[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 412 KB, 777x554, nietzsche und marx.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19145203 No.19145203[DELETED]  [Reply] [Original]

how do I reconcile my favorite economist with my favorite philosopher?

>> No.19145214
File: 145 KB, 487x800, 5586563711_199542e757_c.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19145214

>>19145203
If you lean more Nietzsche
The collected works of Benito Mussolini
If you lean more Marx
The collected works of Vladimir Lenin

both were wrong btw

>> No.19145216
File: 9 KB, 200x240, doctor G.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19145216

There is only one man with the answers

>> No.19145218

>>19145203
Well mix in Heidegger and Giorgio Agamben will do you well

>> No.19145224

>>19145218
>Heidegger
hack who only wrote for money

>> No.19145225

>>19145203
But more genuinely OP, read Sorel

>> No.19145228
File: 1.40 MB, 1370x878, 1627944677402.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19145228

>>19145224
Yeah yeah he plagiarized le ebin Nippon man don't care didn't ask faggot

>> No.19145233

>>19145225
i already did and idk what is better. removing bourgeoise or just placing le boot over them.

>> No.19145241

>>19145233
Then you haven't read The Civil War in France

>> No.19145251

>>19145203
Easy: you dont
Marx was a confirmed advocate for racial genocide, and Nietzsche wasnt. So drop the shmuck and ride with the Mustache King.

>> No.19145259

>>19145251
>Marx was a confirmed advocate for racial genocide
where?

>> No.19145263

>>19145241
lemme guess
vanguardist?

>> No.19145269

>>19145259
Look up what he wrote about the slavs
Look up where the term "holocaust" originated from

>> No.19145278
File: 15 KB, 334x499, 317W79vEjCL._SX332_BO1,204,203,200_ (1).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19145278

>>19145263
Nah

>> No.19145280

>>19145269
>Look up where the term "holocaust" originated from
biblical times?

>> No.19145304

>>19145203
>favourite economist
THAT ISN'T ENGELS
OR II RUBIN

You're a cunt.

>> No.19145409

>>19145203
Nietzsche said Marxists where "little people"
So there is no reconciliation.

>> No.19145436

>>19145409
Nietzsche and Marx were completely obscure to each other in their lives. Nietzsche never uses the word "Marxist" - he does "socialist." There is a reason why these two words are not completely redundant.

>> No.19145447
File: 16 KB, 217x337, 198384.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19145447

>> No.19145454

>>19145447
Land has no answers. There's a reason his work turned into ressentiment towards leftists and some kind of bitcoin/blockchain mysticism that says nothing but a promise of libertarian-ancap paradise.

>> No.19145482

>>19145269
>Look up what he wrote about the slavs
can i get a source?
i cant find it

also
>19th century jew wrote racist thing
what a surprise

>> No.19145498

>>19145482
Search: "Marx racial trash"
Dont use Google

>> No.19145504
File: 60 KB, 500x483, hoppe sub.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19145504

>>19145203
>my favorite economist

>> No.19145509

>>19145498
>http://noisyroom.net/blog/2011/03/09/karl-marx-%E2%80%9Cracial-trash-will-have-to-be-destroyed%E2%80%9D/

i will read into it

it better be fucking true, it BETTER BE FUCKING TRUE. I HOPE IT IS.

AFTER I COMBINE MY scientific racism/EUGENICS WITH MARXISM I WILL BE UNSTOPPABLE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

>> No.19145513

>>19145504
ltv doesn't come from marx retard, it comes from Ricardo and adam smith, and he literally disproves ltv in chapter 1 of capital.

fucking retard, read marx

>> No.19145519

>>19145203
read marx in light of technology as an expression of the will to power. man dominates the private individual through collectivist rational arrangement of universal material fulfillment. the russian cosmist federov as a marxist -- the ultimate conquest of nature through technological determination of existence via immortality and resurrection. 'from each according to his ability' = federov's 'common goal'. federov's techno-farmer, immortal and resurrecting his perished fathers as the overman.

>> No.19145521

>>19145409
>>19145436
He never referred to Marx, but it's hard to reconcile his aristocratism with Marx.

>> No.19145527

>>19145521
Not if you rely on a non-humanist reading of Marx.

>> No.19145529

>>19145513
I never said the ltv was a marxist invention, the "necessary labor" is the marxist ltv, which still holds that the value of labor comes from the amount of time put on it, doesn't matter if you want to call "necessary labor", is still the ltv.

>> No.19145534

>>19145527
take your meds

>> No.19145535

>>19145498
https://communism-explained.blogspot.com/2010/05/did-marx-call-for-extermination-of.html
yes turns out you're not telling me the whole story
now i have to justify my scientific racism through other means

what a shame.

>> No.19145538

>>19145527
Marx was too revolutionist for Nietzsche. The fire hound in Thus Spoke Zarathustra was a caricature of revolutionists that Zarathustra mocks.

>> No.19145546

>>19145203
I view them as having very similar intellectual projects, just approached from different angles. Marx wanted to uncover the economic factors that influenced and controlled “free rational agents” and the history of philosophy, and Nietzsche wanted to uncover the biological factors that did the same thing. On that level, they complement each other nicely and there isn’t much to reconcile.
Obviously they do have disagreements, but on fundamental questions of metaphysics, epistemology, and methodological approaches to philosophy, I don’t think they’re that different.

>> No.19145560

>>19145203
Hm. Maybe read Alexander Bard? He's more a tech-philosopher but his politics and world view are a synthesis of neetch and Marx. From his lectures and talks he clearly comes off as an idealist who wants humanity to transform into Nietzschean unermensch and thus being "smart" enough to become Marxists without fucking shit up a la animal farm or the other historical accounts of marxisms failure

>> No.19145592

>>19145218
Pretty much this, throw some Schmitt in there to have more context for Agamben

>> No.19145645
File: 28 KB, 331x500, 9781913462499.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19145645

read cuck philosophy

>> No.19145653

>>19145203
Marx wasn't an economist

>> No.19145655
File: 26 KB, 680x383, 632092043ad50c112f94b25d802c0198.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
19145655

>>19145645
>youtube "intellectuals"

>> No.19145662

>>19145653
ye he was
how was he not
practically invented the field