[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/jp/ - Otaku Culture


View post   

File: 102 KB, 500x387, 1326199431529.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8692938 No.8692938 [Reply] [Original]

Anime Thread


What's are your favorite anime?

>> No.8692943

Don't bother me with that low-brow pish posh, /jp/ is far above that gutter trash.

>> No.8692944
File: 355 KB, 600x600, 1301878025488.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8692944

I haven't watched any animez this season.

>> No.8692951

u posted it XD
best love story ever told

>> No.8692952

I just can't get myself to watch anime anymore. I'm more into western TV now.

>> No.8692956

I like pretty much everything I watch. How do I determine what my favorite is?

>> No.8692957
File: 58 KB, 230x258, homu.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8692957

I haven't watched anime in months.

>> No.8692958
File: 262 KB, 920x920, anime.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8692958

This 9x9 showcases my favorite animes.

>> No.8692963

>>8692958
Lain | Kaiba | Mo No No Ke
LoGH | Zeta Gundam | Boogiepop Phantom
Naruto | Robot Carnival | Utena

>> No.8692961

>>8692958
Worst taste I've ever seen

>> No.8692962

>>8692958

2/9

I wish I could kill you purely for liking Utena

>> No.8692964

>>8692958
1/9
pleb

>> No.8692969

Puella Magi
Tweeny Witches
Sora No Woto
Kino's Journey
Strike Witches
Last Exile

>> No.8692973

>>8692963
Naruto? That is not naruto.

>> No.8692974
File: 19 KB, 217x217, 13258765001.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8692974

Puella Magi
Nichijou
Kill Me Baby
Ano Hi
Steins Gate

>> No.8692988

>>8692974
You started watching anime in 2011.

>> No.8693001

That one with the girl that grows a penis when you pour hot water on her

>> No.8693007

>>8693001
Wasn't it the other way around?

>> No.8693008

Index
Milky Holmes
Card Captor Sakura
Evangelion
Gundam

>> No.8693011

>>8692958
Great taste.

>> No.8693006

dougram
layzner
votoms
FLAG
gasaraki
zeta
XD

>> No.8693017

>>8693008
WHICH GUNDAM HUH? YOU CAN'T JUST SAY GUNDAM

>> No.8693022

>>8693017
Probably Gundam SEED

>> No.8693031

Lain
Mushishi
Aria
Nekojiru-sou
Evangelion

>> No.8693038

Evangelion
Bakemonogatari
Elfen Lied
Mnemosyne
GiTS - 1st movie
Jin-Roh

>> No.8693040
File: 47 KB, 363x612, 1271228598736.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693040

Mai Otome
Touka Gettan
Turn A Gundam
K-ON
Code Geass

>> No.8693034

>>8693017
I like a few of them equally so it is hard to choose just one.

>> No.8693042

>>8693031
Alright

>>8693038
Good

>>8693040
Not so good

>> No.8693043
File: 22 KB, 188x204, 1330897343797.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693043

>>8692961
>>8693011
Same person.

>> No.8693055

List of anime approved by /jp/:
Index
Railgun
Modoka
Naruto

And that's it.

>> No.8693059

>>8693055
u forgot Bleach

>> No.8693060

Gunbuster
Evangelion
Disappearance
Madoka
Kaiji

>> No.8693061
File: 107 KB, 932x651, 1331354130549.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693061

>>8693055
You forgot Autism: The Anime.

>> No.8693064

>>8693055
Are you sure you meant Naruto and not Narutaru? One is the complexdeconstruction of beloved RPG games and the other is kiddy ninja shit.

>>8693060
Alright

>> No.8693066

>>8693055

you forgot hanasaku iroha

best anime of the millennium from now on the two accepted anime on jp will be logh and iroha because its just that good

>> No.8693075

When are we getting a 2hu anime?

>> No.8693070

>>8693042
I'm too real for you

>> No.8693073

>>8693055
Remove Madoka and Naruto because those shows are rubbish, and add in Milky Holmes.

>>8693066
That show was awful.

>> No.8693078

>>8693073
Fuck you asshole.

>> No.8693080
File: 184 KB, 1280x720, laughing_detectives.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693080

>>8693064
>Narutaru
>complexdeconstruction of beloved RPG games
Bokurano is the only good thing Mohiro has ever done.

