[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature

View post   
File: 911 KB, 1242x1413, 0B0A5C04-61C1-4623-93E5-EB59A4F6ADE6.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17253010 No.17253010 [Reply] [Original]

Why does music effect me more than any book has?

>> No.17253011

Because music is more sensory, making it easier to hijack your emotional response

>> No.17253014

>>17253010
Because you are dumb.

>> No.17253015

>>17253010
low IQ

>> No.17253020

>>17253010
please dont post beautiful women here, it will make me wish to kill myself out of deprivation

>> No.17253022

>>17253010
Because good music (the kind where people play actual instruments) is a far superior way to express emotions

>> No.17253026

>>17253010
Because you are probably reading poetry wrong. I used to do that.

>> No.17253035

>>17253020
>OP
>beautiful
Topkek

>> No.17253036

>>17253010
You are young.

>> No.17253046
File: 141 KB, 700x510, Stockhausen_03-5NNM.Oe8NWWdGWc3hYPhTFta0sBgEXnC.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17253046

>>17253022
>(the kind where people play actual instruments)
Faggot detected.

>> No.17253054

>>17253010
Because you're an underage zoomer born past 1999 who was brought into a world overloaded with information making it an equivalent of a massive microwave turning your brain into scrambled eggs, you lack the attention span to sit down and read a book, hell you probably don't even listen to songs in their entirety, you just choose the parts you like and play them on loop. All of this has been me projecting my past self onto (You) BTW

>> No.17253063

forms of art effect us differently. music is much more immediate, much more visceral. a song will make you cry, it will evoke powerful feelings and evoke them quickly. but as quickly as they come, they go.

books rather, leave something in you that isn't immediate. you might carry a book around in your heart for a month after reading it. it touches you in a different way than more sensory things (music, film, etc) might. this doesn't make any form of art better or worse than another. they achieve different things and for that reason you should have a breadth of artistic interests.

>> No.17253071

>>17253011
>hijack
Enhance

>>17253020
>deprive me
>so as to not remind me of being deprived
You are confused

>> No.17253080

>>17253071
Don't quote me tranny

>> No.17253146

>>17253063
Cope

>> No.17253155

>>17253063
WisdomPilled. This anon gets it.

>> No.17253229

>>17253010
because you're a pleb.

>> No.17253291

>>17253063
>forms of art effect us differently. music is much more immediate, much more visceral. a song will make you cry, it will evoke powerful feelings and evoke them quickly. but as quickly as they come, they go.

i came here to say this. its basically just a fast/short term versus slow/long term issue

>> No.17253404

>>17253020
buttchin, wow low standards

Older music styles have a transcendent aspect. Even if you don't believe in god they can incite oceanic feels.
Rap and hip-hop are trash.

>> No.17253449

>>17253404
Music is for evocation. Hip hop, rap, jazz, etc., are for conjuring up a place and feeling some don’t like to inhabit

Oceanic feelings can still be incited
https://youtu.be/saVe-kYCYCs

>> No.17253627

>>17253010
What ethnicity is that girl? I can't tell if she's a Castizo Hispanic or just a southern Italian.

>> No.17253652

>>17253627
Makeup, anon. She could even be a middle aged man as far as it goes.

>> No.17253662

>>17253010
Her sister is hotter and no, it's not pedophilia but ephebophilia.

>> No.17253706

>>17253404
Playboi Carti's self-titled mixtape has given me similar transcendent feelings to those I find in Josquin, Ockeghem and Palestrina. You're not listening to good rap.

>> No.17253708

>>17253010
I've seen some very realistic deep fakes of pic rel

>> No.17253914

>>17253652
Well can you tell me what ethnicity that middle aged man is? Is he Italian or a mix of Southern European and indigenous American? I need to know whether or not I'm allowed to be attracted.

>> No.17254055

>>17253010
>>17253020
That’s a man.

>> No.17254097
File: 432 KB, 2560x800, cropped-42733958121_b5940acebe_o-2.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17254097

>>17253010
Gosh, she is stunning. I want to pump her with my seed a thousand times. I'm such a sucker for the Mediterranean/MENA look. I just want to fuck her mouth till her eyes are red and watery. Why am I not doing this right now? How do I meet this girl irl?

>> No.17254103

>>17253010
>effect me
This is a literary board, anon. Please proofread your posts.

