[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/lit/ - Literature


View post   

File: 597 KB, 1653x2066, IMG_20190215_155027_248.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12725163 No.12725163 [Reply] [Original]

I just... really fucking hate Infinite Jest? I feel like I got meme'd into thinking it was good.

Look, I've read Joyce. Ulysses is often lumped into "the meme trilogy" with this book and I honestly find that unfair and insulting to Joyce.

To call Infinite Jest a "farce" would be to undercut the sheer magnitude of bullshit it employs. Hundreds of pages of nigh-endless, mandatory footnotes that establish a lot of important but ultimately pointless worldbuilding. I mean, not to call /ourguy/ David Foster Wallace a hack or anything, but his magnum opus just feels needlessly cryptic and tone-deaf.

Don't get meme'd into reading it, it's Atlas Shrugged for nihilists.

>> No.12725212

>>12725163
There is truly no point to the book at all, it’s only supposed to recreate the feeling of being bombarded by stimuli, much like the television and connected internet it predicts.

The book is explained by the little allegory about the prank Hal’s dad played on the academic community with the mirror reflected back on the audience. I forget the details because I read it 10 years ago.

>> No.12725394

>>12725163
>t-the meme trilogy is bad because LE MEMES XDDD
Shut the fuck up you retard they are the most discussed books of the board since forever its that simple now fuck off and kill yourself

>> No.12725420

Wow, finally someone has found the courage to stand up to David Foster Wallace and his book Infinite Jest

>> No.12725423

>>12725163
>This is my opinion. It is right; I am right. You should believe me because I am me.
Woah, strong argument.

>> No.12725501

>>12725423
Refute it then, peon.

>> No.12725505

>>12725394
The meme trilogy is bad because all three of those books are bad. They're overblown, pretentious, tryhard, downright incoherent at times, and praised by the most insufferable kinds of people.

https://www.google.com/amp/s/amp.pastemagazine.com/articles/2018/06/why-insufferable-people-love-infinite-jest.html

>> No.12725556

>>12725505
>to retarded to get a proper link on his phone
>hey guys check out my no-name zine
kek

>> No.12725708

>>12725556
>being this pedantic

>> No.12725731 [DELETED] 

someone post the pasta

>> No.12725738

>>12725708
>the literal first word of my post was a typo
>pedantic
;^)

>> No.12725771

>>12725738
Stop shitposting any time, DFW was a hack

>> No.12725779
File: 710 KB, 1044x495, 1407273651418.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12725779

>>12725771
what a fresh and unique perspective

>> No.12725787

Infinite Jest is pretty masturbatory but there are a lot good sections of writing and thought contained in it. I dont particularly think Wallace, pynchon, and joyce are all that similar in thematic concern though even if they all write encyclopedic "novels".

>> No.12725808

ME NO LIKE THING ME DIFFERENT

>> No.12725886

>>12725808
t. triggered DFWfag

>> No.12725898

>>12725779
Why the fuck is Ulysses in there? It's a classic isn't it?

Now Finnegans Wake is a meme book through and through. Why Ulysses and not that?

>> No.12725912
File: 252 KB, 517x323, 1408231180222.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12725912

>>12725898
Because >>12725394
>they are the most discussed books of the board since forever its that simple now fuck off and kill yourself
newfags these days

>> No.12725916

>>12725779
that macro is low-effort: the image

>> No.12725917

>>12725886
t. triggered snowflake

>> No.12725940

>>12725916
>hey guys this is the first time I'm seeing an 8 year old image and let me tell you, I'm gonna bitch
stop posting

>> No.12725944

>>12725917
M8, you're the one acting like a chimp over someone not enjoying something you enjoy

>> No.12725949 [DELETED] 

It's time 2666 was replace this garbage. All in favor say (you).

>> No.12725959

>>12725949
>muh latin american representation
Make you own meme trilogy banana breath quit being a wetback

>> No.12725967

/lit/ mk1 loved IJ because its aimed at humanities academic students.
I have no idea why post 2016 /lit/ like IJ as they are anti humanities, academia and post-modernism.