>> No.8693082

>>8693038

same person here:

Spice and Wolf - how could I have forgotten this?!
and Code Geass, Mirai Nikki <- guilty pleasures

And by guilty pleasures, I mean that I confess that I watch Mirai Nikki only for Yuno and Code Geass only for LeLouch. There, I said it.

>> No.8693091

>>8693082
There's nothing wrong with enjoying entertaining shows. This isn't /a/.

>> No.8693087

I find it hard to believe you guys are seriously in almost unanimous agreeance that that guy with the 3x3 full of classics has shit taste and the only list someone said was "good" thus far had Elfin Lied on it.

>> No.8693088
File: 111 KB, 1280x720, 1290198196611.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693088

What about Rika's anime?

>> No.8693098

>>8693064
One is trying too hard while the other isn't.

>> No.8693106

>>8693087

Tbh, Elfen Lied is possibly only there for nostalgia. It was the first anime I watched and was my gateway drug.

It didn't age that well, unfortunately, when I rewatched it a couple of years later. It seemed much better in my memory when I had less exposure, experience, and understanding, but I nevertheless have a soft spot in my heart for it.

Also, just remembered: NHK

>> No.8693111

TTGL
Turn-A
Votoms
Tetsujin 28-gou
Macross
Gundam SEED

>> No.8693115

>>8693087
If I said Citizen Kane, 8 1/2, Godfather, 7 Samurai and Vertigo as my favorite movies, I'd be a pseudo-intellectual lemming with no actual personal taste at all.

Good taste comes from picking favorites that may not be the best, but have some sort of merit, charm, intrigue, or artistry that attracts a person to it, regardless of the overall quality.

That 9x9 is basically the same as some weaboo listing all the Miyazaki films ever made.

>> No.8693116

>>8693075

When I move to Japan to write it.

Give me some time for fucks sake.

>> No.8693121

>>8693115
>9x9
81 CLASSICA ANIMES

>> No.8693128

Gungrave
Entire Full Metal Panic series
Railgun
08th MS Team

I don't watch a lot of moe shit. That's probably why I don't watch much anime at all anymore.

>> No.8693124

cowboy bebop
I also love samurai champloo
ive finished, recently, Baccano! and puella magi
Im not deeply into animes
my first was either magnetic rose and those with it or spirited away. you could say both.

>> No.8693134

>>8693124
also, I call now baccano! and cowboy bebops soundtracks GOD LIKE
And Im about to watch DRRR!

>> No.8693136

>>8693128

>implying there isn't any anime worth watching that doesn't have moe shit in it

>> No.8693141

Eva

Also notable:
LoGH
Rakkyo
PMMM
Baccano

>> No.8693143

>>8693082
>Spice and Wolf

First season was alright, second season was meh. Holo's character just devolves into a clingy, whiny, jealous little bitch in the second season.

>> No.8693139

>>8693128
It's awfully silly to complain about moe on /jp/.

>> No.8693151
File: 9 KB, 148x189, 1324428978568.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693151

>>8693128
>I don't watch moe shit
>Railgun

>> No.8693149
File: 37 KB, 719x646, 1331471320329.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693149

>>8693128
I've been avoiding Railgun like the plague just based on the shitposting I've seen from it but if someone whose favorite anime is 08th MS Team likes it maybe I should give it a shot.

>> No.8693156

>>8693149
It's actually pretty similar to 08th MS.

>> No.8693159

Anime was never good.

>> No.8693160

>>8693149
>>8693156
It's funny because Railgun is good and 08th MS is the worst entry of the Gundam franchise.

>> No.8693170

>>8693160
08th MS? The worst? Have you even seen Gundam AGE?

>> No.8693166

>>8693143

Ah, but her breakdown in the second season was all worth it...character development, you know? Also, I think that by that time the viewer has already formed an opinion of Holo that it was acceptable to segue more into sequestered territories in order to stretch viewer's expectations. A repeat of season 1's formula would just be lacking.

Still, I can't shake the feeling that they rushed the ending/ran out of budget

>>8693139

Moe is okay, but only for designated waifus. Nothing else is allowed to be moe.

/yandere

>> No.8693168

>>8693160
It was the only Gundam that I've seen and liked, but I'm not really a mecha fan.

>> No.8693174

>>8693149

It's pretty much like a SoL with some action mixed in. Though it was a bit too much on the SoL side for my taste. Instead of focusing on the story I felt like I was watching K-On with superpowers. I mean, Mugino didn't even show up.

