[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature

View post   
File: 351 KB, 1754x2560, 81vfRPFWMtL.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14421518 No.14421518 [Reply] [Original]

Why did he strawman Hume so he could shoehorn in his antiquated Aristotelian-Retardism? Is this the power of the Catholic intellect? Imagine believing in final causes because you've been spooked by social constructs lmao. The final cause of the phone is only to call someone because we socially constructed that concept, not because of any dated concept of causation.

>> No.14421652

>>14421518
>The final cause of the phone is only to call someone because we socially constructed that concept, not because of any dated concept of causation.

lol what?

you're the retard

>> No.14421666

>>14421652
Stupid post. You're stupid. Not an argument. You don't need to appeal to essence to explain the final cause of something. Essence itself is subjective.

>> No.14421692

>>14421666
satanic trips

i rest my case

>> No.14421881

I will remind /lit/ every day that the early moderns refuted Aristotelianism until /lit/ stops being Christian. Read Hume

>> No.14421892

>>14421881
why should someone read Hume? and where does one start? you must realize you sound like a retarded 19yo telling people to "read theory."

>> No.14422155

>>14421892
So that they can break free of archaic systems. Read Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion and An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding

>> No.14423028

Read Hume

>> No.14423194

>>14421518
Feser is not a good catholic intellectual. There are plenty of others

>> No.14423335

>>14423194
Why isn't he good? Who's better?

>> No.14423857

>>14423335
this

>> No.14423870

>>14421881
Christianity began without Aristotelianism , and can live without Aristotelianism.

>> No.14424122

>>14421518
>The Last Superstition: A Refutation Of The New Atheism
Sounds like he strawman'd more than just Hume.
>>14421881
Aristotelianism is anti-christian.

>> No.14424179

>>14423870
>>14424122
The ultimate redpill is realizing that Aquinas is right even if Aristotle is wrong.

>> No.14424357

>>14424179
>Aquinas is right even if Aristotle is wrong
Literally what could you possibly mean by this? If Aristotle is wrong then Thomism collapses

>> No.14424843

Read Hume! Christianity is dead!