/lit/ - Literature

>>23133745
>love Ali so he is the chosen successor
Where does that love come from then? All of their praise about Ali is how he helped the prophet and how he aided the prophet and their condemnation of the enemies of Ali is because they betrayed the prophet and thus God.

>>23133771
If one believes in a diety other than God he is not a Shia nor a Muslim by definition. There was a former comoanion of imam Ja'far Al-Sadiq a.s who apostated and started claiming that Al-Sadiq was literally God. He attracted followers and even talked, or tried to convince Al-Sadiq's eldest son Ismail that his father was God. There is a funny hadith in Shia books in which this person's name is mentioned in front of imam Al-Sadiq and he starts cursing him (la'n, asking Allah to withhold his mercy), then he starts cursing his companions, and those who question cursing him, and those who refrain from cursing him, and then says those who don't curse him are cursed by God lmao.

>>23133782
He's like the second main guy in the history of islam. If you mean mentioned by name in the Quran, the only person mentioned by name who lived amongst the propher, other than Abu Lahab who is condemned to hell, is Zaid RA and no muslim believes he is the greatest muslim because his name is mentioned lol. But both sects believe verses are explicitly about him or refer to him but don't say his name. Such as 5:55 and 2:207. If name is how we rank people then Moses must be in first place.

>>23133784
The issue is because they believe the prophet died from poisoning because he said he "feels" the poison from the jewish woman three years ago. And now he says he "feels" his aorta being severed. Also it is a very specific and peculiar thing to say when it is the exact same phrase in the Quran. God has made falsehood clear it seems.

>>23133836
>t. Reddit

>>23133851
No, the shahada specifically states belief in one God and Muhammad. Saying you believe in one God and Moses doesn't prove you are a muslim, jews believe that too. Also prophets are equal in that they all relay the revelation and all are equally prophets. But they are not equal in rank. That would contradict the Quran. "Those are the Messengers! We have exalted some of them above others" (2:253).
And "Allah preferred Adam and Noah and the Family of Abraham and the Family of ´Imran above (all His) creatures some of them are descendants of the others, and Allah is all-hearing, all-knowing.." (3:33-34)

>>23115613

>>23095992
>I will only date Asian women

>>21569899
Yeah you're faggot who can't make new words up and goes to reddit and copy+pastes your entire personality and then gets mad when it's pointed out, then tries to project it on others.

>>21372280
>I need a book that debunks islam
T.

>>18079156
>>18079173
>>18079175
>>18079185
>>18079225
>>18079231
>>18079238
>>18079242
>>etc. etc.

back to /leftypol/ you go

>>17195427
>meditating

>>16471702

>>16292988
>>16292968
>>16292962
>>16292941
>>16292937
>>16292902
>>16292897
>>16292896
>Why yes, I do feel there's something very profound between me and this retarded animal, how could you tell?

>The God Delusion
>The Moral Landscape
>The Selfish Gene
>Nietzsche
>Isaac Asimov
>Jordan Peterson

>>15327345
>why yes, I’m a moral realist, how did you know?

>>15146045
>Tesla, the greatest scientist

>>14714588
>IngSoc isn't real socialism

>>14312641
>NOOOOO DON'T BE A CONSUMER UNDER CAPITALISM. Be a HAPPIER consumer under my particular 19th century ideology that says an idustrial society of consumers will be much better if the merchants aren't in charge

> I don't care about politics, race, nationality or gender. I just want to be happy.

>existentialist

>>13979375
>Aquinas

>>13408785
Pic related: the novel adaption