. Adding her own spin on it gave her an davantage unmatched by any other.

Maybe if we focuse on specifically vSingers instead of tubers we can find someone close to?

>> No.50919265

>mogs everyone
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ko9M-K5FJnQ

>> No.50919653 [DELETED] 

>>50889668
Kys cuckbeat.
>>50889537
AZKi did it pretty damn well https://youtu.be/N06ICR1cgQ0

>> No.50919841 [DELETED] 

>>50901823
Ogey cuckbeat.

>> No.50920021

>>50919653
>AZKi did it pretty damn well
no she didn't lol

>> No.50920114

>>50889537
no one has done it right yet. they all need to keep making covers until one of them gets it right...

>> No.50920140
File: 131 KB, 525x427, drinkdakober.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
50920140

my daughter will do it justice

>> No.50920364

>>50889668
This was really mid.

>> No.50920405

>>50919265
unironically a banger

>> No.50920630

>>50889668
Incredible music video. Song doesn't suit her voice well. The "Idol" high note is a little rough, I refuse to believe that was the absolute best take they had.

>> No.50921593

>>50889955
this

>> No.50922191
File: 1.45 MB, 1535x874, image-30.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
50922191

https://youtu.be/dZSLSAFqzAA
koyori has the best version, its between hers and kanatas

>> No.50923069

Where is the Sora version.

>> No.50923280

>>50923069
there should be a full mobilization of hololive. everyone assemble to listen to a live broadcast from yagoo. he declares all other work stops while everyone produces a cover of this song. the full cover corp machine spins up to pump out a version from everyone.

>> No.50923397

ENTER BLYAD
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=H0egAZGA7MY

>> No.50923640

>>50889668
Honestly not awful. If she had taken it lower it probably would've been one of the best ones in the thread.

>> No.50923713

>>50922191
Wow she did an amazing job.

>> No.50923830

>>50905947
The song is perfect for Mumei

>> No.50924381

>>50918969
>Maybe if we focuse on specifically vSingers instead of tubers we can find someone close to?
My guy there's already plenty of vsingers posted in this thread.

>> No.50924425 [DELETED] 

>>50919653
>>50919841
It's actually hilarious how thin skinned the Deadbeat janny is.

>> No.50925050

>>50898248
No other cover posted in this thread comes even closer to these two.

>> No.50925174

The OG song is bad so all covers are bad too. The anime also sucks. Watch episode 1, glare at Japanese culture, then drop it.

>> No.50925770

>>50922191
I don't hate the vocals but wtf is with the mixing

>> No.50926072

>>50889537
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=z6RSOiYOVuQ
The Koreans sell this image way better than even Yoasobi.

>> No.50926307

>>50898248
I was just about to post this. I stumbled across them the other day and damn they're good at singing.

>> No.50926744

>>50889537
I love Mumei's version. It fits her voice even the rap parts. Kinda want her to do an actual cover now.

>> No.50927037

>>50926744
Mumei is one of holo's most underrated singers

>> No.50927065

>>50925174
Yeah that's why I didn't even bother with the anime it's just oozing with j*panese (((culture))). And all these retards eating it up normalizing the fuck out of it

>> No.50928388

>>50925174
>>50927065
You have to go back.

>> No.50928474

>>50889955
The fuck are you smoking? It hurts my ears.

>> No.50928906

>>50928474
huh?

>> No.50929099

>>50922191
koyoooooo!

>> No.50929739

>>50895800
This is the best one so far

>> No.50929920

>>50889537
Nope.

>> No.50930365

>>50928474
You're not supposed to say that out loud. You're supposed to call it SOVL and pretend it's the greatest thing you've ever heard.

>> No.50930474

>>50930365
Pippa is a SOVL when she sings outside of her voica range, but this is just atrocious.

>> No.50931335

>>50930474
kys pippiger

>> No.50934510

I really liked Mori's.

