[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 179 KB, 1163x1080, ContraPoints_(cropped).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177318 No.13177318[DELETED]  [Reply] [Original]

How is Natalie so well read?

>> No.13177329

an education

>> No.13177332

>>13177318
Who is Natalie?

>> No.13177334

>>13177318
He's not.

>> No.13177336

he's not, he did an MA at a state school in philosophy and dropped out after a bit of coursework. he barely knows anything and you can tell.

>> No.13177354

>>13177318
>beauty is a social construct
Welcome to the bleeding-edge of leftist philosophical inquiry. We had to become very very well read to reach this veritable pinnacle of human thought.

>> No.13177356

>>13177318

reminder that this youtube tranny reads Hegel in the original German and you can't even into an intro to Hegel youtube video

>> No.13177367

>>13177318
He isn't, its easy to seem well read and understand what you're talking about when your user base is a bunch of retarded tranny tankies and you have as much time as you want to prepare the content for them.

>> No.13177371

>>13177367
Natalie has denounced tankies

>> No.13177372

>>13177318
I wish we could put all these mentally ill freaks in internment camps so I don't have to accidentally look at their horrendous face when a faggot like OP posts them here

>> No.13177373

>>13177318
Because he/she probably doesnt spend all their time commentating on YouTube trannies on 4chan.

Fucking Neet faggot

>> No.13177377

>>13177336
She was an adjunct philosophy professor working on her PhD when she dropped out

>> No.13177380

>>13177371
All these far leftists types have secret inclinations towards communism.

>> No.13177382

>>13177334
>>13177336
>>13177367
>>13177373
>he

>> No.13177383
File: 957 KB, 1088x569, 1558749527212.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177383

>>13177372
Stop being a bigot

>> No.13177389

she just had plastic surgery and shes looking great

>> No.13177393

>>13177382
Genital mutilation and hormones don't change your sex.

>> No.13177394

He's well read, you can see his copy of grammatology in his videos. You have to be really smart to peruse Derrida.

>> No.13177396

>>13177383
That pic is something else.

>> No.13177397

>>13177318
Who is she

>> No.13177402

>>13177393
pronouns don't refer to biological sex

>> No.13177403

>>13177377
no, he was a TA, not a professor, and an adjunct is not a professor, it's an adjunct. maybe you are thinking of assistant or associate professor, but neither of those are possible pre-PhD either.

being a TA is meaningless. i'm literally a philosophy TA too, are you saying i'm an authority? i'm eating chicken mcnuggets and i'm about to jerk off, you want to see my youtube channel?

>> No.13177410
File: 38 KB, 474x729, 1550785624478.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177410

>>13177382
>chopping off your dick and taking hormone injections makes you a woman

>> No.13177412

>>13177403
sure, link it

>> No.13177413

Who cares about the opinions of a self-mutilator who believes beauty is a social construct.

>> No.13177422

>>13177402
Pronouns are intrinsically interlinked with biological sex.

>> No.13177431

>>13177413
Ummmm sweetie. We don't appreciate bigotry around here.

>> No.13177433
File: 49 KB, 500x489, 1558235094162.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177433

>>13177422

>> No.13177437

>>13177422
>he doesn't even know what gender is

>> No.13177440
File: 69 KB, 645x729, 1550788587728.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177440

>>13177433
>If you choose your dick off that means everyone has to call you a woman

>> No.13177441

>>13177402
Then was is he trying to change something that doesn’t exist.

>> No.13177442

>>13177437
are we really doing this

>> No.13177445

If gender is biological then why would I call someone a she if they aren't actually one?

>> No.13177446 [DELETED] 

>>13177433
>gender identity isn't overwhelming aligned with biological sex

Exceptions are not the rule.

>> No.13177447

Trannys should be thrown in a furnace. Prove me wrong.

>> No.13177448

>>13177433
>>13177437
>gender identity isn't overwhelmingly aligned with biological sex

Exceptions are not the rule.

>> No.13177450
File: 1.56 MB, 288x360, 1556876517305.webm [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177450

>>13177447
How can I prove you wrong when you're right?

