[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature

View post   
File: 881 KB, 1700x2151, Hegel_by_Schlesinger.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14212042 No.14212042 [Reply] [Original]

Hegel philosophy is not based, as hegelians would have you believe, on rational logical process.

Rather, so called "Hegelian Dialectic" is a manipulation, a vile corruption, of logic and the socratic method. Hegel's entire metaphysics and phenomenology is based upon semi-spiritual conjecture and mysticism - Hegel is representative of the corruptive influence of catholic philosophy on the general character of western thought.

Hegel's nigh religious interpretation of the kantian noumena leaves a stain on western philosophy, a stain that was not to be removed until the development of logical empiricism in the early 20th century.

Fuck Hegel.

>> No.14212047

>>14212042
Hegel was reckless.

>> No.14212057
File: 965 KB, 279x279, tumblr_inline_o3xeytJUSA1tm4oog_500_cropped.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14212057

>>14212042
>hegel
>catholic
retard

>> No.14212081

Hegel is awesome

>> No.14212191

>>14212042
>Hegel philosophy is [...] based [...]
yes

>> No.14212229

>>14212042
>Hegel philosophy is not based
wrong

>> No.14212492
File: 11 KB, 265x190, 53252343.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14212492

>>14212042
>a stain that was not to be removed until the development of logical empiricism in the early 20th century

>> No.14212540

>>14212042
>Hegel philosophy is not based
Correct

>> No.14213221

>>14212191
Kek

>> No.14213291
File: 195 KB, 430x582, wyeo1j1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14213291

>>14212042
There are two kinds of people:
The ones who actually read Hegel.
And those who make threads about him.

>> No.14213303

I think he makes up terms as he goes. I can't understand him. It might be because i'm reading it like a normal book, but the way he talks seems like h'es bullshitting.

>> No.14213326

>>14213303
Most of his terms are normal German words or compositions of such. Often he insists upon original meanings and etymology, which only makes one wonder how based the not-so-awful German language really is.

>> No.14213347

>>14213326
Actually 99% of his terminology comes from Aristotle, St. Thomas, Kant, Fichte and Schelling, scholastic jargon was still the standard in his times.
The guy you're responding to must have never read any of these philosophers>>14213326

>> No.14213377
File: 59 KB, 640x640, bcc5ad31fff441d14b652383c10137e8.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14213377

>Kantians are still upset that Hegel stole the philosophical show
Stop posting and go think about some stuff that exists but that you can't technically ever experience or something

>> No.14213802

>>14212042
>Hegel is representative of the corruptive influence of catholic philosophy on the general character of western thought.
Catholic hegel, even catholic influence on him, sure. Wait, what?
>the development of logical empiricism in the early 20th century.
Hegel was btfo on that front by Bolzano. Logical empiricism is just as trash as Hegel.

>> No.14213826

>>14212042
>Hegel's entire metaphysics and phenomenology is based upon semi-spiritual conjecture and mysticism
sounds more based than it actually is

>> No.14213845

>>14213291
this
t. tha latter

>> No.14213866

>>14212042
>Rather, so called "Hegelian Dialectic" is a manipulation, a vile corruption
Uh, ok Schopenhauer. Tells us more.

>catholic philosophy
Stopped reading. Disregard everything else OP wrote.

Move along boys. Nothing to see here.

>> No.14213875

Is the end point of his philosophy, a singularity?

>> No.14213886
File: 127 KB, 782x758, BBDB505F-F119-48A1-850F-14F2395A6A2D.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14213886

>>14212042
>the corruptive influence of catholic philosophy on the general character of western thought

>> No.14214672

>>14213826
It isn't, he was a fanboy of rosacrucians.

>> No.14214706

>>14213875
Why do you believe in endpoints?

>> No.14215203
File: 29 KB, 720x540, nochin.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14215203

>>14212042
>a stain that was not to be removed until the development of logical empiricism in the early 20th century.

>> No.14215210

>>14213377
based

>> No.14215313

>>14212042
Lucky me there was logical empiricism to save me from Hegel. Now my life is full of happiness and meaning.

>> No.14215360

congratulations. ok now tell that to millions and billions of people born into it unknowingly.

>> No.14215480

>>14213291
I've read one of his works and never made a thread about him, so this checks out.

>> No.14216738

>>14212042
>semi-spiritual conjecture and mysticism -
Whats wrong with this though

>> No.14216765
File: 50 KB, 244x262, silven.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14216765

>>14212042

>some boomer presents their unprovable "metaphysical system" episode number 9001

>> No.14216957

>>14212042
OP here.

To clarify my claim about catholic influence on Hegel:

Catholic obsession with virtue, contrary to the rational virtue of plato and aristotle, is obsessively focused around the veneration and imitation of Christ. This Christ-worship, which inevitably entails collectivism, is extremely influential in Hegel's metaphysics, as well as his examinations of art and other cultural phenomena. Hegel's philosophy presents itself as religion - although Hegelian philosophy stems from assertions made be earlier, more legitimate philosophers such as Kant, Hegel nevertheless succumbs to christian spiritualism, which, in a noumenonic sense, is monolithic and irrefutable.

>> No.14217652

>>14216957
why is it hard for you to say protestant