>> No.8693180

azumanga daioh
logh
akagi
eva movies
madoka
nanoha A
minami-ke
tatami galaxy
macross plus
>>8692958
Such shit taste for lumping logh with such filth.

>> No.8693184

>>8693174
Uhh no. Please don't compare Railgun to K-ON. K-ON is the most boring modern anime I've seen. How you can say Railgun is the same just with super powers, even though it's a completely different genre, is mind boggling, unless you consider any anime with slice of life bits to be like K-ON. And Mugino will be in the next season.

>> No.8693189

>>8693184
>next season.
;_; by the way FUCK MUGINO I just finished reading her fight with Shiage and that was a fucking terrible fight filled with "Shiage luckily dodged that" over and over.

>> No.8693195

boku no milky star

>> No.8693206

Reported.

>>>/a/

>> No.8693201

Clannad
Angel Beats
Madoka
Toradora
Haruhi
Code Geass
AnoHana
Death Note
Eva
Baccano
Anything by Makoto Shinkai

Come at me bro

>> No.8693217

nanoha
initial d
queen's blade

>> No.8693212

>>8693206
Please review the global rules before posting again. Thanks.

>> No.8693222

>>8693184

I can compare the two because basically the entire first season of Railgun just appealed to moefags. That's what it was for. Cute girls doing cute things.

>> No.8693219

>>8693201
Entry level tastes but you have potential to improve with more knowledge and exposure.

>> No.8693223

>>8692958
Nice, Boogiepop Phantom is one of my favourites as well

>> No.8693224

>>8693212
Please visit /jp/ for more than a couple hours before posting.

>> No.8693229

>>8693222
Considering I am not a moefag and typically do not enjoy 'moe' anime, I am inclined to disagree.

>> No.8693232

>>8693219
There are far more worthy posts of being called "entry-level" in this thread.

>> No.8693230

Akagi
Kaiji
Planetes
Golden Boy
Hikaru no Go

These are all the anime I rated "Masterpiece" on ANN.

>> No.8693234
File: 179 KB, 850x1165, simoun5542f94f.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693234

Giant Robo OAV for the glorious soundtracks. The animation and cool characters aren't bad either. It took 6 years to produce six 50 minute episodes and you can feel and hear the quality in each one.

Simoun for how it focuses on themes about the modern war in the middle east except told through these unisex alien girls who pilot magical universe altering aircraft. That fictional setting was crazy, but I'll probably remember it until the end of my days. Soundtrack was really amazing too. Also it has /jp/'s favorite girl Aaeru.

>> No.8693236

Macross should be /jp/'s choice over Gundam for obvious reasons, but then again /jp/ has shitty taste 8 times out of 10.

No mention of Ichigo Mashimaro makes me sad.

>> No.8693237

>>8693234
>Simoun
I thought you didn't like yurishit?

>> No.8693235

>Clannad
>Angel Beats
>Toradora
>Haruhi
>Code Geass
>AnoHana
>Death Note
They are fine being your favorite but these are just slightly above average. Angel Beats is downright shit with the OST being the only good thing about it. DN has a shitty 2nd half.
Watch better stuff.

>> No.8693238
File: 987 KB, 500x281, 1329644293535.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693238

Evangelion
Darker Than Black
Samurai Champloo
Haibane Renmei
Bakemonogatari
Bounen no Xamdou
Madoka
Now and Then, Here and There
Serial Experiments Lain

Am I the only one in this thread with good taste?

>> No.8693240

All the anime I've ever watched neatly fills up a 3x3.

Reported for >>>/a/.

Fuck the police.

>> No.8693241

>>8693238
>Darker Than Black
>Samurai Champloo
>Haibane Renmei
>Bakemonogatari
>Bounen no Xamdou
>Madoka
>Now and Then, Here and There
>Serial Experiments Lain
>good taste
What?

>> No.8693245

>>8693229

It was mixed. I'm not saying there was mindless moefaggotry like K-On, but the element was obviously there. I'm not saying it makes it bad specifically, I enjoyed the anime. I just wished they'd have cut back on it some.

>> No.8693248

>>8693245
> moefaggotry
Stop that

>> No.8693251
File: 36 KB, 340x460, 1329268832060.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693251

>>8693241
Nice attempt at trolling, but it won't work peasant.