>> No.13177454

>>13177446
gender identity traits are arbitrary social constructs. there is nothing intrinsic to possessing a certain set of sex organs and how you present yourself.

>> No.13177458

I love trannies because it's the achilles heel of deranged progressive liberals

They are forced to pretend they agree with trannies because their ideology says they have to countenance every fucking weirdo that comes along, as long as they are "expressing themselves authentically!!!" Nobody likes trannies, it's obvious to everyone that there's something seriously "off" about the whole tranny phenomenon, it's clearly just fags forcing their weird sissification fetishes on everybody, but the college liberals are stuck with them and have to pretend they like it.

Imagine having to pretend to be friends with trannies. They're gross, slimy, narcissistic freaks. Imagine having to pretend to like them a lot. I can think of no worse punishment.

>> No.13177461

>>13177437
>mah gender sophtity
Then why is is trying to change his sex with Drugs and surgery
And why do gender warriors demand things like accesss to female (sexed) showers if gender != sex

>> No.13177467

>>13177454
Cultural norms centered around gender is relative, what isn't is that every society has gender roles based on the biological sex of the person.

>> No.13177468

>>13177450
holy kek

>> No.13177470

>>13177447
If you were mentally ill would you like to be thrown into a furnace, q.e.d bucko.

>> No.13177471
File: 105 KB, 1021x734, 3C28B4B4-EC3D-45A4-87C8-07EB2E99543F.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177471

>>13177318
What is this creature and why does it look like a fucking tranny

>> No.13177475

>>13177413
Self-mutilator is an accurate description of tranny monsters. I use it to describe them ad well

>> No.13177477

>>13177448
>pronouns are based on gender
>gender often correlates with sex
>therefore pronouns should be based on sex
this syllogism would get you an F, it's not even close to being valid

>> No.13177481
File: 496 KB, 686x960, 166FC404-ECEF-4049-9D4B-B35F880D86EC.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177481

>>13177454
Wrong.
Protip=nobody fucking cares if you put on lipstick and wear dresses. THAT WOULD BE CHANGING GENDER FASHION NORMS WHICH ARE SOMEWHAT ARBITRARY
but that is NOT what you do, instead you demand the entire state and government and its people accept you as biologically female, so you can do things like complete in female sports teams .
Pic related, a French king wearing hose and high heels

>> No.13177486

>>13177481
louis XIV was the original tranny

>l'etat c'est moi

oh so everybody has to fucking pretend you're l'etat now?

>> No.13177488

>>13177481
No one is asking anybody to be accepted as biologically female; a trans-woman will not demand to see a gynecologist, they'll go to a urologist.
Do you really think people are transitioning to get a leg up in sports? Is that the big trans agenda?

>> No.13177489

>>13177477
Are you trying to arguing my point for me? Yeah the rule is that gender identity overwhelmingly correlates with biological sex. Just because a few mentally deranged freaks like yourself deviate from it doesn't make it the new "rule". You're an exceptional abomination, and should be treated as such.

>> No.13177493

>>13177481
TBF Louis was considered extremely effeminate in his time, he was an outlier, not a representative of contemporary male fashion

>> No.13177495

>>13177382
sorry 'it's' not

>> No.13177496

>>13177488
Kek, have you ever actually met a tranny? Everything you've described has occurred on numerous occasions

>> No.13177500

>>13177495
She has stated on numerous occasions that her pronouns are she/her. Please do not disrespect her like this. I know you want to be an epic edgy incel because your hiding behind anon, but I think it's time to grow the fuck up.

>> No.13177501

>>13177489
the "rule" is that pronouns are based on gender, not sex. you are basically asking for an expectation for every trans person to be held to a separate standard because gender and sex correlate; but no one is arguing that gender and sex don't corrolate, it's a total non-sequitur.

