/jp/ - Otaku Culture

[Anonymous No.]

It's too bad she doesn't exist. I was just getting to like her.

[Anonymous No.]

Erika 'exists'

[Anonymous No.]

Well she's a witch of course she doesn't

[Anonymous No.]

Wait, does she not count as a person in Ep5?

[Anonymous No.]

Gwahahaha! She exists just as much as I do!

[Anonymous No.]

>>4925870

They word things regarding her very ambiguously. The red states "The number of people on the island is equal to the number of people in this room" not "There are 18 people on this island." In other words, Erika's corpse was all that washed up.

[Anonymous No.]

>>4925873
I haven't played Ep6 yet, is this some Ep6 spoiler?

[Anonymous No.]

>stupid fag not realizing that erika not existing stll means only 16 people on rokkenjima

[Anonymous No.]

>>4925877
Didn't everyone see her alive, including Battler? How could she be a detective and interact with the other characters without being "alive"?

[Anonymous No.]

>>4925883
Magic

[Anonymous No.]

>>4925878

Nah, just common sense.


>>4925880

Enlighten me.

[Anonymous No.]

>>4925878
It's from episode 5. Battler says that "Kinzo doesn't exist should already be an established fact" in red.

[Anonymous No.]

>>4925883

How could the Siestas shoot everyone in the head in the dining room? The outcome's the same, the details are different.

[Anonymous No.]

>>4925887

"Even IF we welcome you, the number of people is 17."

[Anonymous No.]

>>4925899

You're welcoming her corpse!

[Anonymous of the !DeathUv6x2 No.]

Everything doesn't exist. The whole thing about Rokkenjima and Beatrice was actually Maria's imagination, she made up everything while she was sleeping in her house. Rosa doesn't have siblings, so Maria's all alone. She just desired to have a big family.

[Anonymous No.]

>>4925899
EVEN IF means it would be 17 with or without her.

[Anonymous No.]

>>4925903

But don't you see? That still means there's only 16 people besides Erika whether you include Erika (or her corpse) or not.

You do see?

[Anonymous No.]

>>4925906
i wouldn't be surprised if r07 would end it like that, you know, maria wakes up and the tears are falling down her face, no sakutarou, no cousins, no aunts, only abusive mother and her

[Anonymous No.]

>>4925912

Corpses do not count as alive people! Kinzo does not count towards the total number of people!

Therefore, even if Erika's corpse washes up on Rokkenjima and everyone acknowledges it as being there, the number of people remains seventeen!

[Anonymous No.]

>>4925912
That's not the only way to interpret it.

[Anonymous No.]

She was a Mary sue anyway

[Anonymous No.]

Also for the sake of theories here. You do not need to say Kanon's name is something else to get around the locations check! All Kanon has to do is leave the cousin's room at the same time Erika leaves her room and he won't be in a sealed room.

http://archive.easymodo.net/cgi-board.pl/jp/thread/4887992#p4895268

[Anonymous No.]

>>4925877
Pretending not to see the rest of the red, are you?
**Furudo Erika only increases it by one person.**
**Besides her, the number of people on this island is exactly the same as it was in the previous games.**

[Anonymous No.]

>>4926428

Who says that Furudo Erika's corpse existing raising the maximum number of people has to mean anything? She's there, the max number of people in Episode 5 is raised to 18, but there's still only seventeen of them there.

And the second red has no contradictions. Besides Erika, there's no one new on the island. Erika's corpse wasn't there before, now it is.

[Anonymous No.]

>>4927881
HOW the corpse is raising the number of people? Corpses doesn't count as people, alright? Otherwise, you have to count Kinzo or whomever corpse is burned almost every game.
Don't tell me it's you, who have just posted the same retarded thing at animesuki.

[Anonymous No.]

The living human Erika not existing in Ep 6 does not automatically give that she did not exist in Ep 5.

[Anonymous No.]

>>4927911

It counts because the red says it counts.

How can you be sure there are no closed rooms? Because the red says so!

The red says Erika increases the count, so whether she is a corpse or not is irrelevant.

[Anonymous No.]

>>4927922

No secret passages**

[Anonymous No.]

>>4927922
Christ, you're retarded. Red doesn't form a truth. It's not a truth otherwise. Red just announces and acknowledges it.

[Anonymous No.]

>>4927911

I was in a hurry. Let me reform my argument. How about this?

Erika washed up on shore, barely alive, on October 4th. She died immediately. The human count was raised, temporarily, but she died immediately so she still doesn't exist.