>> No.8693259

>>8693253
Hellsing, Twilight except shit.
Darker than Black? More like Browner than SHIT
Neon Genesis Evangelion, makes about as much sense as a pedophile in a retirement home.
Beck, if I wanted to watch shitty bands, I would go see Tool live.
One Piece, if I wanted to watch a good shounen I would watch Naruto.
Eureka 7, more like Gurren Lagann 2.
Serial Experiments Lain? More like Serial Experiments LAME shitsux
Vinland Saga, shitty manga and even worse anime. 2 episodes in and I fell asleep.
Koi Kaze, if I thought incest was wrong I would stop having sex with my little sister.
Grave of the Fireflies? If I wanted to watch a whiny cunt and his little sister fuck around I'd go to Chuck E. Cheese.
Golden Boy? If I wanted to see a genius get horny, I'd videotape myself masturbating.
Mononoke, if I wanted to see a crossdressing, homosexual pothead wearing make-up, I'd move to Brazil.
Claymore, looks like a dick, strong beginning and middle but a cheesy ending.
Mushishi? More like MushiSHIT
Vagabond, one episode in and I fell asleep
Ghost in the Shell, pretentious shit with walls of text. I'd rather watch Code Geass than this piece of shit.
Cowboy Bebop, Shitty ripoff of Trigun
The Girl who Leapt through time? I wish she leapt through a meat grinder.
Baccano? More like BAKA NO!
Natsume? Like MushiSHIT wasn't gay enough already
Interstella 5555? If I wanted to watch cheesy music videos, I'd turn on MTV.
Yotsuba. Stupid little bitch runs around and acts "lol so kawaii". NOTHING HAPPENS
Hajime no Ippo? If I wanted to see fags jerk eachother off in a steamy shower room, I'd go to a bathhouse.

>> No.8693252

>>8693237
It isn't yuri thankfully. The protag is male for all intents and purposes according to the series creator.

>> No.8693253

>>8693245
darker than black more like browner than shit LAMO

>> No.8693262

>>8693259
> if I wanted to see a crossdressing, homosexual pothead wearing make-up, I'd move to Brazil.

you have crossed the line

>> No.8693271

>>8693252
wow, he actually believes that.

>> No.8693272

Maria Holic. Traps got old two years ago.
Kino no Tabi? If I wanted to watch a dyke on a motorcycle, I'd go visit San Francisco instead.
Ichigo Mashimaro, fanservice without fanservice.
Aria, a show about nothing.
FLCL, boring, unfunny, LOL SO RANDUM XD shit.
BLAME! If I wanted buildings and walking, I'd go outside
Welcome to the NHK, if I wanted to watch a loser, I would stare at the mirror.
Kaiji, atrocious character design and completely contrived plot.
Planetes. As empty as space.
Legend of the Gay Lactating Homosexuals.
Cromartie Highschool, Lucky Star with men.
Berserk, shitty anime and even worse manga.
Full Metal Panic? More like Code Geass with a shitty tsundere.
Zero no Tsukaima, more like Harry Potter: The Animation
5 Centimetres Per Second? More like 5 Wallpapers Per Second
Cowboy Bebop? More like Cowgay Begay. Shitty music and plotless style-over-substance bullshit.
Azumanga Daioh, shitty ripoff of Lucky Star.
Gurren Lagann, not so good.
RahXephon? If I wanted to watch a shitty Eureka Seven clone, I'd watch Evangelion
ARIA? I liked it better when it was called naptime.
Outlaw Star, One Piece in space.
Gintama, Bobobo with shittier animation.
Bartender? more like BOREtender.
Sayonara Zetsubou Sensei? One look and I said sayonara to this piece of shit.
Gurren Lagann, childish Drill-penis show.

>> No.8693276

>>8693262

Faggot, mononoke is shit.

>> No.8693282
File: 34 KB, 300x412, simoun.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693282

>>8693236
>Macross should be /jp/'s choice over Gundam for obvious reasons
I like Macross as much as the next guy but it doesn't stand up to the top tier Gundam series.

>No mention of Ichigo Mashimaro makes me sad.
It was somewhat entertaining but I don't see it making people's favourite anime ever lists.

>>8693238
Most of those shows aren't too great, but at least you have Evangelion I guess.

>>8693252
Stop it Zunbar. You and I both know it's a yuri show. I don't really care what the creator may or may not have said, the protag (the blonde one!) is not a dude.

>> No.8693284

>>8693276
Mononoke is sexy.
It's like if Mushishi were good.
Prove me wrong.

