[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/vr/ - Retro Games


View post   

File: 13 KB, 540x309, 1886067_0.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5614276 No.5614276 [Reply] [Original]

the ultimate debate

>> No.5614279

>>5614276
Who is their PC game opponent? I would argue Half Life.

>> No.5614303

>>5614276
This image isn't blurry enough, you need to blur it some more

>> No.5614309

FFVII

>> No.5614334

>>5614276
having only played a few hours of the first and the second only once, I can say at least in the case of the second, that there's nothing extremely special about it except the storyline. The first seems to be a better game, from the few hours I played it. btw "best of all time whatever" is a cancerous troll spawning topic, fuck you.

>> No.5614339
File: 790 KB, 5000x5000, belmont_shiggy.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5614339

>a game from the '90s
>best of all time
kys zoomer

>> No.5614346
File: 100 KB, 652x396, 68747470733a2f2f7974697572696e2e6769746875622e696f2f7465747269732f7075626c69632f64656d6f2e676966.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5614346

hard yikes

>> No.5614358

>>5614339
'90s games > '80s games. Half of the '80s was arcade shit.

>> No.5614362

Ff7 revolutionized the video game industry and whose influence still exists to this day.

>> No.5614367

>>5614276
>japshit vs. japshit
yeah, "ultimate" debate

>> No.5614368

>>5614358
>arcade
>a bad thing
Never go full zoomer.

>> No.5614370

>>5614362
ff7 was ff6, but rendered more primitively, same goes for OoT being aLttP retread.

>> No.5614375

Both lead to a succession of boring clones.

>> No.5614401 [DELETED] 

*makes /vr/niggers upset*

>> No.5614419

>>5614368
Arcade is not bad, but it gets too samey, and a lot of arcade games from the '80s era don't stand out right now.

>> No.5614425

>>5614362
eh, so did Ocarina with its refinement of 3rd person perspective in a 3D action game.
>>5614279
Yeah probably.
Although the general age range to appreciate for all these games is slightly different
Ocarina: 12 and under
FF7: 13-19
Half-Life: 15+

>> No.5614429

>>5614370
>OoT being aLttP retread.
eh it really wasn't. I find OoT boring as shit but not because it's an aLttP retread.

>> No.5614430

>>5614425
Who is their Sega Saturn opponent? I will nominate Panzer Dragoon Saga.

>> No.5614436

>>5614419
unironically kill yourself, weeb retard

>> No.5614448

>>5614430
dragon force. pds is an unfinished game

>> No.5614452

>>5614276
Panzer Dragoon Saga is better than both.

>> No.5614456

>>5614276
>the first wrpg vs. the first jrpg
Why would you compare different genres?

>> No.5614496

FF7

>> No.5614565

>>5614456
Zelda is an advemture game

>> No.5614689

>>5614362
>whose influence still exists to this day
in a bad way: sacrifing aspects of the gameplay in favour of visuals and story.

>> No.5614702

I was 13/14 then so FF7 was my choice, it was edgier and more "mature".

If I were 8/9 years old instead I probably would have chosen Zelda.

>> No.5614728

Majora's Mask is better than Ocarina of Time.

>> No.5614780

>>5614276
OoT is better than your whole family, maybe even entire nations.

>> No.5614787
File: 73 KB, 202x296, 1497450483409.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5614787

>>5614456
Here we fucking go again.

>> No.5614789
File: 66 KB, 222x317, bg.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5614789

>>5614276
Neither of those pieces of shit, that's for true.

>> No.5614835

>>5614276
FF4, FF5, and FF6 are all better than FF7. So how can FF7 be the greatest of all time?

>> No.5614846

>>5614276
FF7 literally any day. The left is children's play bullshit.

>> No.5614898

>>5614846
>shuns actual gameplay
>enjoys wait-your-turn-mandatory-hit-nonsense
>calls others children

>> No.5614964

>>5614898
>being too stupid understand even dumbed-down Final Fantasy combat

>> No.5614980

>>5614964
>being dumb enough to fall for straight-RPGs

>> No.5615014

>>5614980
you're not very good at this

>> No.5615016

>>5614846
and the right is for emo prebuscent fags, so not an argument.

