/jp/ - Otaku Culture

[Anonymous No.]

/jp/ there thousands of eroge out there. what's the best one?

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767432
how about this one *grabs cock*

[Anonymous No.]

The one you that you dislike.

[Anonymous No.]

Whichever you like best.

[Anonymous No.]

Going by VNDB, MLA is. So MLA?

[Anonymous No.]

Cut kageaki some slack nerd, he's gone through a lot.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767447
>trusting vndb ratings
next u gonna say umineko is a good vn

[Anonymous No.]

MLA is clearly the best VN.
Whether it has the best story or characters or w/e is a different debate, but it's hands down the greatest work within its medium.

[Anonymous No.]

ITT mla scum

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767462
You mean it's the best translated one.

[Anonymous No.]

MLA is shit.

All that I read about Baldr Sky suggests that it's even worse.

So I'll go with Muramasa.

[Anonymous No.]

You should ask /v/ about the best video game of all time too!

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767462
>it may not have the best story or characters, but it's just the best game ever!

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767471
BS is a lot more consistent than MLA, but MLA's story has more peaks.

[Anonymous No.]

Fate/Stay Night is

Haters gonna hate but search your feelings. You know it to be true

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767462
A polished turd is still a turd no matter how shiny you make it.

[Anonymous No.]

F/SN and ever17. Prove me werong

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767478
I'm not going to call F/SN the best eroge ever, far from it, but you know, it's not like it's worse than MLA.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767477
Ohhh, it's been a while since I saw that image.
Reported.

[Anonymous No.]

Tsukihime 2

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767477
I agree with this. Muv Luv was a rollercoaster bouncing between "really good" and "really shitty", but Baldr Sky stayed consistently good all the way (save for Sky 2 forcing you to reread the flashbacks in 記憶遡行).

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767432
>putting Muramasa together with MuvLuv aka DaCapo Mecha Edition
Good god OP, doesn't it hurt to live ?
I can understand how some people could find Baldr Sky comparable, I don't, but MuvLuv ? SERIOUSLY ?
Just... no...

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767496
>Muv Luv was a rollercoaster bouncing between "really good" and "really shitty"
Sucks for me, I guess.

The really shitty parts were so many and long that they completely killed my care for the really good parts.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767496
>(save for Sky 2 forcing you to reread the flashbacks in 記憶遡行).
Why didn't they release a patch or something? i wouldn't have minded reading new memories before Makoto's route, but the whole thing was just skip button till october.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767510
Well, 6 or so months is a long time, so I guess they did that to refresh the memories of those who did Dive1 before Dive2 came out.
Forcing it was kinda stupid, though.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767432
I love it how the upper picture has some hardboiled guy staring into your soul, the middle one has some awesome lesbian in a latex suit while the the lowest one has some school romance bullshit going on.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767525
You must feel very witty right now.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767529
he got nothing on me
>upper: bleach
>middle: naruto
>bottom: one piece

[Anonymous No.]

who narutu here

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767535
Upper is Naruto, the MC does those hand seal things to summon his armor. Clearly a shitty Naruto rip-off.

>>8767453
To be honest he knew exactly what sort of shit he was getting into.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767535
Is Suhahibi death note?

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767586
Elfen Lied.

[Anonymous No.]

Now, I don't want to sound like an obnoxious fanboy or anything as I love all 3 games to death and people can like what they want, but it truly boggles my mind how anyone can even compare MLA and BS to Muramasa and try to pass it as a fact that those two aforementioned games are of better quality and try to pass it as a fact without basis (like Moogy).

Muramasa shits on both so much it's not even funny. Muramasa takes many original approaches, which I welcome with open arms, on the conventional justice/heroism/revenge you name it bullshit that is prominent in every VN or anime and even literature ever. The story plays out the least you expect it to and it subverts many tropes, which I find quite unusual for eroge. I could go on what makes it a timeless title.

You could argue that BS has gameplay which makes it superior, or that MLA has great presentation and visuals (Muramasa too by the way), but I think that's beside the point here when the quality of VNs is usually derived from the quality of the story and characters.

[Anonymous No.]