>> No.8693285

>>8693235

Why do you think AB is so bad? It has high quality animation and a top notch OST. It was funny at times, and sad at times. The only weakness I see is in the story. Some of it doesn't make sense and the character development isn't all there, but they only had 13 episodes to work with. If they had 25 I feel like it could have been much better. Of course there are flaws with it, but I could name flaws in any anime. It certainly isn't "downright shit" like you call it, but it's not the best show in the world either and nobody is claming it is. I'm curious as to what anime you would recommend me?

>> No.8693287

>>8693276
Only edgy teenagers on /a/ think it's shit. If you can't appreciate it then you probably have ADD and can't through a serious thought provoking film.

I recommend Gurren Lagann, it's probably more your style.

>> No.8693294

>>8693235
>watch better stuff

What is "better stuff" to you?

>> No.8693295

>>8693285
>The only weakness I see is in the story.
Kind of an important part of the show. If the only thing that matters to you is the animation and OST, then sure, it's a fine show.

>> No.8693300

>>8693294
What he likes

>> No.8693299

>>8693285
AB was nothing but plotless lolsorandum generic fanservice dogshit.

If you like it, I'm sorry to inform you that you have a disease called "shit taste". Don't be alarmed though, it affects roughly 99% of the world, the only downside is it's not curable.

>> No.8693301

>>8693287
But the teenagers on /a/ love artsy bullshit.

>> No.8693303

>>8693282
>Most of those shows aren't too great

Probably too deep for you. The picture you posted just confirms my assumption.

>> No.8693306

>>8693301
Their new thing is "LOL HOW MANY TIMES CAN MIYAZAKI MAKE THE SAME FILM".

>> No.8693305

>>8693285
>The only weakness I see is in the story.
>doesn't make sense
Thanks for answering it. AB is like a melting pot of random shit. The main story is about Kanade and her heart donor. Nobody give a shit about character that disappear after showing up for a few minutes.

See >>8693180
Come at me.

>> No.8693307

>>8693271
Aaeru fought in the Gulf for years before the series starts. So it made perfect sense to me.

>> No.8693309

No jew! no!

>> No.8693310

Jigoku Shojo
Witchblade
Darker than Black
Pegiundrum
Madoka

Still havent ever made it more than 5 episodes into any gundam, I dont know why I hate it so much.

>> No.8693311

>>8693282
I never said it was my most favourite, but it definitely is in my top 10.

Here are my top 5:
CCS
Dennou Coil
Escaflowne
Railgun
Macross

>macross not as good as gundam
Those nostalgia glasses are clouding your judgment desu no~

>> No.8693312

>>8693303
What? The picture was in response to Zunbar. I have no vested interest in that show, as I don't enjoy yuri.

>> No.8693318

>>8693295

I never said it didn't have story, I just said it could be seen as a weakness, just like Railgun. There were some loose ends here and there, and some things weren't explained as well as they should have been, but those are hardly all-encompassing. Overall it was a good show.

>>8693299

You're a faggot dude. Go back to trolling /a/ please.

>> No.8693319
File: 104 KB, 1024x1152, n4f5836e005192.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693319

>>8693311
>Railgun

>> No.8693327

>>8693311
>Those nostalgia glasses
I've watched Zeta Gundam as recently as two years ago. I like Macross 7 quite a bit and have seen it several times, but it's still no Zeta, Turn A, etc.

>>8693318
Railgun's story is not its weakness. AB is supposed to be Maeda making a nakige in anime form. What instead happens is, you have no character development for most characters, a nonsensical plot, and 0 closure. You have people getting killed early in the series as a gag because you can't really die, but then in a later episode it's suddenly supposed to be serious that these people have died. It was an absurd show. The comedy was ok, the music was good, that's about it.

>> No.8693328
File: 68 KB, 1280x720, 1329212911115.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693328

>>8693318
>You're a faggot

You sure showed me. Don't lash out at others to compensate for your complete lack of good taste.

If you honestly believe Angel Beats was a good show, I recommed Gaia Online, it's a great place for people like you to discuss their love for plotless fanservice shows.

>> No.8693329
File: 146 KB, 1000x733, samba!!.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693329

>>8693319
>>8693319
CRAZY FGVZS DFDS VJNVG HKJM JHBNJKVMHYUVGHJVCIJBKMBHKM NB

>> No.8693330

Bleach
Bakemonogatari
Madoka
Naruto
One Piece
Evangelion
Death Note

>> No.8693332

>>8692938

>>>/a/

>> No.8693334
File: 145 KB, 1280x720, are_you_ready_kids.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693334

this

I also like:
Infinite Stratos
Tomodachi
Angel Beats!
Lucky Star

>> No.8693339
File: 11 KB, 214x201, 1305762162410.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693339

>>8693330
Are you guys trolling? It's really making me upset.

