[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/jp/ - Otaku Culture

View post   
  [?]In ghost mode, only threads with non-archived posts will be shown
File: 24 KB, 350x450, 1263349632513.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4778205 No.4778205 [Reply] [Original]

leading theories aside, who do you actually want to be the culprit among the remaining possible ones?

>> No.4778223

Magic did it, of course.

>> No.4778229

Beatrice

>> No.4778235

Kanon

>> No.4778251

Moonchan, Shanon, and queerboy are all possibilities, I guess. I REALLY don't think Kanon is Beatrice. In episode 4 he died before at least two other people. Of course, Jessica would need an accomplice because of the ending in episode 1. However, Jessica is a good culprit for episode 2 and 5.

>> No.4778275

>>4778251
>However, Jessica is a good culprit for episode 2 and 5.

Except she's dead by around noon time in EP 5, according to Virgilia's read and is dead in EP 2 on the 2nd twilight (I swear if you use a shitty insulin excuse for this)

Anyways, I would like Kyrie.

>> No.4778303

Genji + horrific chain reaction revenge killings.

>> No.4778315

>>4778251
>In episode 4 he died before at least two other people.
I don't see what this has to do with anything, especially since we haven't the slightest clue who died when.

>> No.4778326

>>4778205
Magic, Kyrie or moon-chan. There are no other answers.

>> No.4778328

>>4778275
>she's dead by around noon time in EP 5, according to Virgilia's red
I thought we had ALREADY went through this, the explanation about Gaap's dimension being outside the limits of TIME & SPACE wasn't there just for the lulz

>> No.4778336

>>4778315
Kanon was the first in his group to die and Battler was alive right up until the end and the last piece of logic, Battler was not in Kanon's group.

>> No.4778365

>>4778328
If you go back to that scene Beatrice doesn't get why Virgilia is repeating that red. Virgilia was directing it to Battler, who was watching from the Golden Land Garden.

>> No.4778375

>>4778336
So how do you know WHEN they died. For all we know none of them died until the bomb went off, and Kanon just happened to be closer so died 'before'.

>> No.4778373

>>4778365
still my point holds
you could even say that red is for the time after the game ends

>> No.4778371

>>4778315
He was the ninth victim, so we know six people besides Battler died after he did. And four of those were his group members.

>>4778328
That whole scene wasn't there for the lulz either. There's a reason the deaths were confirmed twice.

>> No.4778367
File: 9 KB, 260x190, 1238892866272.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4778367

>>4778365
Fascinating.

>> No.4778377

>>4778275
Battler wasn't the detective in game 2, so she doesn't really need insulin.
And I don't recall Virgilia saying that, mind being a little more specific?
The only real red that hurts Jessica's chances is in episode 2 "Ushiromiya Jessica has not committed murder."

>> No.4778383

>>4778373
You could also say that Beatrice was referring to corpses of people that weren't on the island, but that would be equally stupid.

>> No.4778387

>>4778371
then please explain Hideyoshi's death, confirmed by the detective that's impossible for everybody on the island, but Natsuhi, denied by red
everything that Battler does is just to affirm that the victims of the 1st twilight, the ONLY ones able to do it, were alive

>> No.4778389

>>4778373
except Virgilia said that red before Natsuhi even went into the closet.

She was definietly directing it to Battler, so he could get help crafting a theory (since Erika never confirmed the wounds) and there was no reason for her to repeat it. She of all people knows about meta-world in regards to time and space.

>> No.4778395

>>4778377
>Battler wasn't the detective in game 2
What is this bullshit?

>> No.4778405

>>4778387
Could you please present some evidence that Hideyoshi actually died? Because he was kind of hamming it up for Natsuhi, and Erika didn't inspect the body, and the stake was already pulled out when she arrived.

>> No.4778407

>>4778387
Battler uses the red about them not being moved to take down Erika's theory. They don't even talk about Hideyoshi's death in the trial either.

Fact that the first set of murders are fake means there's a good chance Hideyoshi's was faked as well.

>> No.4778421

>>4778375
Ushiromiya Battler. I will now... kill you. And right now, there is no one other than you on this island.
That was said in red. And Mr. Requiresred, the existence of a bomb has yet to be confirmed in red.