>> No.13177505

>>13177377
>wahhhhh i dont wanna read hegel hes too difficult and cryptic!!!!!!! also racist btw

>> No.13177508
File: 961 KB, 1000x1000, 1540776466437.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177508

>>13177500
Goddamn fucking commie thought police.
You can have my thoughts when you pry then from my
>Cold
>Dead
>Hands

>> No.13177510
File: 25 KB, 480x480, 4Chan_Meme_Pepe_Laughing_2.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177510

>>13177450
nigga got beat up by a 12 year old

>> No.13177515

I have no inclination to believe she is truly learned. Yea, she read. It doesn't show so much in her videos. Didn't she identify with the YouTube 'skeptic' community? Or did she call those neckbeards something else?
Nobody who knows dick about epistemology would identify as a skeptic in this day, besides extreme idiosyncratics. Certainly not the kind of dilettante 'skepticism' going on in YouTube. She knows what she is talking about, but she doesn't really speak of learned society type shit. Love her rhetoric, you can tell she uses those philosophy gains.
Sad story about her experience in acdemia. Our universities are so backwards.
>Inb4 ">she"
STFU and treat others the way you would like to be treated. Have sex. Try rapprochement, stop being such a fag.

>> No.13177516

>>13177508
>asking someone to be called by their preferred pronouns
>REEEEE JUST LIEK ORWELL SAID GUISE

>> No.13177517
File: 25 KB, 878x219, 60840c7.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177517

Completely normal and not at all a fetish

>> No.13177518

>>13177318

Please stop posting rape-bait on 4chin.

>> No.13177520

>>13177516
>PLEASE CALL ME A WOMAN
>I CUT MY DICK OFF SO THAT MAKES ME A WOMAN!

>> No.13177521

>>13177500
cringe mom poster

>> No.13177527

>>13177501
>the "rule" is that pronouns are based on gender, not sex

Pronouns are based on gender identity which overwhelmingly correlates with biological sex. That is the norm, that is the rule. You're pronouns almost always correlate with your biological sex.

> you are basically asking for an expectation for every trans person to be held to a separate standard because gender and sex correlate

Of course I am, because they are an extremely unusual exception that go against the rule, and so therefore cannot be considered to fit into it. Calling yourself a pronoun that does not correlate with your biological sex, is abnormal and exceptional.

>but no one is arguing that gender and sex don't corrolate, it's a total non-sequitur.

Then you should agree with me.

>> No.13177530
File: 537 KB, 1024x1024, 1550548112954.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177530

>>13177516
If you only knew just how much Orwell was warning us about people like you, you wouldn't be so quick to police the language of others. Go read some actual Marxists, radlib

>> No.13177531
File: 40 KB, 950x461, 78f96cb.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177531

>> No.13177534
File: 35 KB, 500x375, FE717761-3C47-4328-812D-0E1F39F98F2F.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177534

>>13177488
That was just one example of what you actually do
You use several layers of equivocation fallacy switching between meanings of gender and sex and pronouns, sometimes several times on one page whenever it sorts your mentally ill propose. Being female is not a state of mind, it is a birthright, and unless you grew up with female body parts you can never claim to have that birthright. Being "feminine"(for lack of better terms male has always been a thing, you could be David Bowie, or a cross dresser or somewhere in between, but you can never be female, and to claim otherwise is to be deeply deeply confused about terms. And to apply prejudice to those terms that actually come from the culture, which you can’t escapes with language.
It is no different than being white and claiming you are black. Trans race is just as silly as transgender
>My mind is Afro man! Check your white privilege, give me affirmative action, since I now present as black you have to treat me as a black,
>let me in the black student union (even though that was set up to help with the unique problems no lack students might face and to advocate for blacks that were repressed in the past and might not have parents who were allowed to go to college, etc)
^this is what you do

>> No.13177540

>>13177500
And English says her pronouns are he/his so fuck off.

>> No.13177544
File: 135 KB, 1200x900, 1555644609293.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177544

Catch-22

>> No.13177549
File: 58 KB, 750x451, 3ba32ef.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177549

>> No.13177552

>>13177530
>asking someone to be called a certain pronoun is policing
gtfo with that hyperbolic nonsense, orwell was warning against the culling of words to limit range of thought since we wouldn't posses the necessary words to express certain ideas. holy shit did you even 1984?

>> No.13177557

>>13177527
I don't understand your logic, if pronouns are based on gender identity then there is no need to appeal to sex at all. The fact that it corrolates with sex is totally irrelevant to the discussion.