The amount of generic shounen shit in this thread is embarrassing.

>> No.8693345

>>8693282
It's a dude, dude. Once you watch it then it becomes obvious.

If anything Simoun truly trolls people who have their "yuri googles" at full blast. Which might be another (unimportant) reason why I like it.

>> No.8693356

>>8693284
How can you hate Mushishi when your tastes just conform to whatever anime elitists like and it's also a highly revered show? Are your tastes perhaps actually shit under all your posturing?

>> No.8693361

>>8693345
Yea. Look at that dude, with her breasts, her female appearance, and her female voice.

>> No.8693364
File: 30 KB, 281x432, 1329512278424.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693364

Keion
Hidamari Sketch
SZS
Tamayura Hitotose
A-Channel
SoreMachi
Yuru Yuri
Pani Poni Dash!
Kill Me Baby

I still need to watch Aria and Sketchbook Full Autism.

>> No.8693360

>>8693328
>fanservice

I don't think you know what that word means.

>> No.8693368

Favorites threads are so hostile.

>> No.8693369

People calling out shit taste to everything and being butthurt is a very easy way to filter out who's from /a/.

Please go back, you're not wanted here.

>> No.8693380

>>8693327
The story in Railgun was pretty terrible. It stalled for episodes at a time and most of it just felt like filler (which it was). The development for AB characters was there, but there were only 13 episodes and how many fucking characters? What did you expect. The main characters got the development. The plot isn't nearly as bad as you make it out to be, your exaggeration is sort of weak. The mix of humor and drama was one of the strong points of the show, I'm sorry you can't appreciate that.

>> No.8693396

>>8693356
> when your tastes just conform to whatever anime elitists like
They only conform to whatever anime elitists like in that they conform to what I like.

>> No.8693398

>>8693345

>>he actually believes that kekekeke

iirc Aaeru is actually asexual, but she's definitely not a d00d.

>> No.8693407

I have two favorite animes; FLCL and NGE. I can't decide which one is my favorite. Both are unique in some ways and rewatching them is enjoyable, always. Kaiji, Cowboy Bebop, Planetes are also mentionable.There are also few good VN adaption animes, but after you've read the VN, anime feels kind bad such Kanon, Clannad and Steins;gate

>> No.8693408

>>8693305
>The main story is about Kanade and her heart donor

No it actually isn't. It's not even mentioned until the end of the show. Why would you think that?

>> No.8693417

>>8693380
>The story in Railgun was pretty terrible.
I'm saying this is a silly comparison because the story in Railgun is not nearly as important as the story in AB.

>The development for AB characters was there, but there were only 13 episodes and how many fucking characters?
Is having few episodes supposed to excuse it? Have more episodes then. If you somehow can't get it to be a 2 cour series, then have less characters.

>The mix of humor and drama was one of the strong points of the show
Not when something that was gag relief is all of a sudden supposed to be dramatic. For example, in episode 6, Otonashi arrives to the scene of all his friends lying dead/beaten by Naoi or whatever. This is supposed to be a dramatic scene. But when the show was killing characters as a joke earlier, it's hard to take any of that scene seriously.

>> No.8693419

I want second seasons of Mayo Chicken and Haganai.

>> No.8693428
File: 95 KB, 600x800, 20534132_big_p0.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693428

>>8693419
I dropped it to wait on the blu-rays. Guess I'll get to that.

>> No.8693429

>>8693361
>>her female voice

No. I don't think I told you this part before, but all the male characters are voiced by female VAs. So the female VAs do a young boy's voice for a lot of the characters. But in the end it just fits because they're talented and it works well with the fictional setting.

Like I said the whole thing is crazy, but it works so well in the end. It's really unique when it comes to anime (they just don't create anime like this anymore due to the risk) so that's why I enjoy mentioning it often.

>> No.8693435

>>8693408
Are you the same AB fanboy in this thread?
Kanade was obviously the main heroine. That other girl is just a haruhi clone. The whole show was about Kanade and the main MC trying get into the medical field/organ donation and other shit.
Do you somehow not get the foreshadowing since the start? Kanade trying to cheat the system, eating tofu alone and etc?
I dont even like AB but someone liking it and not getting the story? That is pretty stupid.
Yes I am the guy that called AB downright shit.

