[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 208 KB, 1280x853, tumblr_p226d1RPTF1rmt9iho2_r1_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14954044 No.14954044 [Reply] [Original]

Why is Tumblr so utterly obsessed with the myth of Persephone? No other Greek character is as chopped up, reimagined, drawn, hotly debated or adored by them and its just fucking weird.

Do they imagine Hades to be an older white dude and secretly desire to be his wife? Do the really buy the meme that she's a big tiddie goth gf who ended up being the boss bitch of Hell?

>> No.14954094 [DELETED] 
File: 95 KB, 700x466, 92B870P.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14954094

>>14954044
>Do they imagine Hades to be an older white dude and secretly desire to be his wife?
Yes, this is pretty much the key to understand the female mind in general.

>> No.14954103
File: 76 KB, 637x478, 1514457277068.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14954103

>Do poor women want an upperclass man to steal them away into riches and luxury
come on bro think.. this is obviously every immature girl's fantasy.

>> No.14954108

>>14954094
Fucking based image.

>> No.14954234 [DELETED] 
File: 135 KB, 577x900, couple-descending-stairs-arrow-collar-advertisement-j-c-leyendecker.jpeg.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14954234

>>14954103
Immature? It's the fantasy of every woman, and not just by upper-class men but elegant and dominant men who will spank their bottoms. Status, power, beauty and strong will with a darker streak.

Men fantasise about the opposite, submissive women falling for them and desiring them, conquering then and taming them.

>> No.14954301

>>14954044
Better question why is everyone on tumblr incapable of drawing aesthetically pleasing pictures? It's all nigger lips with red noses and nigger eyes and disgusting fat bodies

>> No.14954368

>>14954301
Because it's ideologically driven and not aesthetically.

>> No.14954425

>>14954044
Even better question, why is all "art" coming from tumblr so infantile? It's like those people were raised on a cultural diet of comic books and Wes Anderson films.

>> No.14954477

god i fucking hate this artsyle

>> No.14955202

>>14954044
her head shape is so wrong

>> No.14955244

>>14954044
Because they know next to nothing about the myth or classics in general and think Persephone (at least the way they pronounce it) is a really pretty name
don’t overestimate that which doesn’t overthink

>> No.14955328

>>14954044
>bored young girl gets abducted by the gigachad boss of mortals (they all end up in his territory) who drowns in riches (literally god of jewelry) without having to do anything but exist and be beautiful
That's the ultimate female archetype.

>> No.14955383

>>14954301
large lips are pretty commonly sought after nowadays

>> No.14955406

>>14955383
*smacks lips*

>> No.14955773
File: 17 KB, 253x400, 503EC824-A1FD-436C-82B7-F3BD7EB06B48.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14955773

Because it is the classic archetype of the straight girls lifecycle. Her father sends her off to marriage without her mother’s consent, big drama, she does indeed become bigger and more important in the afterlife because we don’t suffer as a shadow wandering around caverns, but in Elysium.
But hey, you don’t like how kids translate this shit, don’t look at it, ya dumb ox.
Start with the Greeks and learn something

>> No.14955813

>>14955406
Does someone have lip envy?

>> No.14956473

>>14955773
What are you blathering about

>> No.14956517

>>14954044
Who cares about Tumblr lmao. You're trying too hard to understand the minds of problematic teenage girls.

>> No.14956523 [DELETED] 

>>14955813
I'm not using my lips to suck dick, so no.

>> No.14956546

>>14954044
i hate "tumblr" art style, but this pic is relatively alright, especially the right character. on the left yes, the signature sjw art influence is strong

>> No.14956547

>>14954301
because people like you who don't like that stuff don't use Tumblr, duh.

>> No.14956558

>>14955773
they're not gonna fuck you, sis

>> No.14956659

>>14956547
it's objectively disgusting

>> No.14956790
File: 54 KB, 828x799, F6859E93-4D02-4AC1-BA46-33CDE24F5764.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14956790

>>14955773
Imagine being unable to view anything outside of the lens of your sexuality

>> No.14956797

>>14954301
>>14956659
They're fucking cartoons, you retard.

>> No.14956810

>>14956797
ugly cartoons

>> No.14956904

>>14954044
name a better and cuter couple then, besides Apollo and Admetus

>> No.14956972

She has her state of innocence and vulnerability destroyed in a moment of violent abduction and as an inevitable result of this twist of fate she becomes the queen of the underworld. This is a common and very accessible trope among feminist “artist” types who see themselves tortured souls, victims of masculine predation and thus forced to the fringes where they use their fecundity to reign as queen in their minds. See Artemisia Gentileschi for similar themes in her paintings of lost innocent and vengeance. It’s extremely predictable desu.