>> No.13177566

>>13177531
How do they not realize something is wrong with them when they do this shit?

>> No.13177568

>>13177552
He also talked about doublethink simplemind
War is peace, Freedom is Slavery, and Ignorance is Strength, males are females...

>> No.13177570

>>13177552
The culling of words and the artificial inflation of words has the same effect: a semantic apocalypse, dissolving metanarratives in that way only creates more space for capital to operate in. Tumblr is just as fascist as Auschwitz

>> No.13177585

>>13177557
Not that poster but
Gender and sex are the same thing
They are just used to refer to different parts of the same thing, but can be used interchangeably.

>> No.13177587

>>13177570
>Tumblr is just as fascist as Auschwitz
PLEASE.
HAVE.
SEX.

>> No.13177595

>>13177557
lol how slow are you? Pronouns are part of Gender identity which is inherently based on biological sex, so of course bringing the concept of sex into the equation is needed. Pronouns however directly correlate with biological sex, the reason why they do is because they a apart of gender identity which is based on biological sex.

>> No.13177596

>>13177585
Why wouldn't you respect the English language anon?

>> No.13177598
File: 186 KB, 738x669, 1548868246603.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177598

*ahem*

>> No.13177604
File: 87 KB, 750x577, 6F440320-582A-4FA1-8557-8FEB572B06AE.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177604

>>13177552
>asking someone to be called a certain pronoun is policing
It literally is, Orwell or not. It is just a way to get power and inconvenience others and be a part of the grievance industry and the privilege Olympics

>> No.13177609

>>13177595
>inherently based on biological sex
But you said that it overwhelming correlates, now your are claiming one is based on the other. Surely I don't need to explain the difference between correlation and causation, right anon?

>> No.13177612

>>13177552
That idiot obviously isn't deep enough to reference Orwell. Likewise, you ought to be able to explain to him why his grammar Nazi transphobia is actually forcing doublethink on trans people a la newspeak. I would but i'm very fucked up and I read that book in detention like 9 years ago.
Listen close retards, and repeat after me.
>Do to others
>As you would have done to yourself
Now let's all detente, call people as they identify, and FTLOG have sex.

>> No.13177613

>>13177587
Normies: HaVe SeX
Also normies: NoBoDy OwEs YoU SeX

>> No.13177616
File: 121 KB, 1165x842, QnEQ336.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177616

>>13177570
t. Brain genius

>> No.13177627
File: 426 KB, 500x400, C8EA6CD9-0F2A-4CFD-800B-1E68AE76D189.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177627

>>13177595
Hold on there, I put on a pink dress, so I am clearly female now, because that is what female is, a dress
>>13177596
Female gender, female sex. Notice anything?
Female gender
Female sex
They are both FEMALE, it refers to the same thing, you can change cultural norms about what females or males wear, but you can not change from male to female

>> No.13177633

>>13177403
Retard. You know nothing about our education system.

>> No.13177637

>>13177587
to have sex after auschwitz is barbaric

>> No.13177639
File: 1.17 MB, 570x291, E9493815-840F-4567-869A-F28D1DA35822.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177639

>>13177612
>call people as they identify,
No, because it is indulging their mental illness. I do not tell schizophrenias their voices are real either

>> No.13177640

>>13177627
Row boat
Row of cars
They are both ROWS see it's literally the same thing!!!

>> No.13177644
File: 448 KB, 2048x2048, omga (3).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177644

Do you guys really created a "pronoun" accesory to cope your mental illness? Grow up.

>> No.13177646

>>13177627
kek I don't think you are this retarded

>> No.13177648

>>13177595
Western gender norms are mostly based on Hebrew and, to a lesser extent Greek, gender norms. Gender norms are based in culture, and they vary wildly between cultures. gender is how biological sex is expressed, and it's expression is modal. Let alone questions about identity, but you aren't a logician I can tell.