>> No.5615025

>>5615014
>can't into timing and reflexes
>calls others not good

Cringe and soipilled

>> No.5615038
File: 470 KB, 1024x896, Tyson_PunchOut-1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5615038

>>5615025
I can beat plenty of reflex-oriented games dumbass. My favorite is Dark Souls but it's not the hardest.
None of that changes the undeniable fact that (1) Ocarina is for babies (2) you are too dumb to understand Final Fantasy, which is really embarrassing.

>> No.5615043

yeah I played ff7 in 1999 in my cabin in the woods. My dad beat me with his belt for playing too much inside, but I helped him chop wood and carry water (we didnt have inlaid water at that time) every day, and also wash the dishes and cut the grass. I also cleaned the roof tiles of growths and painted the terrace. He allowed me to play then anyway.

God damn that game was fucking good. Definitely worth the work and the beatings. Unlike zelda kek thats zoomershit. You zoomers dont even know how to chop wood do you? laughable

>> No.5615045

>>5615038
>>5615038
>My favorite is Dark Souls but it's not the hardest.
Bet your ass it's not the hardest.
lol you can't beat your pic related.
You can't enjoy OoT-LoL

>> No.5615046

>>5614276
debate of what? they're not even the best games of their series

>> No.5615048

>>5615046
>they're not even the best games of their series
Not sure on FF, but it is true for Zelda; OoT is the peak.

>> No.5615051

Both games are great in their own unique way, and contesting them is the stupidest thing in the world.

>> No.5615069

>>5615045
You prove your idiocy with each post.

>> No.5615078

>>5615069
Everyone already knew you were seething, you don't have to overdo it.

>> No.5615079

>>5615051
What I was going to post. I don't know why people feel the need to compare two completely different games. I had both an N64 and a PSX (and a Saturn) so I got to play all the good games.

>> No.5615081

golden eye started the "ironsights" zoomed in aiming

resident evil did tank controls, and made "adventure" games more than just point and click.
ff vII was lauded at the start becuase of graphics and story
zelda was good becuase of lock on controls.
you like both of these becuase the biggest things the accomplished was in their art direction, and you think they should be lauded for revolutionizing the industry.
is your zoomer brain so adhd ritanlined up and fed too many remakes and super hero movies? becuase both of these games are sequels in a franchise. how much of a corporate cuck are you really?

>> No.5615085

>>5614425
>Ocarina: 12 and under
you are so fucking stupid

>> No.5615090

>>5615016
>>5615085
Seething holy shit

>> No.5615092

>>5615085
Ocarina is designed for little kids. It doesn't mean you can't enjoy it. If you're offended by my words you might have some insecurities to sort out.
Same with Final Fantasy 7. It's heavily aimed at teenagers, a lot like marvel capeshit.

>> No.5615115

>>5614448
Dragon Force came out in 1996. Try to keep it between 97-98.

>> No.5615123

>>5615090
you're not pointing to the same person you desperate cunt

>> No.5615170

FF VII is baby's first JRPG. Western kids weren't used to long games focusing on story and characters and it certainly helped that it had at the time cutting edge graphics and presentation.

The only problem is that the story is a clusterfuck that doesn't really make any sense and half of the cast is optional. Also outside of those pointless minigames FF VII plays like a regular 2D Final Fantasy but with fancier backgrounds. The reason it made such a fuss was because westerners weren't familiar with japanese RPGs.

>> No.5615212
File: 25 KB, 540x309, 1559062153987.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5615212

>>5614276
Looks like you made a mistake OP, don't worry I'll help you out.

>> No.5615216

>>5615212
t. seething Pi-let

>> No.5615405

>>5614276
They were both downgrades to other games in their series, but beloved by a lot of people because it was their first introduction to the series.

Also, am I the only one who gets turned off when a game recycles the soundtrack and SFX from its predecessors (which both of these games do heavily)?