Now, I don't want to sound like some obnoxious fanboy or anything as I love all 3 games to death and people can like whatever they want, but it truly boggles my mind how anyone can even compare MLA and BS to Muramasa and try to pass it as a fact that those two aforementioned games are of better quality and try to pass it as a fact without basis (like Moogy).

Muramasa shits on both so much it's not even funny. Muramasa takes many original approaches, which I welcome with open arms, on the conventional justice/heroism/revenge you name it bullshit that is prominent in every VN or anime and even literature ever. The story plays out the least you expect it to and it subverts many tropes, which I find quite unusual for eroge. I could go on what makes it a timeless title.

You could argue that BS has gameplay which makes it superior, or that MLA has great presentation and visuals (Muramasa too by the way), but I think that's beside the point here when the quality of VNs is usually derived from the quality of the story and characters.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767651

[Anonymous No.]

Now, I don't want to sound like some obnoxious fanboy or anything as I love all 3 games to death and people can like whatever they want, but it truly boggles my mind how anyone can even begin to compare MLA and BS to Muramasa and try to pass it as a fact without basis that those two aforementioned games are of better quality (like Moogy did).

Muramasa shits on both so much it's not even funny. The game takes many original approaches, which I welcome with open arms, on the conventional justice/heroism/revenge you name it bullshit that is prominent in every VN or anime and even literature ever. The story plays out the least you expect it to and it subverts many tropes, which I find quite unusual for eroge. I could go on what makes it a timeless title.

You could argue that BS has gameplay which makes it superior, or that MLA has great presentation and visuals (Muramasa too by the way), but I think that's beside the point here when the quality of VNs is usually derived from the quality of the story and characters.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767660
Grimderp shit.

2/10 would not replay.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767659
i think it would ghelp your cause a lot more if you posted arguements instead of image macroing

[Anonymous No.]

I'm going to post a picture of Moogy every time you mention him.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767667
>ghelp
>arguements
>posting image macros himself
Get english-peasant scum.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767667
>ghelp
>arguements
>posting image macros himself
Get out english-only peasant scum, this thread is for the big boys

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767659
I feel sad... Leave /jp/ for a few months.
Come back and see only one person calling out the person using the spiderman image macro.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767706
>Leave /jp/ for a few months.
Try leaving for a few years and coming back to see literally nothing has changed.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767667
I was being ironic, haha

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767713
Atleast the trips change, right?

... Or do Currybut/Sion, Arc, MAGATROID
Still roam around?

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767535
i bet you like clannad.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767743
I liked it when it was unpopular.

[Anonymous No.]

Muv-Luv didn't used to get so explicitly shit on as much until it got translated. Before that we could have intelligent discussions on why the end result of the combination of its flaws and strengths still qualified it to be in an image with BS and Muramasa, but now everyone has to go out of their way to declare it to be absolutely nothing but shit.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767713
What years were you gone from?

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767726
Trips, trips never changes.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767762
Don't you know, as soon as something is translated it becomes shit.
Expect the same to happen with Baldr Sky, and with Muramasa as well if it ever gets translated.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767771
A while after Baldr Sky came out, sometime mid-2009.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767781
>Expect the same to happen with Baldr Sky, and with Muramasa as well if it ever gets translated.
Not so sure about this as BS's and Muramasa's flaws aren't as glaring as Muv-luv's. The only way to troll those games would be making shit up and try to force it, like "grimdark shit durrhurr" on muramasa's part