>> No.13177652

>>13177371
pretty obvious that shes a crypto commie imo

>> No.13177653

>>13177633
substantiate your criticism by telling me where i went wrong, then

that is, if your BIG, VEINY, MASCULINE HANDS at the ends of your POWERFUL, THICK-WRISTED ARMS can perform such delicate work

>> No.13177654

>>13177639
You are nothing

>> No.13177655

>>13177566
They all do. They all realize it's a sexual perversion. Same as gays. They know.

>> No.13177660

>>13177609
Pronouns correlate with biological sex because it is a part of gender identity which correlates with biological sex. Pronouns fall under the umbrella of gender identity.

>> No.13177662

>>13177544
So they're going after young kids that are going through the typical difficulties of being a hormonal teenager. Imagine my shock.

>> No.13177667

>>13177648
Huh? Read my earlier posts, the cultural norms centered around gender roles may be relative but that gender roles exist and are inherently based on biological sex is not.

>> No.13177668

>>13177667
>Wearing a dress is based on ur chromosomes
Ok stupid, sure thing

>> No.13177670

for a board that's supposedly well versed in the literature and humanities, it sure feels like the people in here are not capable of more abstract thoughts.

>> No.13177671

>>13177653
>an adjunct is not a professor, it's an adjunct
adjunct is short for... wait for it.... adjunct professor. You are mistaken.
> maybe you are thinking of assistant or associate professor, but neither of those are possible pre-PhD either.
You can be a professor without a PhD. Again, you are mistaken.

This is very basic knowledge.

>> No.13177675

>>13177668
No, the actions of gender norms are relative (to a degree), but that gender norms exist in every society and always revolve around biological sex is not.

>> No.13177677

>>13177640
Nice strawman

>> No.13177679

>>13177660
>correlates
so it's not inherently based on it? it can't be both anon. either it's simple correlation (and therefore there is no connection between pronouns and sex) or it is an inherent basis and therefore you are rejecting the accepted English language definitions of both sex and gender. You can't just say one correlates with the other, therefore one is the basis of the other; that's not the way logic works.

>> No.13177681

>>13177670
Keep that to yourself. Nobody cares how you feel weirdo

>> No.13177685

>>13177681
yeah, f-facts don't care about your feelings right shapirobro???

>> No.13177688

>>13177685
That is correct, TRANNY.

>> No.13177692

>My thread already has 100+ replies
and they say that /lit/ is a slow board

>> No.13177694

>>13177679
Do I have really have to explain this again? Gender identity almost always correlates with biological sex, one can then say that the rule is that gender identity is based on biological sex, with rare exceptions that go against the "rule". In the same way it is the rule that humans have 10 fingers, with exceptions.

>> No.13177696

>>13177692
How do you feel about Hitler?

>> No.13177697

>>13177692
/pol/bait is the only way to guarantee hitting post limits on /lit/

>> No.13177699

>>13177677
You don't know what a strawman is

>> No.13177701

>>13177679
Also

Correlates definition: have a mutual relationship or connection, in which one thing affects or depends on another.

Depends, as in the basis of something.

>> No.13177702

>>13177675
Then why do trans and queer people exist in many cultures?
You seem to be treating these people like they are transsexuals, they are transgender. It has nothing to do with biological sex and you obviously can perform any gender role you want regardless of your sex. It's merely cosmetic and social

>> No.13177706

>>13177685
Actually I'm on your side, sjw

>> No.13177710

>>13177688
based manlet jew

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o--EfKAAU6w

>> No.13177716

>>13177702
How can it have nothing to do with your biological sex when the overwhelming majority of people, in all societies fulfill and feel comfortable with their with a gender identity that correlates with their sex. This is the rule and always has been the rule, the exceptions do not make this rule void and that gender identity therefore has no correlation with biological sex what so ever.

>> No.13177718

>>13177702
Gender roles detached from reproduction Is as useful of a concept as class detached from politics. All it does is obsfucate power relations

>> No.13177723
File: 104 KB, 635x442, Correlation-VS-Causation.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177723

>>13177694
>Gender identity almost always correlates with biological sex
yes
>one can then say that the rule is that gender identity is based on biological sex
no. correlation does not equal causation. you don't get to create a "rule" just because you feel like it. either go by the agreed upon definitions, or make an argument for why they are wrong. simply pointing to correlation and claiming it's causation is something they teach you is fallacious in fucking high school anon; how old are you?