>> No.8693436

WARNING WARNING WARNING
ZUN!bar has reached critical level autism
WARNING WARNING WARNING

>> No.8693437

Hikaru no Go
One Piece
Hajime no Ippo
Yakitate Japan

>> No.8693441

>>8693408
>No it actually isn't. It's not even mentioned until the end of the show. Why would you think that?
What makes you think that Angel Beats has nothing to do with Kanade? What she did practically drove the show. That's a given fact, assuming you've watched the damn thing.

>>8693380
>The mix of humor and drama was one of the strong points of the show, I'm sorry you can't appreciate that.
There was little to no buildup for the drama. The final scene involving Kanade's goodbye was so cliched that it was laughable. I'm not saying that all Key dramas are bad, but Angel Beats is terrible because there was no character development whatsoever. Ayato turns from the most evil villain to a good guy in the space of one episode. They tried so hard, but it failed nonetheless.

>> No.8693456

>>8693419
Haganai will probably get a second season. Mayochiki is kind of doubtful due to the sales, but hardly impossible.

>>8693429
>but all the male characters
There are no male characters Zunbar. That is a setting to make closet yurifriends such as yourself feel more comfortable with the show.

>> No.8693457

Macross F (SDF has too much Korean animation, DYRL is only the best supplement ever)
Gundam 0080
Nanoha A's
Haruhi
Eureka Seven

>> No.8693460

DMC
School Rumble
Arakawa under the Bridge
Nichijou
CCS

>> No.8693477
File: 17 KB, 274x387, 1331134200861.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693477

Ura-on
K-ON!!
K-ON!
Monster

The rest falls behind.

>> No.8693498

>>8693417
>the story in Railgun is not nearly as important as the story in AB

Why is there any difference? What excuses Railgun for not having a strong story if you're crucifying AB for not having a perfect one?

>Is having few episodes supposed to excuse it? Have more episodes then

I touched on this and said I think it would have been better if they'd have had more episodes. I don't feel like you need to thoroughly explore every single character in a show especially if they aren't really in the spotlight. They gave us the development of the main characters as well as a couple less central ones.

>Not when something that was gag relief is all of a sudden supposed to be dramatic

It seemed like they spent most of that episode trying to set up a more serious tone so it didn't seem like they were just hopping back and forth between jokes and drama at will. I know where you're coming from but it seems to me like the show took on a more serious tone when it needed to and dropped it at times when it could. I didn't marathon the whole show at once so maybe that's why I got that feeling.

>> No.8693519

k-on, nothing comes close

>> No.8693520

>>8693498
Railgun has a strong cast of likable characters.
Angel Beats has got nothing on this. The large cast of AB doesnt help in this case. 1ep to develop 1character and then he/she just got killed off.
Railgun although not a masterpiece is 10000000x better than AB.

>> No.8693521

>>8693457
You faggot, the corean animation is the good one.

>> No.8693536

>>8693498
>Why is there any difference?
Because they are different genres? That's like saying the story in Minamike isn't good. It doesn't matter because it is not a story heavy show. Compare apples to apples my friend.

>I don't feel like you need to thoroughly explore every single character in a show especially if they aren't really in the spotlight.
Sure, but as the viewer I also am not going to care if some character that has not been developed and has just kind of been 'there' disappears or dies or whatever.

>it didn't seem like they were just hopping back and forth
That is irrelevant. The point I'm making is, at the beginning of the series, dying in that world is not a big deal, because you come back to life. They even kill the protagonist for laughs. However, regardless of how it was set up, it is still hard to take it seriously, considering what they had done in the previous episodes, how death is treated in the show, and how they will all come back to life afterwards and more gags will ensue.

>I didn't marathon the whole show at once
Neither did I.

>> No.8693540

>>8693520
>strong cast of likable characters.

No, not really. It's cool that you don't know the difference between opinions and facts though. Misaka is the cliched tsundere and Kuroko is yurimaniac purely there for the fanservice. AB has better animation + music. I could easily make the case AB is better.

>> No.8693549

>>8693540
>Misaka is the cliched tsundere and Kuroko is yurimaniac purely there for the fanservice. AB has better animation + music.
Kanade is the cliched Ayanami Rei character, and Yuri is the haruhi clone. Railgun had better animation and music.