>> No.5615490

>>5615405
>recycles the soundtrack and SFX from its predecessors (which both of these games do heavily)?
No. Certainly not in these cases. In fact I don't think it's proper at all to call any of it recycled in the first place.
The fuck are you talking about? There are literally 2 previously used tunes in the entire 4-hour FF7 soundtrack. One is called "The Final Fantasy Prelude" and the other is "The Final Fantasy Theme." Both are new arrangements. I don't think any sound effects are reused.

>> No.5615516

>>5615212
Based.

>> No.5615771
File: 88 KB, 640x424, ad7ebb83a8fd64f8c9ae71c95e4158d81347051365_full.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5615771

>>5614846
This. Zelda sucks ass I can never finish oot it's so damn boring yet I've beaten ff7 many times

Better music
Better gameplay
Story
Graphics
You get the idea

Plus it had the fucking ad of all time, eternally BTFO Nintendo forever. Pic related

>> No.5615782
File: 122 KB, 1200x811, DmgXWBLVsAAEo-P.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5615782

>>5615771
I can't seem to find a better quality version of that pic but at the bottom it says something about how it would take a shitload of cartridges to fit ffvii

>> No.5615864

>>5615782
"Possibly the greatest game ever made is available only on PlayStation. Good thing. If it were available on cartridge, it'd retail for around $1200."

>> No.5615879
File: 114 KB, 800x441, Gold.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5615879

>>5614276
Both of them suck. Give me gold box D&D games any time.

>> No.5615885

>>5615879
Great artwork.

>> No.5615910

>>5615885
Yes, back in the days of real RPGs, not Nintendo and Square faggotry.

>> No.5615924

>>5614276
Is there like a book or YT video that breaks down every Millenial video game debate over the past two decades? There are suddenly a million threads here devoted to this.

>> No.5615951

>>5615864
That's it. Holy shit what a Savage ad. Plus it used to have commercials during prime time American television.

>> No.5616058

>>5614339
Zoomers were born in the late 90's you dumb fuck.

>> No.5616072

>>5615771
but cartridges last longer than cds

>> No.5616085

One is a video game. The other is an interactive story where you press "X" to continue.

>> No.5616094
File: 130 KB, 336x792, 1532192762122.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5616094

Ocarina of Time

but PS1 had Alundra

and Alundra is way better than Ocarina of Time

>> No.5616646

>>5614276
This hread is full of cringy snoy zoomers faggots saying that a pseudo rpg movie anime is better than the glorious OoT. This only proves how bluepilled this board is, I mean you don't even have to play with FF7, is just a movie with excel tier combat. Disgusting.

>> No.5616653
File: 25 KB, 320x311, mm_legends_ps1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5616653

>>5614276

>> No.5616656

Is this thread real? I can't believe vr has fallen so far, are you all really just a bunch of teenagers pretending to be old now?

>> No.5616668

>>5614419
too samey? like jarpig evil church gay elf god killer quest?

>> No.5616691

>>5614276
FF7 easily.

>> No.5616874

Different fucking games. A better debate would be OoT vs LttP and FF7 vs FF6

>> No.5616880

>>5616653
I loved Mega Man and I've never enjoyed this game.

>> No.5616887

>>5614276
OOT isn't even the best game on N64 despite most thinking it to be. SM64 was the real best N64 game.

FFVII for me. Felt much more epic, has better characters, the music is best I've heard in gaming, materia is really cool. Probably PS1's best game.

I do like OOT a lot though. For its time it gave a level of freedom in 3D we really didn't see in games at the time. It was a great adventure game with fun dungeons, memorable pretty much everything. Would say it is second best game for the console.

>> No.5616895

>>5616653
This ends the thread

>> No.5616908
File: 1.03 MB, 4096x2816, loz_dungeons.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5616908

>>5616646
best zelda game by far

>> No.5617083

>>5614276
Ultima Underworld

>> No.5617431

>>5614276
Zay roo duh no den set soo toe key no oh ka reeeeeee nuh.