>> No.12725977

>>12725944
>phoneposter

>> No.12725987
File: 963 KB, 940x836, 1546372951586.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12725987

>>12725967
based melodramatic retard

>> No.12726047

>>12725977
Well, I can't argue with those dubs, but fuck you anyway.

>> No.12726084

>>12725967
Post 2016 /lit/ has a Nick Land fetish though which is pretty compatible with postmodernism, the humanities, and academia.

>> No.12726089
File: 57 KB, 500x628, 1540245444831.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12726089

Here OP. Have a nice day.

>> No.12726117

Ulysses - the only book i regret finishing to the last sentence. What a load of crap. "Classic".

>> No.12726221

>>12725898
fw is only a meme book to those who haven't read it
it's a slog of a read, since it's not really reading in the traditional sense. but it's also the funniest and punniest book ever, with an obscene number of parallel meanings interwoven in its sentences. I've unironically read FW twice, and it's far from gibberish. i wouldn't even consider it cryptic, since it reveals itself by simply reading it and doesn't require any decoding in the modern sense of the word.
fw is the monomyth and the world would be drastically different without it. easiest example is that campbell wouldn't have articulated the hero's journey, and if he hadn't done that, lucas wouldn't have cribbed the cycle when writing star wars. it's affected billions of people in a way that no other modern work has. it's the never ending story of everything. there is nothing new or novel to be found in any work outside the wake, past present or future. literally.
the burgess interpretation is pretty shit, but campbells skeleton guide is the foundation for basically all modern exegesis.

>> No.12726453

>>12726221
Woah buddy are you saying Joyce was the first to elaborate the mono-myth as such?

>> No.12726582

WHY DOES EVERYONE SAY DFW IS PRETENTIOUS AND ELITIST IF I READ HIS LOBSTER ESSAY AND FOUND NOTHING BUT WARMTH AND HUMILITY EXTENDED TO ME?

It felt like he was speaking directly to myself, and not anywhere did he use vocabulary or syntax or otherwise that was even slightly pompous. Why, then, would he do the very opposite in a large-scale book of his? If you have any pretentious passages from IJ, send me them so I can see for myself that you aren't just bullying the poor guy.

>> No.12726626

>>12726582
He comes across as smug because the book and his prose style in general has an endearing absurdity to it and it really rubs some people the wrong way

>> No.12726653

>>12725163
I have to agree. I was fucking underwhelmed by this. GR and Ulysses I was also memed into - and loved both.

>> No.12726664
File: 8 KB, 300x168, brainlet1.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12726664

>infinite jest
>the joke is on you for reading it

>> No.12726679

>>12725163
OP is based, I am at page 900 and I want to DFW myself (if you know what l mean)

>> No.12726686
File: 400 KB, 803x688, 1551086281168.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12726686

>>12726679

>> No.12726785

>>12725163
the book is good. it is okay to not like books OP. just because you don't like it doesn't mean others will feel the same.

>it's Atlas Shrugged for nihilists
this sentence is either bait or really, really stupid.

>> No.12726799
File: 124 KB, 750x1166, FB13380D-52D9-48CC-AA3D-EB19876A1EAB.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12726799

>>12726084

>> No.12726817

>>12725505
>le reddit buzzwords
You're on /lit/, faggot, act like it.

>> No.12726843

>>12725163

It's "well written," but I don't think it's a "great" work.

DFW was a very good writer, but I don't think IJ is a book for the ages. It's going to be remembered, but it's also going to be remembered as a high point (not sure if THE high point) of postmodernism.

PS. I lump Dave Eggers in this same category

>> No.12726852

>>12725505
>They're overblown, pretentious, tryhard, downright incoherent at times, and praised
>overblown
k.

