[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 1.73 MB, 1000x1500, 3DBE43CE-B69D-48F8-8FA7-5C2EA93DA39A.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18521235 No.18521235 [Reply] [Original]

How is it that someone can misinterpret Dostoevsky this bad?

>> No.18521239
File: 1.78 MB, 1000x1500, A7D69937-BB8E-4607-9EC5-6988A36C56CC.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18521239

>>18521235

>> No.18521244

>why do people who write their ideas in elaborate novels with many characters and situations as metaphors get misunderstood?
This is what hate most about literature, they write as vague as possible to reach those 300 pages and then get all smug when somebody finds a wrong interpretation.

>> No.18521435

>>18521239
kek the soccer goalie one is actually like a scene out of Doestoesvky, nice

>> No.18521444

>>18521235
>>18521239

By not understanding the difference between the author and their work.

>> No.18521464

>>18521244
They write 300 pages of vagueness because it is more like life than a single declarative paragraph without contradiction.
Further, a brutal reduction is guaranteed to be seen as a wrong interpretation— would you respect my opinion if I said GR was about how nazis are bad, or that Moby Dick is about chasing your dreams?

>> No.18521466

>>18521435
Not really. Most of the characters that self-destruct didn't rationalize it, Stavrogin and Kirilov being the notable exceptions.

>> No.18521662
File: 10 KB, 320x240, 3ophzwx78i271.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18521662

>>18521235
These comics are the literal equivalent of late night television shows. Shitty humor used to poorly disguise almost elementary retard-level opinions that are pushed onto audiences as satirical insights because most people don't read, don't understand, but love to feel they can do both.

>> No.18521672

>>18521235
Most likely this is done by people who have never read his books for people who will never read.

>> No.18522026

>>18521662
underrated post

>> No.18522100

>>18521235
I don't know I got a chuckle out of the brain fever one

>> No.18522112

>>18521239
That bottom panel is literally not recognizing what "the author" wrote to refute the thoughts of Raskolnikov. So retarded.

>> No.18522209

>>18521464
>Moby Dick is about chasing your dreams
I will be using this interpretation from his on

>> No.18522236

the faggot who makes these is a leftist anarchist

imagine studying philosophy your entire life just to end up an anarchist making kiddie comics

>> No.18522301
File: 430 KB, 1000x1500, worldcup_1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18522301

>> No.18522310
File: 474 KB, 1000x1500, worldcup_2.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18522310

>>18522301

>> No.18522324
File: 416 KB, 1000x1500, worldcup_3.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18522324

>>18522310

>> No.18522331
File: 498 KB, 1000x1500, worldcup_4.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18522331

>>18522324

>> No.18522367

>>18521244
>>18521464
faggot BTFO eternally

>> No.18522390

some commie who cares

>> No.18522391

>>18522301
>>18522310
This ones pretty good honestly.

>> No.18522548

>>18521235
>How is it that someone can misinterpret Dostoevsky this bad?
For comedic effect catering to an undergraduate audience for the purposes of making money.

>> No.18522644

>>18521235
Regarding that last panel, wasn't Raskolnikov's argument not that great men will accomplish great things therefor they can do what they want, but that great men accomplish great things because they don't conform to morality?

>> No.18522702

>>18521235
these are gay

>> No.18522732

>>18522310
Realistically they would be in despair because Camus would be absolutely demolishing them in soccer.

>> No.18522859

>>18522301
Okay I admit, the Sarte part made me laugh

>> No.18522938

>>18522301
Imagine ripping off a decades old Monty Python sketch and still managing to make it 10 times worse

>> No.18522994

>>18521235
>>18521239
Therapist: 4/10
Engineer: 2/10
Doctor: 9/10, Nabokov could have written that

Priest: 3/10
Goalie: 7/10
Office Worker: negative 10/10

>> No.18523030

>>18522310

Panel 4 is gold.

>> No.18523060

This guy's comics are pure cringe.

>> No.18523094

>>18521239
The priest is actually correct.

>> No.18523178

>>18523060
Anyone who sees philosophy as a buffet or museum of demarcated ides is cringe.

>> No.18523264

>socialist "artist" can't cope with the fact that his egalitarian fairyland Utopias will never manage to truly eliminate suffering so he makes heavy-handed Dostoevsky strawmans
lol

>> No.18523374

someone post the stairs one

>> No.18523400

>>18522331
I enjoyed this

>> No.18523439

>>18522331
truly some retarded stuff for dummies, if you ask me

>> No.18523457

>>18521239
Based priest

>> No.18523465

>>18521464
>Moby Dick is about chasing your dreams?
It’s about how chasing your dreams won’t necessarily make you happy.

>> No.18523521

>>18521244
This is why Borges was and still is so based.

>> No.18524667

>>18522938
came to say this.

>> No.18526127

>>18521239
They made him seem pretty based. The cartoonist's point seems pretty stupid.
>be mediocre then die, because I said so

>> No.18526135

>>18521662
This is something I've been trying to put into words for a long time. This is why libs can't meme.

>> No.18526163

>>18522324
>desperately trying to rehabilitate Marx
/pol/ has done more to rehabilitate Marx by quoting what he said about LaSalle than this comic ever will.

>> No.18526181

>>18522331
This is so sad, it is probably one of their best comics, but it is not original and it is hundreds of times worse than the one it is ripping off.

>> No.18526203

>>18521239
>Goalie

>> No.18526244

>>18522644
You are correct. The cartoonist is stupid.

>> No.18526254

>>18521235
Westerners are completely fucking retarded thats why. Disregard their existence totally and you'll feel a lot happier.

>> No.18526263

>>18522301
>>18522310
>>18522324
>>18522331
I haven't cringed this hard in years.

Please stop, you're killing me worse than Covid.

>> No.18526270

>>18526263
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LfduUFF_i1A
It's a shitty rip off of a Monty Python sketch.

>> No.18526351
File: 475 KB, 1000x1327, 1605697720782.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18526351

>>18521235

>> No.18526469

>>18522301
>>18522310
>>18522324
>>18522331

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LfduUFF_i1A

>> No.18526616

>>18526351
Why are they so unfunny. I think its because this feel like woman humor

>> No.18526627

>>18521235
What sucks is that this influences Youtuber and millennial/ zoomer conversations more than the actual texts, which reinforce childlike beliefs that this is what these writers represent.

>> No.18526642

>>18521235
>>18521239
B^U

>> No.18526668

>>18526616

>woman humor

What if I told you a woman wrote this?

>> No.18526723

>>18526668
say it ain't so

>> No.18526847

>>18526254
Seeth monkey man.

>> No.18527013

>>18526181
that Monty Python skit has 1 actual line about philosophy and it's just name dropping ideas not related in any way to the game. The skit is just men in funny costumes on the pitch (like most MP)
Everything is derivative but this comic actually integrates the philosophies into the game and made me chuckle a few times which is pretty good by shitty webcomic standards.

>> No.18528080
File: 97 KB, 318x485, 1624565959307.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18528080

>>18521239
how i feel desu

>> No.18528135

>>18526351
This is good.

>> No.18528144
File: 183 KB, 1413x805, 1548978513318.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
18528144

>>18526351

>> No.18528502

I havent even read dostoyevsk

>> No.18528517

>>18521235
cultural Marxism

>> No.18528590

>>18526668
I would not be shocked