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767771
A while after Baldr Sky came out, sometime mid-2009, till a few weeks ago.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767801
They are, they're just different flaws.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767801
It's happened with every single title that's been translated.
Those two will be no different.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767801
Katawa Shoujo - The best the medium has to offer, if you have played it dont bother about the rest
FSN - All the heroines are sluts!
Tsukihime - Twilight lite
Umineko - Newfags first Sound Novel.
PW - FSN ripoff.
ignanock - furry disney shit
Saya no Uta - really really average
Kazoku Keikaku - "The powerlevel is over 9000", CENSORSHIP
Phantom - DVD FORMAT
Sharin no Kuni - Overrated and pretentious shit hurr durr I purposely act as if I hurt my legs, I smoke drugs NO I DONT just trolling
Kikokugai - Kill Bill the VN
Hanachirasu - Kill Bill the VN except you are playing on the side that is being hunted by the revenger
Ever17 - Archimedes and physics class
Cross Channel - pantsu jokes everywhere
YMK - hipster drug is so cool vn
Swan Song - autism the vn
kira kira - k-on the vn
wanko - furry shit
Muramasa - Mecha shit ver. A
Gekkou - furry shit
3days - Higurashi meets Naruto
11eyes - lol Bleach lol slut
Baldr Sky - Mecha shit ver. B
Little Busters, Air, Kanon - KEY AIDS
Planetarian - chobits the vn
G-senjou no Maou - lol retarded coincidence plot twist with 75% shitty heroines and fake incest
Clannad - lol lets collect dragonballs and revive my waifu
Stein's;Gate - pretentious sci-fi mumbojumbo shit
Chaos;Head - more like head full of plot holes
Sharnoth - copypasta shit is copypasta is copypasta
YU-NO - shit art
Sumaga - meta shit with shit protagonist
999 - Saw the VN
Muv Luv - I rather watch ESPN for real lacross or Iron chef
Muv Luv Alternative - Quantum physics and mechanics class
Sengoku Rance - glorified rape
Symphonic Rain - wannabe rhythm game
Utawarerumono: shitty srpg with furry shit
Kara no Shoujo - Babby's first grimdark, prostitution, gore (SO REAL DEAL XD)
Monmosu Quest - boring rape my face when I purposely lose rpg with monster sex organs gimmick

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767811
Yeah, it's probably the same in substance.

It's hard to get good perspective from the inside since it only seems like everything is getting shittier all the time.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767713
Why dont you drop by /a/ or /vg/, they talk about the same topics as /jp/. Perhaps you might find them appealing.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767824
Blah blah blah
>Phantom - DVD FORMAT
Blah blah

... Wait.
That's the only complaint you could find for Phantom?
Does that mean it's like... The best ever?
Or you were too half arsed to make an actual attack at the game itself (Just the medium it was delivered on)

[Anonymous No.]

Now, I don't want to sound like some obnoxious fanboy or anything as I love all 3 games to death and people can like whatever they want, but it truly boggles my mind how anyone can even begin to compare Muramasa and BS to MLA and try to pass it as a fact without basis that those two aforementioned games are of better quality.

mla shits on both so much it's not even funny. The game takes many original approaches, which I welcome with open arms, on the conventional dimension travel/alien/robots you name it bullshit that is prominent in every VN or anime and even literature ever. The story plays out the least you expect it to and it subverts many BETAs, which I find quite unusual for eroge. I could go on what makes it a timeless title.

You could argue that BS has gameplay which makes it superior, or that Muramasa has great themes and and characters (MLA too by the way), but I think that's beside the point here when the quality of VNs is usually derived from eroge website rankings.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767867
>Muramasa has great themes and characters (MLA too by the way)
>MLA too by the way

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767867
>mfw this is posted for the fourth time ITT

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767867
This really doesn't work with MuvLuv.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767828
If anything I'd say it's maybe even a little better than I remember it being. Meido seems to be pretty decent.

>>8767855
I looked at /vg/ and it honestly surprised me, my first thought was "Wow /v/ has REALLY changed." before I realized my mistake. But they only really seem to talk about translated stuff and they move too fast and it frightens me.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767867
>Muramasa has great themes
I see people bringing this up all the time, can someone explain what the fuck makes Muramasa thematically superior?