>> No.12727103
File: 247 KB, 1280x960, trip_to_okinawa.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12727103

>>12725163
I'm glad I didn't read this post before I finally decided to read Infinite Jest. The book spoke to me, and was so full of compassion that it brought me to tears. The gimmick of endnotes wasn't a pain and sometimes got good use (Incandenza the Senior's filmography, for example). DFW made me care about Don Gately and Mario and Joelle enough to read every page and it was worth it.

I don't see how you found it cryptic. Everything is written in plain English. DFW's criticism of commercial culture wasn't exactly subtle, nor his value of empathy and relating to others.

>> No.12727134

>>12727103
Based ADposter

>> No.12727161

>>12727103
Was DFW a good person in real life? I really hate to hear of the scandals which have come to surround his name. From interviews, he seems like a very jovial and kind fellow.

>> No.12727504

>>12727161

He hung himself.

>> No.12727588

>>12726453
whoa buddy, is that what my post said?
fw is the only embodiment of the monomyth, for it is the monomyth, for it contains every story, every past and present.
campbell was one of the first to tackle the wake, and from his reading of fw did he articulate hero/1000 faces, et Al, from which lucas cribbed. without the wake, campbell most likely didn't attempt to formalize the hero journey, lucas didn't polish star wars on top of it
the most asinine thing about readers today is that everything must be qualified against it's negation to get anywhere. just read what was said, don't force the reader to say "I'm not saying..." over and over again.

>> No.12727601

>>12727161
he was a depressed tortured artist and pussyhound bound to fits of passionate rage, iirc he once tried to push the girl he was lusting after out of a car when they had a fight and plotted to murder her husband. Genius writer and great at interviews but probably not someone you would want to be too close with read "Every Love Story is a Ghost story" and "The End of the Tour" if you want more insight on his life

>> No.12727617

>>12727601
>plotted to murder her husband
Oh dear...

but okay i will thanks anon :3

>> No.12727671

>>12725163
Don't sperg because you didn't understand it and you're jealous you'll never write it. No matter how hard you hate it, this book is talked about every day on here, has been for a while, and will be for a long time. You're not that much smarter than most other people on here, so don't be so full of yourself.

>> No.12727785

it's way overated and he's an admitted plagiarist c&p'ed half the novel from early 90s web

>> No.12727786

>>12725163
>I just... really fucking hate Infinite Jest?
Do you? Are you sure about that? Is that a question or a statement? Talk and write properly, and stop using uptalk like some sort of Californian limp-wristed faggot.

>> No.12727789

>>12727785
plagiarized from which sources?

>> No.12727838

>>12725163
>IJ is NEEDLESSY CRYPTIC
>CLAIMS TO HAVE READ (likely didnt understand) ULYSSES
I'm SEETHING.

>> No.12727841

>>12727789
He didn't plagiarize.
He just lifted the idea of the entertainment from some short story that was buzzing around Cambridge (basilisk something-or-other) and he had VERY HEAVY Pynchon influence

>> No.12727850

Maybe you have to be american to understand it? Because I'm not american and I didn't get it

>> No.12727868

>>12727841
What's so great about Pynchon? Should I look into him?

>> No.12727891

I finished this book 2 days and felt that IJ was a chore to read. The book was unique and creative but ultimately it just wasn't enjoyable to read except the parts about Gately and Addicts.

>> No.12727894

>>12725163
run an acrostic program on the corpus, you'll find his admission of plagiarism

>> No.12727905
File: 48 KB, 456x356, 1431154675154.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
12727905

>>12727868
He's bananas

>> No.12727916

>>12727894
no you won't.
prove it.

>> No.12728250

>>12725163
>Pointless worldbuilding
Bait

>> No.12728571

>>12727841
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BLIT_(short_story)
It was this.

>> No.12730298

>>12725163
OP shut up you don't.

>> No.12730635

>>12727786
Seconded.

>> No.12730655

>>12728571
That's just riffing on The Zahir

>> No.12730681

>>12727504
hanged

>> No.12730738

>>12726221
Holy fucking shit are you for real forgetting Jung and Frued? Hahahaha was a Ponce