>> No.5617538

>>5614276
FF7 is better

>> No.5617543

>>5615170
cope

>> No.5617552

FF7 severely outclasses OOT

Final Fantasy 7
>Has a brand new remake coming because of how demanded it is
>Among the most anticipated games of all time with HL3 and the new TES
>Tons of spinoffs and expansions to the story
>Sold 11,000,000 units
>Games dick was so big they couldnt fit it on one disc fucking had THREE
>Had one of the greatest stories with twists and turns and took players on the journey of a lifetime, with themes of environmentalism, terrorism, government, betrayl, megalomania and friendship
>Had some of the greatest music of all time
>A lovable cast full of unforgettable characters with charming dialogue and interactions
>Has not one not two but FOUR amazing waifus
>One of the best paced JRPGs of all time always keeping things refreshing

Ocarina of Time
>Legacy is a soulless remake locked to an obsolete handheld
>Outclassed by Majoras Mask in terms of worldbuilding, gameplay, music, and graphics
>Only sold 7.6 million copies
>Story is hollow and as bare as can be
>Notorious for its awful ingame cutscenes and 20fps stuttery gameplay
>No FMVs, cheap MIDI tunes
>Water temple
>HEY HEY LISTEN
>Gameplay is often obtuse and requires trial and error breaking immersion
>Poor pacing, middle is a slog to play through

And yes FF7 is the best FF along with 6 and 10

>> No.5617578

>>5614279
DOS-ROMs can't handle.

>> No.5617584

>>5615016
this post is proof you didnt play FFVII so you dont even get an opinion

>> No.5617594
File: 56 KB, 355x355, goeOST.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5617594

>>5616653
*blocks your path*

>> No.5617598

>>5614835
Good thing they're not

>> No.5617608

>>5614898
>wait-your-turn nonsense
You must be talking about OoT enemy "AI"

>> No.5617613

>>5614430
Shining the Holy Ark

>> No.5619186

>>5614276
Both of them fucking Suck.

>> No.5621492

>>5614276
both are kino

>> No.5621521

>>5614276
zelda obviously

FFVII isn't even the best FF

>> No.5621659

>>5621521
Yes it is and its better than copearina of time

>> No.5621714

>>5614276
7 for feels
Oot for gameplay

>> No.5623403
File: 120 KB, 1000x1000, 1549846615957.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5623403

Ocarina>>>>>>Final Fantasy

>> No.5623437

>>5614276
Both have way better follow up games (8, Majora).

>> No.5623480

For me, it's DOOM.

>> No.5623497

>>5617584
wrong; played it years ago and discussed it on the internet a long time. the fanbase is mostly that, still is, always will be.

>> No.5623517

>>5614276
ff7 is the best one of the 90s, but not even close to the best game of all time which is sekiro, but we cant discuss this one here

>> No.5626549

>>5616880
I will never understand this. How can fans of MegaMan not love the absolute fuck out of Legends?

>> No.5626558

>>5623517
>Sekiro
>best game of all time

Very bold, but you may be onto something there, anon.

>> No.5626962

>>5614276
Only redditors think either of those games are remotely deserving of being called "greatest of all time".

>> No.5627135

>>5614276
>outclassed by MM and literally every 2D Zelda
vs
>outclassed by IV, VI and IX
really makes me think

>> No.5627163
File: 201 KB, 560x495, 1534537585.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5627163

>>5627135
>he liked furry faggotry 9
leave your opinions in the trash where they belong

>> No.5627169

>>5627163
>not liking IX
are you unironically a nigger?

>> No.5627171

>>5627163
Other than Freya, what are the other "furry characters?" Final Fantasy IX forgets about the rats as soon as they are introduced. Zidane has a monkey tail, but that is as furry as Son Goku in OG Dragon Ball.

>> No.5627271

>>5614276
Is this the thread where we pretend it was 2007?

>> No.5628067
File: 182 KB, 1011x769, Zelda equipment.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5628067

>>5614276
ff6 was the clear winner of ff's when it came to game of the year awards and "best game ever" lists, so it ought to be ocarina vs ff6

I loved ff7 as a preteen. I like lttp and oot thematically, but I just can't get with the gameplay of zelda games; never could. I couldn't get through ff6 either; everything about it was distasteful for me.

