[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/jp/ - Otaku Culture


View post   

File: 235 KB, 452x559, ì˜ÄäòP14a(ï¯).png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2217979 No.2217979 [Reply] [Original]

[ ] Protect Sakura.
[ ] Insist on becoming a superhero.

>> No.2217984
File: 50 KB, 803x599, fatedad.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2217984

[x] man up

>> No.2217985

[x] Put it in.

>> No.2217986

inb4slut

>> No.2217990

[x]DGAF

>> No.2217992

[x] genuflect

>> No.2217993

Ilya was unbelievably cute in that scene.

>> No.2217999

>>2217993
Isn't she always?

I might actually consider reading/playing the VN if Ilya had a route.

>> No.2218001

>>2217985

>> No.2218005
File: 79 KB, 810x656, BRING ILYA BACK.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2218005

>>2217993
>>2217999

I don't even like Ilya, but this was the best option choice in the game.

>> No.2218008
File: 243 KB, 800x600, youarekiritsugu.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2218008

>>2217984
SEIGI NO MIKATA DA

>> No.2218010

[x] Send her back to the kitchen

>> No.2218012

>>2217999
I meant especially in that scene.

>> No.2218018

[x] Put it all the way in.

>> No.2218025
File: 264 KB, 600x840, 1235856516316.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2218025

I'm probably the only one who will say it, so I'll say it proudly.

[X] Protect Sakura, with all my heart.

>> No.2218035

>>2218025
Too bad you don't have a heart, since your body is made of swords.

>> No.2218043
File: 216 KB, 487x594, 1236474198466.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2218043

>>2218035

Heart made of swords.

>> No.2218044

MIND OF STEEL

>> No.2218057

>>2218043
A dick made of swords would not be popular with the ladies.

>> No.2218065

>>2218025

Enjoy despair, ungratefulness, and either dying or having a loli do it in your place.

>> No.2218071

>>2218057
Waga kosshi wa nejire kuruu
KARADOBORUGU

>> No.2218072

MIND OF MOTHERFUCKING STEEL IS THE ONLY TRUE END

>> No.2218074
File: 128 KB, 800x600, 1232016474518.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2218074

>>2218057

My dick's not a sword, it's a jackhammer.

>> No.2218090

>>2218071
Caladbolg II: The Fake Spiral Penis

>> No.2218101
File: 132 KB, 1022x750, dmc krauser.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2218101

fucking capitalist bitch pigslut needs to GO TO DMC

>> No.2218114

>>2218090

Caster_arching_Saber.jpg

>> No.2218183
File: 96 KB, 610x473, 1228741786139.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2218183

[x] Protect Sakura
[x] Attack Rider

Die a manly death

>> No.2218199

[x] Rape Sakura.
[x] Insist on becoming a superhero.
[x] Kill Sakura.

>> No.2218210

[x] Genuflect

>> No.2218214

>>2218199
How does one rape Sakura?

Is it... actually possible to rape her? Because rape implies that she doesn't want it.

>> No.2218232

>>2218025
I don't even like Sakura all that much, and I can't understand why Shirou goes so far for her.

But damn it all, when that scene came up I couldn't help but be behind Shirou 100%.

>> No.2218239

[x] Insist on becoming Sakura

>> No.2218246

Fun fact :
Anon, even though you forgot, as a male human being your ultimate objective is to pass on your genetic code to the next generation.
This means that it doesn't matter how much you keep on denying it with shitty morals or ideals, having a family with Sakura is the manlier choice Shirou could've made in FSN.

Saber is the planet's bitch, and even if by some weird shit she could stay in Shirou's world for a year, I highly doubt a servant body can conceive a child.
Rin is Rin, I don't really believe she would accept to give up most of her magic studies and career for a family.

>> No.2218259

>>2218214
[x] Violently Fuck Sakura
[x] Insist on becoming a superhero.
[x] Fuck Sakura till she die.

Better?

>> No.2218267

>>2218246
>as a male human being your ultimate objective is to pass on your genetic code to the next generation

Says who? You're confusing instinct with human motivations. The manliest choice of all is to choose your own path and truth, and walk it without hesitation. Instinct makes you want to dive into the Erotical Black Hole.

>having a family with Sakura is the manlier choice Shirou could've made in FSN

Hardly.