>> No.14957010

>>14956523
I still feel like you wish that were an option for you.

>> No.14957681

>>14956904
Gaea and Aether.

>> No.14958374

>>14956810
that's nice that you don't care for it

>> No.14958419
File: 1.52 MB, 4096x2094, Lore Olympus.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14958419

>>14954044
Are you talking about Lore Olympus anon? Here is Hades and Persephone.

>> No.14958435

>>14954368
This.

>> No.14958441

>>14954425
>It's like those people were raised on a cultural diet of comic books and Wes Anderson films.
I've got some news that might surprise you.

>> No.14958715

>>14954103
I rarely say this, but fpbp, and unironically

>> No.14958744
File: 19 KB, 393x395, CZINCPgUgAE_BS7.jpg large.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14958744

>>14954044
>mfw I read that and actually thought it was a great line of poetry but then I realized it's a tumblr comic and it's meant to be taken literally

>> No.14958972

>>14956473
Being the only one here who’s read up on the topic ITT, I thought I’d help ya out.

>>14956790
It’s an ancient myth for women this time. Go read your oafish Hercules myth

>> No.14959240
File: 151 KB, 1280x853, tumblr_p226d1RPTF1rmt9iho1_r2_1280.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14959240

>>14958972
>It’s an ancient myth for women this time
Which is bizarre considering that almost every premodern interpretation involves a young girl who does zero decision making.

Is that why Tumblr likes it so much? Do they like being an object?

>>14956904
Apollo and Cassandra

>>14958744
I mean yeah, what did you expect?

>> No.14959381

>>14959240
The story is about the pain of the separation mothers and daughters feel when one has to grow up and marry. I don’t keep up with kid’s online portfolios and I don’t care what they’re getting out of it

>> No.14959387

tumblr is a weird place. They fell in love with this story of a woman being kidnapped and forced into marriage and managed to make it about female empowerment. They're like that with a lot of things where they love shit that goes against all of it's believes. In a lot of the fanart Hades is a handsome goth boy so it fits into the fantasy of having a person way out of your league fall for you for no reason (which let's be honest is very popular with both genders)

And the real reason why it's popular is because tumblr is used mostly by women and gays, women and gays love musicals, there is a musical "Hadestown" which is about Persephone and Hades.

>> No.14959396

>>14956972
interesting take. I think for some girls this is how they see it and the other girls see it as a fantasy.

>> No.14959407

>>14959387
>and managed to make it about female empowerment
Did you just get here? Filtering me?
It IS. Fucking Demeter could have ended the world and the gods would have been stuck with nothing.
But they caved and gave her a better deal for her beloved daughter. Hence the Eleusinian Mysteries

>> No.14959431
File: 2 KB, 92x125, 1581823280261s.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14959431

>>14959381
what a profane view...it isn't about mothers and daughters...it is about about the eternity of the soul and the cycles of life...death and rebirth (Winter and Spring)...maybe if you didn't disrespect Guenon (pbuh) you could realize the Elysian mysteries...

>> No.14959438

>>14959407
I'm talking more about how in tumblr memes/fanarts Persephone is the dominant one in relationship, ordering Hades around, always getting her way, going for his dick, generally being aggressive and extroverted etc.
OP is about tumblr interpretation of the myth rather than the actual thing.

>> No.14959442

>>14959396
It’s a brainlet take

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=NQ2r_oGT8C8

>> No.14959497

>>14959431
Idiot. Demeter would have held back ever allowing spring again because of her grief. Read the book I posted.

>>14959438
So off topic r9k drivel

>> No.14959508

>>14959497
>taking myths literally
nah

>> No.14959524

>>14959508
>taking tumblr literally

Or in case you’re the other one
>>14959508
>taking the Guener literally

>> No.14959532

>>14959407
>she was about to decimate the planet and all she could get out of it was a "better deal"
>empowerment

Notice how Persephone's decision making is still completely absent from this scenario.

>>14959381
>I don’t care what they’re getting out of it
Then why are you even commenting?

>>14956972
I don't get why Tumblr considers Persephone their goffick kween representation in Greek mythology. Surely Heacte, Medea or other girl bosses would fit better.

>> No.14959553
File: 58 KB, 500x500, 19748744.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14959553

>>14959524
>Because it is the classic archetype of the straight girls lifecycle. Her father sends her off to marriage without her mother’s consent, big drama, she does indeed become bigger and more important in the afterlife because we don’t suffer as a shadow wandering around caverns, but in Elysium.

nice back pedal

>> No.14959564

>>14959431
What? Guenonfag is now posting good posts? Is it the end of the times already?