>> No.4778432

>>4778205

It's difficult to say mastermind or culprit. But in any case, I hope it's Shannon (hopefully she isn't Beatrice) or George. If it's Kyrie, well damn...

>> No.4778442

>>4778432
If Shannon is involved, its implied in EP 6 that she would be only a pawn of the mastermind.

>> No.4778456

>>4778442
No, it's not.

>> No.4778471

>>4778442
It seems to me that Kanon would be a pawn, if anything, the way 6 turned out.

>> No.4779630

Kyrie AND Shannon or moon-chan, haven't decided yet. The MO for 1 and 2 is so different from 3-5 that there's gotta be two culprits.

>> No.4783314

>>4778328
Wait, wait, so you actually believe that the demon appeared, erased their corpses with magic and put them in a gap between the worlds, right?

>> No.4783325

Rudolf. I want him to do something other than die all the time.

I mean, the little time he's been alive, he's had an EPIC gunfight and pretended he was Jack Bauer. Just think of how awesome he'd be if he survived an entire episode.

>> No.4783334
File: 473 KB, 800x561, 1237643769217.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4783334

Moon-chan since EP3

>> No.4783339

Rosa, it's not going to happen though

>> No.4783358

I think Kyrie and Moon-chan are bros.

Just look at dat teamwork in episode 4!

>> No.4783363

Jessica. Subtle troll is subtle.

>> No.4783377

The only way Beato can be a scapegoat is if she has a mastermind who has always been close to her behind her.


Moon-chan fits that bill. Shkanontrice's sins can only be absolved with Moon-chan.

>> No.4783387
File: 247 KB, 638x476, triforce.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4783387

U MAD BATTLER

YES THEY DESERVED TO DIE, AND I HOPE THEY BURN IN HELL!

>> No.4783403

>>4783387
Who?

The family?

Hell no.

The culprit(s) and Beato?

Hell yes.

>> No.4783414

>>4783403
The entire family is fucked.

Jessica and Shkanonlanondingdong are just doing the world a favor.

>> No.4783449
File: 43 KB, 768x432, Rozen Maiden ~Traumend~ - 05.0-12-26.680.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4783449

>>4783403

>> No.4783487
File: 60 KB, 231x319, bern kawai.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
4783487

I can't wait for EP7; with Bern as the GM, it's going to be 200% trolling.

>> No.4783502

>>4783487
wait till the end, she'll be 34-trolled

>> No.4783509

>>4783502
The TRUE CULPRIT is going to troll someone at the end.

Seriously, like whoever the TRUE CULPRIT is, they are just going to trollface and kill Bern or something silly/awesome like that.

>> No.4783515

>>4783487
Just looking forward to her torture. Not sure if:
Battler will be the detective again
Beatrice will be forced to Bern's side

Hopefully we get a sob story & more development on Kyrie/Rudolf/servants.

>> No.4783517

>>4783487
>200% trolling
Try again, we already have that

>> No.4783523

>>4783515
taht should be due last ep, considering Kyrie is the mastermind behind everything

>> No.4783541

>>4783523
also, considering Ryu lives only to troll his fans as much as he can...
ep7 will contain shannon and kanon backstory and will fuck up shkanontrice

>> No.4783559

>>4783523
Yeah, because being dead half the time from the get go is the signature mark of a great mastermind.

>> No.4783565

>>4783559
she just miscalculates things, don't bother
also half
ep1 and 2 were the only ones with early deaths
time at 3 is unknown before nanjo's death
4 unknown
5 survives
6 killed by erika

>> No.4783580

>>4783565
Not exactly a mastermind then, is she?

Umineko is about trolls trolling trolls, you know.

Come now, I think we all know that there are several people all with the ability to troll well.

Rosa - Episode 2 speaks for itself, really. A fine effort by her, pity she's dead most of the other time.

Jessica is rather impressive in Episodes 1 and 4.

Kyrie seems to be in fine form in Episodes 3 and 4.

Shannon and Kanon get high marks throughout, but they are really more or less glorified body doubles/ killing machines, no art to their trade. Consistency sees them through, though.

>> No.4783589

>>4783580
she's mastermind/wire puller
whoever is Beatrice (or whoever is controlling her, Jessica) she's working under her BUT at the same time she has her very own agenda and takes advantage of it

>>
Reply to thread [?]Don't expect anything heroic. Your post will not be uploaded to the original board.
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action