[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature

View post   
File: 148 KB, 943x761, Screenshot_20240306_014700_Brave.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
23151125 No.23151125[DELETED]  [Reply] [Original]

Which one of them was right?

>> No.23151130

All of them in different ways. /thread

>> No.23151141
File: 390 KB, 1125x1319, TheOneAmongTheMany.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
23151141

>>23151125
>>23151130

>> No.23151145

>>23151141
Oh, you're the Kant NEET who's barely literate. Thanks for making an appearance.

>> No.23151190

>>23151125
Socrates/Wittgenstein dichotomy

>> No.23151214

>>23151125
None, because I know they know nothing

>> No.23151220

>>23151125
Hegel

>> No.23151232

>>23151125
They're all wrong but Ari moms

>> No.23151234

the three above.. were not in the same league as Pythagoras.

>> No.23151256

Serious question: which of them were really fags/pedophiles?
To me, there words would be blemished, if not completely dismissed, if I knew that they were pedophiles.
But how do we know if the accusations against them were slander or not?

>> No.23151263

>>23151125
Heraclitus clears all other Greeks.

>> No.23151327

>>23151125
Ultimately, none of them. If only they had kneeled to the great prince of Samos and properly interpreted the Goddess' words as describing reality as a solitary and perfect metaphysical entity.

>> No.23151336

Pyrrho, obviously.

>> No.23151342

>>23151125
All in agreement actually

>> No.23151346

>>23151256
>which of them were really fags/pedophiles
None of them. The whole "ancient greeks were gay" thing is a modern psyop

>> No.23151522
File: 232 KB, 1400x930, 1 -tJbk2tZukl89oV5O4HrNA.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
23151522

>>23151256
>which of them were really fags/pedophiles?
Plato
>>23151346
This. It's not gay to just have some sex with your bros

>> No.23152465

>>23151256
>>23151522
https://youtu.be/BNAT4ybsz_E?si=NCE2D7YqGfHtrBto

>> No.23152489
File: 40 KB, 640x599, e0gatc8h5td41.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
23152489

>>23151125
Diogenes

>> No.23152496

>>23152489
The virgin Socratic dialogue Oeconimicus (on household management) vs the chad pithy Diogenes quote about spitting on rich people

>> No.23152541

>>23151125
Parminides.

>> No.23152544

>>23151125
Anaxagoras.

>> No.23152547

>>23151125
None of those 3.
They are the most popular, but they are actually bad compared to the other lesser know greeks like Heracitus, etc....

>> No.23152549

>>23152544
Tell me again how the sun is the size of the Peloponnesus and how it is made out of stone.

>> No.23152550

>>23152549
I mean his thoughts on the Aperion not that.

>> No.23152553

>>23152549
Oh, wait, i see where the error is.
I meant Anaximander not Anaxagoras,i got the wrong philosopher.
Sorry.

>> No.23152554

>>23151125
Name their album

>> No.23152556

plotin

>> No.23152562

>>23152465
what are this guys' qualifications? seems like just another yank confidently talking about things he knows little

>> No.23152566

>>23152553
Anaxagoras was actually a philosopher too, just not much of a good one. Socrates mocks his philosophy of the Nous in the dialogue Phaedo and Hippocrates subtly rehashes these insults without naming Anaxagoras in On Ancient Medicine.

>> No.23152568

>>23152562
He actually read the sources, though.
So i recommend you watch that video.
It's good.

>> No.23152572

>>23152566
Imagine being mocked by Socrates himself.
Lol.
I feel bad for him.

>> No.23152573

>>23151125
Socrates, the reddit forefather.
>Uhmm do you have a source for your claims :^)

>> No.23152586

The one who's oracle is in Delphi neither reveals or hides, but signifies.

>> No.23152588

>>23152566
Also, claiming that the sun is the size of the Peloponnese and it is made out of stone, is not that bad of a claim all things considered.
Specially for the time.
But, yeah, it's bad, compared to the other, better more accurate in retrospective claims.

>> No.23152592

>>23152588
Yeah I actually agree. I was a being a pedantic dweeb trying to be silly.

>> No.23152597

>>23151125
Thales of Miletus.

>> No.23152599

>>23152568
yes it seems fine. my only problem is that his perception of how ancient greek society is viewed within academia seems to be entirely drawn from youtube and shoddy american newspapers. fair enough if his aim is to dismantle certain misconceptions present in the mainstream, but his implication that any serious academic genuinely believes "all greeks were gay" is absurd

>> No.23152610 [DELETED] 

.

>> No.23152981

>>23151522
>>Plato
>t: haven't read Plato

>> No.23154513

>>23152981
christ kike cope

>> No.23154525

>>23152981
Yes but he read Diogenes Laertius.

>> No.23154711

>>23152981
Symposium moment

>> No.23154930

>>23154711
And Lysis and the Charmides and Rival Lovers

>> No.23154961

>>23151125
Define "right".

>> No.23156257

>>23152573
he didnt say that

>> No.23156721

>>23151256
None of them. Plato, for instance, told in Laws and in Republic how the only valid relationship was between a man and a woman.

Also
>there words

>> No.23157447

about what ?