I've seen a LOT more people claim that oot is the greatest game ever than ff7, or any other particular game even.

>> No.5628206

>>5615048
Not even the best Zelda game on the console

>> No.5628372

They were only really considered best games of all time shortly after they came out. After that sure, they're on top of lists nobody gives a flying fuck about. Since then dozens of games that are considered by many as "best game of all time" came out. Also, many older good titles were more widely available. FFVII and OOT have both unique "atmospheres" that make them stand out. I feel both are great games and I'll never say they're not good, but they cannot be the "best games of all time".

Let's start with FFVII. The setting is kinda unique, though it merges with the fantasy setting from other previous entries. However the writing is not that good compared to even other Squaresoft RPGs of the time. The most memorable parts about it fit the first disc for the most part. The materia system is also fairly flawed, and something that I found a bit irritating (though I admit that's down to preference) is how party members aren't that unique in their abilities. I like the approach from the new threat mod and I feel that's what they should have done, make some characters more suitable than others for certain roles.

About OoT, it's more cinematic and slow than it needed to be. It's also a bit more linear than I would have liked (without sequence breaking). I understand it's a more modern Zelda game, but ALTTP at least pretended to be a bit more open.

>> No.5628409

>>5627171
>calling the hero zidane because of the world cup

>> No.5628434

>>5628409
He was called Djidane in the French version, Yítan in the Spanish version, and Gidan in the Italian version. It is weird they called him Zidane after the soccer player when soccer is not that popular in the USA.

>> No.5628446

>>5614276
>Hey guys, which one of these dog logs smells better?

>> No.5628814

>>5614276
FFVII

>> No.5628893

>>5617552
I can smell that you are a weeb from miles away. The typical majoras mask fag with a passion for "Le unpopular opinion". Every fucking time. I swear.
I get that it had balls with the 3 day system but come one... everything felt so restricted and short compared to Ocarina.

Go ahead and try to pretend that the weeb story in FF7 is deep but the gameplay is still a shitty menu battle. Boring to the bones, made for kids with autism.

>> No.5628896
File: 37 KB, 3000x3000, ugag.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5628896

>>5614276
ugag

>> No.5628905

>>5614279
Starcraft. Half-life is overrated as fuck.

>> No.5629439

>>5628905
Kys

>> No.5629456

>>5615516
Based on what?

>> No.5629759

>>5628896
what does that post mean?

>> No.5630160
File: 46 KB, 619x453, A518FFAB-2EE3-4381-8948-86D9BED4C081.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
5630160

>mfw I beat oot again yesterday
I’m 30 and still like playing oot, I had no idea people hated it this much. I never played any of the final fantasy games, is this the best one to start the franchise or ff2/3?

>> No.5630170

>>5614279
I'd say Deus Ex

>> No.5630182

>>5630160
FF9 is designed as a back-to-basics sendoff for the series with a ton of small references to the early games, but I actually recommend starting there. It's really solid, and doesn't require any prior knowledge to enjoy. The references work just as well the other way around so the visual similarities between characters and classic sprites might help you click with the earlier barebones entries. It has the most final fantasy tropes in the series and the story takes you on a ride.

>> No.5630276

>>5630182
Thank you anon, I’ll start it tomorrow

>> No.5630495

>>5614276
One is an action-adventure game and the other is a (nearly) turn-based JRPG, so I really don't think a direct comparison is possible. But if I had to say, I guess FF7 is a better example of its genre than OoT is just because it still stands out today. OoT still a lot of fun, it's just been outdone in every way I can think of. Meanwhile, FF7 is still pretty high up there in terms of atmosphere and characters, and the Materia system is a lot of fun. The only problem is it's too fucking easy, but OoT suffers from that too.

>>5614419
A lot of games from every platform, from every era don't stand out and have never stood out. A majority of them, actually.

>> No.5630524

>>5630160
Try FF4 (any version before DS) and either PS1 or GBA FF1.