>> No.2218268

>>2218259
Superb

>> No.2218272
File: 49 KB, 400x425, 1231396768153.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2218272

>>2218246

>I highly doubt a servant body can conceive a child.

You make me sad.

>Rin is Rin, I don't really believe she would accept to give up most of her magic studies and career for a family.

Maguses need a descendant for their Magic Crest.

(Which makes me wonder; what happens to the child if two magus family heirs fall in love? Having two Crests would suck.)

>> No.2218280

>>2218272
Love doesn't have much to do with magus families, so I doubt it's a very common problem.

>> No.2218284
File: 14 KB, 334x402, Kiritsugu.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2218284

>>2218267

>The manliest choice of all is to choose your own path and truth, and walk it without hesitation

Then Mind of Steel isn't manly at all, because it's not his own path.

>> No.2218290

>>2218246
>I don't really believe she would accept to give up most of her magic studies and career for a family.
Rin had a grandchild that became Sakura's student.

>> No.2218299

>>2218284
That's why UBW is the best, since he makes the ideal his own.

>> No.2218316

>>2218284
Wrong. He made it his own path.

Just because a conviction wasn't born of your mind originally doesn't mean you can't make it your own. You could be the son of a cancer researcher and decide that you want to develop a cure for cancer. It probably wasn't your dream to start with, but you decided on that path yourself, so it's your dream now.

>> No.2218323
File: 18 KB, 200x250, nerine.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2218323

>>2218272
yeah it probably sucks to inherit too much magic..isn't it sad Lycoris?

>> No.2218329

>>2218316

>Wrong. He made it his own path.
See >>2218299.
He did in UBW, not in Mind of Steel, where he simply cloned Kiritsugu.

>Just because a conviction wasn't born of your mind originally doesn't mean you can't make it your own.

But if you copy a person, mind and body, you're not making it your ideal.
You're just being a good mimic.

>> No.2218341

>>2218272
>>2218246

You forget though, that whilst Saber is a Servant, she is also still alive and the body she appears in is her own body transported through time, rather than a clone of a hero who is being stored in the throne of heros.

Saber seems to eat, drink and sleep like any normal person does, i imagine she will be able to have children. The real question is wether she had started having her period by the time she took Caliburn from the stone. If yes, then there is no problem, but if she hadnt, there is no way she can reproduce as taking the sword from the stone froze her at her current age.

>> No.2218352

>>2218246
Actually, Rin would continue with her studies while Shirou stayed home with the kid/s. I bet he'd actually like it.

>> No.2218439

>>2218341

Ah, the logistics of Saber's menstral cycle, i love /jp/

>> No.2218664
File: 50 KB, 800x600, 1232368845250.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2218664

>>2217979
Yandere Sakura makes me hard

>> No.2218679

I dont get why so many people are angry shirou gave up his goals for Sakura. His goals were childish and unrealistic. That fact was pounded into us after reading UBW and Kiritsugu's story.

Becoming the superhero shirou wanted to become was impossible.

>> No.2218695

Why can't Shirou just become a salaryman like a normal Japanese man?

>> No.2218699

>>2218679
You didn't understand anything at all, did you, sir?

>> No.2218702

>>2218272
Remember folks Saber is not a real servant. She was summoned to the time period Shirou was in BEFORE her death because her wish was to obtin the holy grail.

Therefore ending is possible, since it's her real body.

>> No.2218714

>>2218679
Just because it's impossible doesn't mean you shouldn't do it. Mind of Steel is the True End. Shirou's ideal is Shirou's ideal, it doesn't matter who had it before.

>> No.2218722

>>2218699
What is there to understand? Shriou wanted to become someone who could save everyone. He was either to sacrifice the few to save the many, even if the few are his loved ones. Walking the same cold and lonely path that Kiritsugu and Archer walked. Or he could abandon his goals and selfishly save who he wanted to save.

He obviously chose the latter.

>> No.2218725

>>2218702
>>2218341

Is it just me, or does the idea of Saber and Shirou having kids warm your cold dead heart up?

>> No.2218727

>>2218722
Not in my game he didn't.

>> No.2218728

What kind of a superhero would abandon a victim like Sakura?

>> No.2218730

>>2218714
I understand that, but we all know the outcome of that end. People are angry that he gave up the path that would lead to his own self destruction.

>> No.2218734

>>2218728
She's not a victim, she willingly accepted evil. The correct path is to kill her to save the real innocent victims.