>> No.13177725

>>13177706
>the only dichotomy that exists is being an sjw or alt-righter

>> No.13177727
File: 78 KB, 511x754, 1103BF35-861E-4C49-8A95-1A343438A77F.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177727

>>13177515
>“she”

I’m treating others as they would want to be treated. If I was mentally ill I would not want others to encourage me to descend deeper into the delusion. So it seems that you, my dear friend, are in fact the “fag,” and in response to your witty “have sex” repartee, I would advise you to stop frying your brain with muh cummies

>> No.13177728

>>13177718
nice word salad

>> No.13177729
File: 373 KB, 1018x857, 8BC735F5-CA11-4D53-9634-3622A03E10E2.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177729

>>13177660
Don’t bother aruging on their terms. They are just trying to semantic you into a corner by attacking words like "correlate", like I said earlier they use equivocation fallacy several times in one page, switching meanings whenever it suits them.
Everyone knows you cant change sex and gender is the social representation of sex. (Which the representation is of course changeable, but not what it is representing, which is unchanged and unchnageable).

>> No.13177733

>>13177701
from the same website:
>Gender
>Either of the two sexes (male and female), especially when considered with reference to social and cultural differences rather than biological ones. The term is also used more broadly to denote a range of identities that do not correspond to established ideas of male and female.

>> No.13177734

Why everyone care so much about trannies? Let those kooky mafuckas do their thing

>> No.13177735

>>13177329
Brainlet answer.
Education only helps brainlets because they're forced to do it, which ironically contrapoints dropped out of because they couldn't handle it. Intelligent people still undergo education, not to learn but simply for the credentials. Big difference.

>> No.13177737

>>13177723
But it is in the sense that humans have 10 fingers is a rule, would you not disagree that humans born with 9 fingers or 11 eleven are exceptions and go against the "norm" or "rule"?

>> No.13177742

>>13177735
>they
it*
>>13177734
>why does anyone care about anything
brainlet response

>> No.13177743

>>13177734
their thing is now convincing children to waste their lives on a subset of BDSM culture (transvestitism) and mutilate themselves

>> No.13177745

>>13177540
>And English says her pronouns are he/his so fuck off.
>her
Gotcha.

>> No.13177746

>>13177727
Photos of actual pretty women should always be deployed when arguing with trannies, it will drive them mad

>> No.13177750

>>13177718
But gender roles aren't intrinsically linked to reproduction. An infertile woman is still a woman.

>> No.13177756

>>13177702
>you can perform any gender role
No you cant.
The role is inherently tied to its biological function.
Let’s take a society where females are repressed, not allowed to go to school...
You don’t just get to put on pants and preform as a male, be called a male and go to school.
Now that is obvious, and in our culture the things are more subtitle, but it is still more then just a costume and you can not escape it by changing costumes

>> No.13177759

>>13177733
That's the definition I've been going on this entire time.

>The term is also used more broadly to denote a range of identities that do not correspond to established ideas of male and female.

This is the problem, these other identities that deviate form the gender identities of male and female and aberrations and go against the rule that applies to the overwhelming majority of people.

>> No.13177764

>>13177735
>Intelligent people still undergo education

yeah, like the many CEOs who dropped out of college or only pursued a bachelors. those who found interest elsewhere and decided to make their ideas a reality certainly all brainlets.

fuck off with the pretentiousness

>> No.13177765

>>13177737
I don't really understand what you are trying to demonstrate with this example anon, it sort of misses the point because we don't classify humans based on the amount of fingers they have. We have no issue calling a polydactyly a human, (and would find it absurd to think otherwise), so I don't know what you are trying to demonstrate. What rule do you think gender should be based on? Chromosomes? Genitalia?