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767912
Use the archive, your question has been answered before.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767920
Too many spoilers there, don'ty wanna get spoiled bro I just want the outline

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767889
Just checked it out myself.
My god it is 2012 April, basically a year after MLA translation came out and they are still talking about it with Fate and CC.
It is like I went through a time machine.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767926
vndb always has nice little one line descriptions? Why not try that out for starters.

http://vndb.org/v2016

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767938
Well those don't really tell much about the execution of said themes, I mean "Revenge" doesn't tell much

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767947
Revenge, heroes and war.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767934
Being monolingual is suffering. You are stuck on bread and water for years.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767432
All 3 are good anon, but SubaHibi is the best one. When you finish, you won't be the same and thats guaranteed
http://vndb.org/v3144

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767934
I don't think they are bad posters for the most part but they just talk about the same games everyone has talked about for years. It is monotonous, I don't know how anyone could stand it unless they were super new to the medium. I wouldn't mind /jp/'s VN threads being a little faster though.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767953
>subashitty
>better than anything

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767965
Who are you quoting?

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767965
>>8767953
Official /jp/ list of kusoge
1. Muv Luv
2. Cross†Channel
3. Umineko
4. Yume Miru Kusuri
5. Subahibi
6. Fate/Stay Night
7.Muramasa

Official /jp/ list of kamige
1. Clannad
2. Planetarian
3. ONE
4. Baldr Sky
5. Tsukihime
6. Grisaia
7. Little Busters!

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767971
mother fucker

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767968
There are translated shit on that list, faggot.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767953
>Yaoi Rape 1.0
you hate me?

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767968
>kamige
More like keyshit with their retarded and disabled girls.
Please dont group BS with those shit.

[Anonymous No.]

Let's get some nominations for these three games.

Which game has the best story?
Which game is the most well-written?
Which game has the best characters?
Which game has the best OST?
Which game has the best art?
Which game has the best VAs?

Also I want your opinion on the OPs

Which game has the best OP?
Which game has the best OP song?

Muramasa: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Le2zxWrD294
MLA: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UENpZitXCCc
Baldr Sky: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zD_ecJalA2s

Lastly: what is your favorite book?

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767978
>Lastly: what is your favorite book?

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767978
>Which game has the best OST?
all of them
http://www.nicovideo.jp/mylist/18922015

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767978
damn they all have goot OPs, is this just a coincidence??

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767978
>Which game has the best OST?
Going with Clannaids.
Maeda Jun should just stop writing and concentrate on making music.

[Anonymous No.]

http://www.nicovideo.jp/watch/sm9028073

/thread

[Anonymous No.]

What, Bible Black not eroge enough?

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767978
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bZWd_7Ud-Lc
Is this a VN OST thread now?

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767999
he probably wanted answers about the three games he mentioned. Anyway,
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4oWNLGv0gRg

[Anonymous No.]

>>8768003
Is that composed by maeda jun?

[Anonymous No.]

>>8768010
http://vgmdb.net/artist/11443
You can search nico or youtube for his cover.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8768010
according to vgmdb, yes.

I'm more of a Shinji Orito guy, though
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZUsSSLlfq9s

[Anonymous No.]

>Asking /jp/ for recommendations on anything.

Son... Ishiggity.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767978

Muramasa is mecha too? God dammit, why is japan so fucking obsessed with giant robots? Can't they come up with anything new?

[Anonymous No.]

>>8768111
Because robots are always cool, no matter what they do. Just like lolis. Now imagine: a VN with both mechas piloting lolis...the masterpiece of our time!

[Anonymous No.]

>>8768111
Power armor is not actually mecha.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8768119
Neither is cyber armor, when you think about it.

MLA is the only trumecha out of the 3.

[Anonymous No.]

ntsa

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767508
I'd have to agree with this. Everybody says it's so sad, but I was fairly apathetic to the whole thing. Meiya was pretty cute, though.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767660
Except if we're talking about eroGE, not VNs, Baldr curbstomps Muramasa and MLA.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8770525
What? Shut up.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8770525
Whoops, serves me right for replying to kopipe.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8770536
Fuck you man, I was going to delete it in a minute. Now the shame will haunt me for years.

[Anonymous No.]

>>8767968
>keyshit
>grisaia
>tsukihime

I hate Subahibi and MLA just like any other autist, but this is just too much.

[Anonymous No.]

epic for the win

[Anonymous No.]

>>8770638
who are you quoting

[Anonymous No.]

>>8773280
ur mom

[Anonymous No.]

>>8770638
Get a load of this try-hard.

[Anonymous No.]

They're all good.