>> No.2218735
File: 232 KB, 842x1200, 37.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2218735

>>2218725
yes

>> No.2218736

>>2218725

I let out an audible "d'aw" when I saw >>2218272

>> No.2218744
File: 86 KB, 1024x768, 3272482121_0262d6e7cf_o.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2218744

>>2218728
Gilgamesh is my Hero.

>> No.2218745

>>2218725

Yes. It makes me smile whenever i think of it or see fanart of it.

>> No.2218747

>>2218730
There's no guarantee it would lead to his destruction. The Archer route isn't any of the published routes.

>> No.2218748
File: 26 KB, 800x602, shirou.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2218748

>> No.2218752

>>2218734

Abandoned by her family to a lifetime of rape and torture.

Vengeance isn't inherently evil, no matter what Disney tells you to the contrary.

>> No.2218756

>>2218725

If there are two characters who ever deserved that kind of simple happiness, its Saber and Shirou.

>> No.2218758

>>2218748
Nobody can laugh at him, because an ideal is stronger than any man.

>> No.2218760

>>2218747
So even though we've seen two examples of that ideal failing, he still should repeat what they (Archer and Kiritsugu) did and walk their same path? History will repeat itself if you do not learn from it.

>> No.2218766

>>2218752
Oh god, not this again. Didn't we figure out last time that while vengeance isn't inherently evil, taking out the actions of three men on the entire world is?

>> No.2218769
File: 45 KB, 800x600, 1235683010288.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2218769

>> No.2218788

>>2218760
The ideal will fail, like the story says, there is no "superhero". But it's not about succeeding for him. The ideal is still beautiful, and that's why he keeps it. "Selfishly pursuing selflessness", was it?

>> No.2218792
File: 110 KB, 1012x679, thatfuckinggirugamesh.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2218792

>>2218744

>> No.2218803

>>2218747
That's not the point though, the point is the ideal doesn't work. It inherently has it's fallacies. You cant save everyone like what Shirou wanted, there will always be sacrifices. His ideal would have to become twisted and morphed like Archer and Kiritsugu in order for him to walk it. Eventually he would be in the same place as Kiritsugu and Archer, having killed so many, including loved ones, his heart would turn cold.

Shirou becomes like Veidt from The Watchmen.

>> No.2218808

>>2218760

If by two examples you mean the other routes, they went quite well.

In Fate, Shirou fucking seduced King Arthur's rule 63 and, because he was mature and not a whiny bitch, let her go when he knew it was the right thing to do. It turned out that the promise of power from the grail turned out to be too good to be true, and he let go anyway, despite honeyed lies and promises that he could have what he wanted. Then he moved on with his life. Tohsaka would see to that. Fate can lead to an Archer End, but it doesn't necessarily have to.

In Unlimited Blade Works, Shirou's got a pretty fucking bright future. He's got Rin and she's got him. They've got their careers and lives together ahead of them. With her around, I doubt UBW Shirou would have become Archer.

>> No.2218811

>>2218725

It makes me dawwww every time i think of it. /r/ing the doujin where, at the end, Rin teases Saber about having children and asks if she is happy. That one seems to end with happy pregnant Saber.

>> No.2218813

>>2218792

>> No.2218818

>>2218766

I don't want to get into it again, but you're pretty heartless to call Sakura evil.

>> No.2218820

>>2218808
I believe he meant Archer and Kiritsugu, who were both destroyed by the ideal.

>> No.2218828

>>2218820

Kiritsugu died a happy man.

>> No.2218832

>>2218818
I'm the guy who last time was saying that while what Sakura was doing -

No. No, you know what? Fuck you. You're not dragging me into this shit again.

>> No.2218831 [DELETED] 

>>2218828
Somewhat. If he had given up on the ideal or comprimised like Shirou did in UBW, he would have gotten the things he wanted and protected the people he loved.

>> No.2218840

>>2218828
Somewhat. If he had given up on the ideal or compromised like Shirou did in UBW, he would have gotten the things he wanted and protected the people he loved.

>> No.2218847
File: 62 KB, 480x360, shitstorm.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2218847

A bit late but SHITSTOOOOORM alert.

>> No.2218859

>>2218831

People with a strong sense of justice have a hard time living with themselves if they know they're ignoring or even causing the suffering of innocent people. What separates the men from the boys is whether they keep at it after they realize how unglorious it is.