>> No.13177770

>>13177759
>especially when considered with reference to social and cultural differences rather than biological ones
this means gender is the term we have chosen to refer to social and cultural norms rather than biological ones, i.e. sex. It totally disagrees with the idea that sex and gender are based off of one another or relate to eachother as some sort of "rule"

>> No.13177771

>>13177450
LMAO

>> No.13177777

>>13177750
That's just being pedantic. You can't accurately analyze the role of women in society while ignoring reproduction

>> No.13177778

>>13177764
Thanks for proving my point, brainlet.
CEOS who dropped out of college had connections, you do not.

>> No.13177782
File: 13 KB, 480x360, E3AB80AB-8901-4744-ADAA-7B230C9FA873.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177782

>>13177750
She also has less muscle mass, if she works at a supermarket she is less likely to be given stocking jobs, if a heterosexual flirts with her, he is expecting a functioning female sex organ to play with at the least.
>performs gender role
Is a meaningless concept if not tied to biology. And even worse when you crazy’s start claiming straight men should date men(transwomen)

>> No.13177783

>>13177765
You're dodging what I actually said to you, is it not a rule that humans have 10 fingers? That people who do not have 10 fingers are exceptions to the rule?

>> No.13177787

>>13177764
most CEOs are dumb as fuck bugpeople

>> No.13177788

imagine SEETHING because someone doesn't want to play a part in your delusions fuelled by mental illness
fuck you trannies, you'll never be women

>> No.13177794

>>13177770
I explained this ealier to you the actions that gender roles may be preform vary and are relative, but that the gender roles themselves what ever they make take on, correlate to biological sex for the overwhealming majrotiy of people through out history.

>inb4 some indian 3rd gender tranny

Again, exceptions to the rule that are rare.

>> No.13177796

>>13177764
>mah dropout meme
97% of Fortune 500 CEOs have degrees

>> No.13177799

you guys are all so easy to bait just to get frothy about gender

anytime anyone asks her about books she admits that she's done with reading and got over it before she dropped out, but she has said she loves prose, so maybe she's "so well read" because she actually likes reading good writing
maybe yall could try that

>> No.13177803

>>13177799
>she
>yall
fuck off, you absolute n*gg*r

>> No.13177809 [DELETED] 

>>13177799
i will only try that if you agree to try gassing trannies with me in my gas chamber

>> No.13177812

Transactivists are straight up COINTELPRO wreckers.

>> No.13177815

>>13177318
Why does this tranny trigger crossboarders so hard?

>> No.13177816

>>13177778
seething

>>13177787
>meanwhile i am a highly intelligent and successful individual

>>13177796
yeah, bachelor's only learn to read

>> No.13177817
File: 10 KB, 263x191, 1511843621646.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177817

>>13177783
Again, what do you mean rule? Define your terms anon, pretend you are competent at philosophy. Number of fingers is not a determining factor to the classification of a human being. Is there a clear norm to number of fingers among humans? Yes, absolutely. It is also the norm that people born biologically male identify as male. For the second time, literally no one is arguing this. The issue is when you take the leaps to saying that all biological men therefore must identify as male; this is as absurd as saying all people born with more than "10 fingers" (8 fingers and two thumbs) are not allowed to be classified as human. It's an absurd standard that goes against the very purpose of the classification.

>> No.13177822

>>13177816
>seething
Yes you are.

>> No.13177829

>>13177799
they just so tribalist. theyll talk all day about how they wanna fuck blair white cause shes on their team. but they cant handle natalie cause shes lefty. its (sniff) ideology

>> No.13177834

>>13177829
you're so out of touch and out of place that you must be an actual girl in real life, please post your feet?

>> No.13177837

>>13177777
checked

>> No.13177840
File: 52 KB, 638x640, uwxchwm8vu701.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177840

>>13177782
>he doesn't want to suck a feminine penis

>> No.13177846
File: 18 KB, 249x249, 1539721901538.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
13177846

>>13177377
>She
>she
>>13177389
>she
>shes
>>13177397
>she
>>13177488
>woman
>>13177500
>She
>her
>she/her
>her
>>13177515
>she
>she
>her
>she
>she
>She
>she
>she
>she
>>13177540
>her
>>13177652
>shes
>>13177799
>her
>she
>she's
>she
>she
>she
>she's
>she
>>13177829
>shes
>shes