>> No.50935694

>>50901266
KEK

>> No.50935845

>>50897060
BASED BASED BASED

>> No.50935917

>>50897060
LET'S GOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO

>> No.50936060

>>50927037
>underrated
It’s one of the things she’s best known for. Hell, Cover even sandwiched her solo performance between Azki and Miko at Holofes.

>> No.50941637

>>50889668
FPBP

>> No.50947380

>>50889537
Sakamata's voice works well, the shift between her usual to deep voice is nice

>> No.50947435

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mzwr8AME9oE

>> No.50948015

come on guys obviously rushia did it the best
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pz1_9VLNi4w

>> No.50948566

>>50948015
s-sugoi...

>> No.50949645

>>50889537
Don't know. Don't speak Japanese so every cover sounds the same to me

>> No.50950548

>>50889537
The song is mid anyway.

>> No.50950912

>>50889537
Isn't this an anti-idol song why are holos covering this?

>> No.50954281

>>50950912
it's cute!!! and it says idol!!!!

>> No.50955675

>>50897992
Mori is a horrifically untalented rapper. Shes trash at it and lacks any talent whatsoever for the genre. Meanwhile you can make the case for her being okay at singing. She should actually start making music shes okay at instead of being fucking awful at music shes not okay at.

>> No.50956017

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4B9f9pP32Vc
The only cover that gets the attitude right. Lumi is a fucking bitch and the song is perfect for her.

>> No.50957874

>>50897060
it's so weird going back to the first few chapters and seeing actual competent compositions for this manga, i'm just so used to Caillou toon boom tier panels by this point.

>> No.50959794

>>50898465
>but she's at least pretty good at it
Your taste is absolutely atrocious, holy shit.

>> No.50960157

Nene did a great job. I think her character puts it into a nice perspective where it doesn't feel forced since she's an idol character.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hzUvOnCzWMA

>> No.50961765

>>50960157
someone just make a hololive mix...

>> No.50962378

>>50955675
She should just abandon rap, but then she'd get sad or some bullshit

>> No.50966930

>>50889955
this is actually pretty good

>> No.50966947

>>50889668
Cool

>> No.50969064

>>50889955
Genuinely well done

>> No.50969862
File: 233 KB, 1280x720, 1669797746968754.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
50969862

>>50956017
You're goddamn right

>> No.50969936

>>50950912
Presumably they don’t care about surface-tier takes from random schizos pretending to understand the source material without actually reading or watching it.

>> No.50971335

>>50889955
It's been years, she had classes with professional voice coaches, how is she not getting any better?

>> No.50971411

>>50889955
BASED BASED BASED

>> No.50971585

>>50955675
How can you be this disconnected from reality?

>> No.50971633

>>50971585
it's okay KEKbeat, you don't have to lie to yourself any longer.
just relax and let her go.

>> No.50971697

>>50971633
Your bait needs some serious work. Come on, I believe in you :)

>> No.50971928
File: 2 KB, 120x120, pill_1f48a.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
50971928

>>50950912
>he ACTUALLY BELIEVES that Hololive was ever anything remotely approaching unironic about the """"""idol"""""" thing

>> No.50972385
File: 41 KB, 321x339, 1672545275291481.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
50972385

>>50971697
shit you're right, dropped my image

>> No.50973673

>>50947435
lol it fits her so much knowing some behind the scenes things

>> No.50973720

>>50950912
holos are anti-idol
thats why they are losing viewers kek

>> No.50973835

https://youtu.be/egepGk1VnYM

>> No.50974334

My favourite version of it is naturally by my oshi
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5R4-5N72xRE

>> No.50975019

>>50889955
kino

>> No.50976909

>>50973835
just suisei singing in the bathroom

>> No.50978045

>>50889537
does this count
https://www.youtube.com/shorts/ZMvQe-mItp4

>> No.50979580

The only good one.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=j10LmbnP5Hs

>> No.50981965

>>50897060
based

>>
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action