>> No.17254117

>>17253706
This is what this guy is referring to for reference
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oCveByMXd_0

>> No.17254135

>>17253010
Probably because you don't know the difference between "affect" and "effect"

>> No.17254301

>>17253063
I don't know. I listen to far more music than I have read books and watched films and the only medium that has both come close to/made me cry is literature and other written things. Words, sentences and paragraphs arranged in all orders leaves something both immediate and long term and with the readers imagination allows them to picture anything, far more than any other medium we have access to. Music is playing with something extremely abstract and beyond and its hard to understand but it is certainly a marvel to behold. Music gives me frisson and boosts of morale as if I were seeing through a mirror into the other side, but it doesn't really meddle with my emotions and I don't think it's as instant as you make it out to be.

>> No.17254404

>>17253011
came here to post this, music is better at manipulating emotions and you're confusing that with effecting you more than a good book

>> No.17254753

>>17253010
I hope she is a fascist who gets married and makes many babies (at least 5) for the glory of Italy and because it personally makes her happy.

>> No.17254763
File: 33 KB, 500x520, t6n7v1tzfw751.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17254763

>>17253010
seek help coomer

>> No.17254765

>>17254753
She’s a fake Italian

>> No.17254773

>>17253035
She is extremely beautiful IMO

>> No.17254790

>>17253914
KEK you can be attracted, it is just a photograph, anon. It doesn't make you gay.

>> No.17254792

>>17254765
What is she actually then? Argentine Italians aren't fake, just off-brand, if that's what you're trying to say.

>> No.17254798

>>17253010
Castizo Futurism NOW

>> No.17254803

>>17254792
She’s literally just American pretending to have Italian heritage

>> No.17254829

>>17254803
Do you think americans sprang out of the ether? There are a ton of Italians in America

>> No.17254840

>>17254829
She has literally zero roots to Italy, you fucking retard. Stop simping for a braindead moron

>> No.17254847

>>17254840
I don't even know who this is

>> No.17254852

>>17254847
Okay, braindead sooner. Go scroll tiktok

>> No.17254869

>>17254803
What is her heritage then? Is it a stage name or something?

>> No.17254891

>>17254869
She’s just American. Just a retarded last name.

>> No.17254903

>>17253010
Because you haven't read the right book yet. But keep reading; eventually you will.

>> No.17254904

>>17254891
Ok, so she is of Italian descent then. Whatever, I still want her to have 5 children because she's pretty and I want the world to be prettier. Positive eugenics is the way forward.

>> No.17255742

>>17253010
because music is more temporally present than written words- you can not go forwards and backwards in music like you can literature, which is a part of what gives music such a sensuous nature compared to lit (t. kirkegaard)

>> No.17255955
File: 6 KB, 240x240, 1602563051253.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17255955

>effect
stick to music OP

>> No.17255988

>>17253010
Its the highest tier of art, obviously

>> No.17256082

>>17253010
because u skim when u read

>> No.17256090

>>17253449
isn't all of it escapism for money and profit? stimuli just for stimulation?

>> No.17256095

Read Kant's Third Critique. He says that highest form of art is poetry and then music.

>> No.17256098

>>17253010
*affect, hang yourself you smoothbrained oxygen thief

>> No.17256310

>>17256090
Not originally. Money corrupts everything, but the musician will still play and compose in a post-capitalist world

>> No.17256472

>>17253035
nigger faggot

>> No.17256486

>>17254135
came here to say this

>> No.17256509

>>17254135
Oh yes gold upvote!

>> No.17256989

>>17253046
Those are instruments, not some faggot making beats in fl studio

>> No.17257002

>>17253706
Did some youtube "critic" told you think that? The only reason his album is getting hyoed is because trap as a genre is so dead that his music seems interesting by comparison. Once the next genre to kill trap comes along in the next few coming years, WLR will be forgotten.

>> No.17257031

>>17254852
You seem like the one addicted to immediate gratification. You can't even proofread a shitpost that only has five words, you're just racing to hit the Post button.

>> No.17257039

>>17257031
Did that belittling elevate you enough to give your hit of instant gratification?

>> No.17257050

>>17256090
There are plenty of musicians who make very little money off of their music to the extent that it can be regarded as a passion project since they still need a day job to pay their bills. Stop listening to Sony Music Productions(tm).

>> No.17257058
File: 183 KB, 771x804, 1607306404495.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
17257058

>>17257039

>> No.17258494

First thing that came to mind was Chapter III in Portrait of the Artist, second was the end of The Dead, I haven't read Ulysses properly but judging by my impression of e.g. the final page I'm sure it has several of these moments as well

>> No.17258545

There is perhaps nothing more pleasant than listening to Prokofiev or Shostakovich while reading Dostoevsky. The emotional tone of the music heightens the experience of his writing.