[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 276 KB, 800x1161, East_of_Eden_(1952_1st_ed_dust_jacket).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16466884 No.16466884 [Reply] [Original]

This is a textbook example of utter mediocrity. The dialogue is unnatural and heavy-handed (such as the almost comical overuse of metaphor and idiom for the characters Samuel and Lee), the themes and allusions are drawn straight from scripture, without any alterations or considerations upon those themes beyond the fact that they're eternal, the style is simultaneously simplistic and barren, yet absolutely pretentious and stilted. Through this book I have somehow acquired an intense dislike of Steinbeck, as if his snivelling sense of poetic and moral superiority emanates in undiluted aspect from the words, sentences and chapters of this book. Not only is the book nauseating and full of itself, it also dares to be an absolute slog, spanning several generations and many, MANY uninteresting, monofacetted personalities. This becomes a special issue when it dawns on you that almost all of the arcs presented within the book is wrapped up through some sort of tired cliché, be it a faux-Shakespearean revelation, a suicide or some sudden, forced change in a characters mental state (a principle perhaps most grievously applied to Adam Trask).

Fuck this absolutely disgraceful pile of steaming shit.

>> No.16467050

>>16466884
I liked it.

>> No.16467052

>>16467050
kek

>> No.16467056

>>16466884
write a goodreads review and stop shitting up the thread with personal blog-posts

>> No.16467072

>>16466884
You went from mediocre to absolutely disgraceful pile of steaming shit pretty quick.

>> No.16467085

I found it a bit parochial and lacking subtlety

>> No.16467089

>>16466884
It's basically Midwit: The Novel. People who love it have no ear for literary quality.

>> No.16467154

>>16466884
You complain about the books length despite the entire novel being easily readable in a week by an average American. There are definitely some overwrought metaphors, particularly at the very end of the novel when the chad son walks past where the religious son and the girl used to play house, but book doesn’t shove such imagery down the readers face that often. At any rate Steinbeck wrote a comfy novel about California. If you’ve never lived in the Central Valley then it might not be as appealing

>> No.16467164

>>16467089
ah fuck off

>> No.16467310

>>16466884
Wrong.

>> No.16467354

This isn't a review site, and if you decide to dislike an author over one work you shouldn't be on this board.
>>16467089
Good thing I don't read with my ears then.

>> No.16467446
File: 18 KB, 650x559, Amerilard.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16467446

>>16467354
>Good thing I don't read with my ears then.