>> No.14959576

>>14959532
The better deal was that she could return to the surface annually, for two thirds of the year, rule the underworld as queen and rule Elysium. The Christian archetype for heaven
> Then why are you even commenting?
Why are you here bitching about an artist who doesn’t even post on this website? Talk about off topic. Gtfo already.

>I don’t get why ... Surely Heacte, Medea or other girl bosses would
Of course you don’t understand. You don’t read.

>> No.14959578

>>14954044
Why is Persephone a nigger?

>> No.14959590
File: 202 KB, 717x880, BacktoRedditFuck.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14959590

>>14958744
expect nothing less from an officefag. gtfo

>> No.14959676
File: 267 KB, 400x450, tumblr_ped9vb2HWM1qegyh3o1_400.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14959676

>>14959576
>The better deal was that she could return to the surface annually
You are missing the point. Persephone is is abducted by Hades. Demeter then negotiates on her behalf to get a better "deal". She has zero agency throughout the myth and is objectified by mother, father and eventual husband.

My question is why do middle white chicks love this idea so much.

>The Christian archetype for heaven
I can't imagine Elysium being that much better than Olympus, but whatever you say.

>Why are you here bitching about an artist who doesn’t even post on this website?
Its not just this person, all of Tumblr cannot stop talking about it and it infects Twitter and Facebook as well. I just don't understand why its just this myth, nor do I get why you are so hostile lol

>Of course you don’t understand
No, I don't understand, but you aren't explaining why Tumblr likes this myth in particular, or why Persephone is teh goff kween, just reiterating what everyone already knows.

>> No.14959710

>>14959676
>that pic

What an abomination.

>> No.14959717

>>14959710
the Greeks must be rolling in their graves lmfao

>> No.14959790

>>14959676
>the point
There’s no getting around it. She’s the innocent daughter, the plot is nothing without her ut she doesn’t have the biggest role to play. Afterwards she has a big deal to play as queen of the dead. (Drrr goff) She’s much beloved, because the place she takes the dead is lovely, though we aren’t in a rush to get there.
>middle white
Ask them.
It is a girl’s myth. Hekate is the old goddess of the dead and more elderly. Venus is a popular enough goddess but the stories are strange and later ones are just stupid.
Why do menboys go ape over the Iliad? Get over it.

>> No.14959829
File: 715 KB, 1600x2410, 919QE25JnTL.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14959829

>>14959790
>Ask them
Thanks, appreciate it.

>it's a girls myth
You don't seem them writing and re-imagining Artemis as much even though she's literally a free spirited young woman that punishes men for their transgressions. Yet, this active, powerful character isn't what they want. They isntead want to be a mugguffin in a story.

>Why do menboys go ape over the Iliad?
Why do women go ape over the Illiad? (pic related) The answer is simple, its a dope story.

>> No.14959831

>>14959829
>Artemis

Not him but isn't she supposed to be a chaste goddess? That's unacceptable for your average tumblr user.

>> No.14959837

>>14959831
DAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAMN

>> No.14959844

>>14959829
Don’t talk to it.

Also, tumbler doesn’t understand its own urges or the irrationality of its own philosophy. Ask why do women have rape fantasies.

>> No.14959861

>>14959829
Straight girls. Why they want men isn’t something I can accurately grasp.
Artemis is the lesbian’s goddess (and an aspect of Hekate)

>>14959831
She’s always killing men for seeing her and her nymphs naked etc. She’s “chaste” enough for Zeus who’s like a lot of men who think women can’t have sex.
No such stories survive of course, but then most everyone accepts that she’s his actual daughter and not a goddess that predates his invader cult

>> No.14959863
File: 205 KB, 600x315, c962b478-0cea-4ae9-93f3-053b5df799c3.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14959863

For me, its shota persephone

>> No.14959877

>>14954044
Actually i noticed that too. was reading a hermione x snape fanfiction with a lot of sex in it because that's the only benefit of having suffered through harry potter, the grade A porn fics, and author was gushing about hermione being persephone and snape hades. OP is on to something. If you're wondering about the porn fic hermione literally becomes his sex slave and he takes her virginity.

>> No.14959878

>>14959844
The term “rape” is used differently in the story. She is actually kidnapped and left untouched till well after the hymn is finished. The pomegranate part of the story wouldn’t make sense if she were ravaged

>> No.14959879

>>14959387
why cant they like a story that's about getting a cute guy above your league who is NOT kidnapping you then?

>>14959438
maybe because the real story is too terrifying and realistic so they have to switch it around to feel better

>> No.14959881
File: 124 KB, 717x1080, hadestown.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14959881

It's because of a popular musical called Hadestown, similar to "Hamilton". Only >>14959387 this anon got it right. Not much of a mystery.