>> No.8693554

>>8693536
>Railgun
>not story heavy

Do you understand where the source material comes from? The Indexverse is pretty story-heavy. You are trying to give its weak story an excuse because of genre. What genre do you consider Railgun? It would be easier to simply say it was a weak adaptation.

>> No.8693555

>>8693540
You are the only guy here trying to bring Railgun down to AB shit level. I dont really care if you dislike Railgun or whatever. Anyway go ahead, I am waiting for your essay on why AB is a C+ lvl anime.
Yurishit = haruhi/tsundere
Kanade = Yuki/kuudere
Same shit if you want to bring in archetype.

>> No.8693558

>>8693540
Why are you even comparing AB and Railgun? They are not even the same genre.
/jp/ sure watches a lot of anime.

>> No.8693557

>>8693549

Thank you, you just proved my point. Is this the first time you've learned what the word "opinion" means?

>> No.8693562

>>8693540
Kuroko isn't a yuri maniac, you faggot.
She's a perverted.

>> No.8693571

>>8693554
Railgun is an ongoing manga with multiple story arcs and plenty of slice of life in between. AB is a finished, 13 episodes series, which is supposed to be a drama, and supposed to make the viewer cry.

>> No.8693582
File: 43 KB, 432x434, 1329670995949.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693582

>watching anime for the plot
Not this shit again.

>> No.8693586
File: 201 KB, 331x391, wakarimasen.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693586

>>8693582

>> No.8693622

>>8693571

Railgun's plot had awful pacing and the show had even more fan service than AB. The only reason Railgun could be given an excuse for its weak plot is if it was a full-fledged SoL, but it isn't. Instead it tries to mix the two and fails pretty terrible. That's why most Indexfags don't like it, because the adaptation was about cute girls doing cute things. Just saying.

>> No.8693632
File: 73 KB, 800x320, 1330730127645.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693632

>> No.8693645

>>8693622
Say what you want. I don't like Railgun as much as I do Index. I'm not saying the Railgun anime adaptation is great, either. I wouldn't rewatch it again. But plot is still hardly as important to it as it is to a show like Angel Beats, which is why I don't think it should be compared to AB on those terms.

>the show had even more fan service than AB
I never made any claims about fanservice. And whilst I'm sure it has more fanservice than AB, it still doesn't have much either way.

>> No.8693679

You do realize that all anime is shit right? What are you expecting, The Godfather or something? Do you really think modern anime has that much character development? Do you think studios think about the plot first before green lighting projects? Everything is relevant. I could sit here and give 10 good reasons why every anime in the last 10 years is shit. Does that make me an anime expert or something? No, it's just so fucking easy to do it. It's proof how bad anime is when something like Madoka starts winning awards. It wasn't even good, it was just the shiniest turd in the shitter.

>> No.8693687

>>8693679
Okay anon, but this thread is for people who actually enjoy their hobbies.

>> No.8693699
File: 274 KB, 1020x1486, image44.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693699

Queen's Blade
Ikkitousen
Hyakka Ryouran
Freezing
sekirei a shit

Bakemonogatari, Spice & Wolf

>> No.8693710

>>8693679
Okay anon. No need to take your anger out on us.
Write a letter to the JMAF panel and Kobe award panel.

>> No.8693724

Evangelion
Slam Dunk
Sora no Woto
Eve no Jikan
GTO
Mononoke

>> No.8693738
File: 227 KB, 1359x1748, 291904.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
8693738

I haven't seen any new anime, but I've heard some of the titles and saved pictures of them. I collect Pretty Cure episodes even though I haven't gotten through GoGo yet. The last new anime I finished was Powerpuff Girls Z. I watch Super Sentai and Doctor Who.

>> No.8693742

>>8693679
>You do realize that all anime is shit right?

I do. I also acknowledge that most VNs, LNs, and doujinsoft are utter shit and that Touhou is full of blatant plagiarism. Does this mean that I'm suddenly not allowed to enjoy it?

Also, why are you complaining about low brow entertainment being low brow? It's like going to Popeye's and then complaining that the food is greasy and the employees are niggers.

>> No.8693749

>>8693742
Why are you so insecure?

>> No.8693762

GITS:SAC
GITS:SAC
GITS:SAC
GITS:SAC
Craig Ferguson
GITS:SAC

>> No.8693795

>>8693555

I'll show you a C+ lvl anime *grabs dick*

>> No.8693798

>>8692938

Boku no GTFO back to >>>/a/

>>
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action