>> No.14959891

>>14959879
Its embarrassing when women try to larp like classicists when all they do is get their info from secondary sources.

>> No.14959927

>>14959590
You don't see how that line, in another context, might be a good way of exclaiming your embrace of the inevitability of death? Also I don't watch the office faggot. It's just a good reaction pic.

>> No.14959955

>>14954044
Because it's a story about abduction and rape that they all collectively decided to reimagine as a totally consensual love story in which Persephone is a boss bitch who takes no shit, girrrrl!

>> No.14959962

>>14959877
This basically sums up what Im talking about. That vs >>14959438 makes up a majority of Tumblr/Twitter's debates regarding Greek myths.

>>14959863
Based.

>>14959861
>Artemis is a lesbian
Bro, what? Also no one on Tumblr is a self-admitted straight, get out of here with that shit.

>No such stories survive of course
You seem to be fully aware that Artemis is a boss bitch and don't think she's chaste, but can't or won't explain why isn't every white middle class girl's projection.

>>14959878
He's not referring the "rape of Persephone" he's just talking about rape fantasies in general. Again, no one here seems to be ignorant about the story but you are wilfully misreading everything lol.

>> No.14960009
File: 112 KB, 220x175, 76F33B56-5E66-4FCC-882C-EECBC2A8EEDD.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14960009

>>14959962
>no one here seems to be ignorant about the story
Bad coping skills

>> No.14960075

>>14959962
>>14959831
>>14959861
There's been arguments that the ancient Greek concept of virginity just meant not having sex with men. Combine that with all the women Artemis hangs out with all the time and the weird story where Zeus pretends to be Artemis to have sex wtih Callisto and the idea that Artemis is a lesbian is there.

>> No.14960095

>>14959790
Persephone/Demeter/Hekate can be considered the same goddess.

>> No.14960100

>>14960075
That reminds me how some islamic "lawyers" think women can't be tried for homosexuality, since they're incapable of having sex, lacking a penis and all.

>> No.14960112

>>14959881
Man anais is talented and i respect her domestic subject matter in her other songwriting and all, but this shit falls off so hard in the second half.
First like, six minutes are excellent dust bowl showtunes, and the other songs have great moments, but they exist to serve the narrative, more than to be fully developed pieces of standalone songwriting.

I suppose that's just how it goes with a concept like this, but there aren't any great compositions on par with her songs like "Young Man in America"

>> No.14960124

>>14960100
In America there are many states that define rape as a penis entering a vagina against the will of the woman. Basically making it legally impossible for rape charges to be brought against any rape that isn't man raping woman. Forcing prosecutors to use lesser charges like sexual assault.

>> No.14960163

>>14960009
But at no point has any expressed ignorance about the core story or the characterisation of any of these myths. Did you really think using a n arranged marriage to explain the change in seasons was some huge revelation like here >>14955773?

>> No.14960183

>>14960100
>>>14959831
>>>14959861
>There's been arguments that the ancient Greek concept of virginity just m
True, but again no on Tumblr seems to link Artemis with saphicism even though they all pretend to be bisexual.

>> No.14960218
File: 93 KB, 640x451, 2EE16876-7544-4815-B0F0-54859EA61FD1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14960218

>>14958972
Way to completely and utterly fail to respond to my post in a coherent manner.

Listen, if you don’t have a rebuttal, just take the loss and move on. Next time don’t dig in your heels and try to screech. It’s doubly embarrassing for you, because you have an identifiable name on an anon image board.

>it’s an ancient myth for women hurf durf hercules (which I only know from Disney)

How does that in any way, shape, or fucking form address the point that your initial “contribution”* to this thread was banal horse shit colored by the lens of your singular personality trait*?

*utter tripe
*h*mosexuality

>> No.14960237

>>14959676
>European myths as niggers

Um, can we like stop this? Thx

>> No.14960259

why is Op concerned about tumblr trends? oh because he is OP

>> No.14960551

>>14960075
AH YES. I forgot that one. Thank you.

>>14960095
I think it's Artemis/Selene/Hekate. But its likely just aspects of maiden/mother/"crone" and its all interchangeable.

>>14960183
Because I hang out here.

14960218
*Yawn*

>>14960259
I think he's the artist.

>> No.14960664

>>14955773
ok woman

>> No.14960682

>>14960551
>>14960009
>>14959878
>>14959861
>>14959790
>>14959576
Of course! The stupid fucking tumblrina who spams this board is defending that cringy fan-art with passion

>> No.14960786

>>14960218
Insanely based