>> No.2218865

>>2218847
I wouldn't really call it a shitstorm, seems like a normal discussion.

>> No.2218874

>>2218859
I agree with you. I posted >>2218788
, the ideal fails every time, but the ones holding it continue anyway, they won't stop believing in it.

>>2218748

>> No.2218882

>>2218828
Killing your own wife and never getting to see your own daughter?

Yeah...

>> No.2218889
File: 4 KB, 730x73, sakuraderail.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2218889

>>2218832

You really want to, though. Look at your two sages. Seething with hate. Calling to me. They feign disinterest, but it's a thin ruse. And somewhere, in your wicked, black heart, you can't resist the compelling urge to make it known that a victim of a decade of child rape is an evil person for what their life has turned them into.

>> No.2218904

>>2218803
The central theme of Watchmen the conflict between the utilitarian ethics of Veidt and the Kantian ethics of Rorschach. It is very careful to avoid picking sides.

Shirou's attitude is much closer to Rorschach than Veidt. In Mind of Steel he kills Sakura not because he's calculated that it results in the greatest good for the greatest number, but because Sakura is actively killing innocents right now and there is no other reliable way to stop her. The big weakness of utilitarianism is uncertainty, and Shirou doesn't have Veidt's godly super-genius to circumvent this. Utilitarianism is only a side effect of Shirou's ideal when it occurs at all.

>> No.2218920

>>2218904

I don't think Nasu put this much thought into this.

>> No.2218924

Holy shit, we need to include Watchmen in every Fate debate from here on out.

>> No.2218960

>Thread about Fate ideals and Watchmen

FUCCCCCCCCCCCKKKKKKKK!

>> No.2218976

>>2218960
Shirou is Rorschach.

Both of them die.

>> No.2218980
File: 59 KB, 800x600, peace.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2218980

>> No.2218991

>>2218924
Why would I save a loli that I have no p0n0s in?

>> No.2219164

>>2218882

At least he was happy because he knew that all his ideal wouldn't be wasted now that there's someone to inherit it.

Too bad, that someone realised it very much later that his ideal sucks.

>> No.2219209

>>2219164

I wonder about that because he also throw it away to save Shirou.

Shirou himself is only doing it because of his sense of guilt over abandoning everyone to save himself ... UBW is funny in the sense its Archer Route and seems a bit disconnected from Fate.

To me its UBW<Fate<HF

>> No.2219232

>>2219209
He didn't 'throw it' away for Shirou's sake. That happened before. After that ,Fire buns everything, he has been hit with the grail mud and finds a survivor.
He was just glad to save someone.
He DIDN'T want Shirou to be a magus and follow the path that for himself only brought hardships and loss, but you know what happens.

>> No.2219246

[x] Have sex with Rider behind her back.

>> No.2219309

>>2219232

He thrown it away in a sense, the shounenfags of /jp/ would have use it ... he did not because he realized the true nature of the Grail.

Then he also realized how fucking stupid his entire life was, he tried to amend and that is why he saved Shirou and tried to meet with Ilya.

But that goes over the heads of the shounenfags here ... the fact that path was only doing to lead to self-destruction since its a impossible goal filled with contradictions (right at the start with the "rejoice Shirou").

>> No.2219338

>>2219309
>shounenfags
get out

>> No.2219353

>>2219309

>>2218788

>> No.2219370
File: 39 KB, 337x469, nothingtomeowabout.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2219370

>>2219309

It also seems that you also forget it's the most awesome path, since in the other all we see is a lot of Nasusex and "BAWWWW suddenly I love her so I'll protect no matter what"

It is obviously clear that Nasu wants to shove this route down our throat as a final ending, you can tell that from the choices he gave us in VN. Unlike Fate and UBW, it has no specific condition nor does it explain why suddenly Sakura becomes the main heroine in this route, apart from 'suddenly, I realise that my personal cook and maid is da best'.

>> No.2219379

I always wondered what MIND OF STEEL was. Then I became super hero and got spammed about MIND OF STEEL in every fucking sentence.

Best end by the way, I wonder how Shirou killed everyone.

>> No.2219383

>>2219309

>shounenfags

Gb2/a/, son. You obviously do not belong here.

>> No.2219400

>>2219379

From my own speculation and Kotomine's statement, he would probably use Kiritsugu's method.

That is, do everything that's needed to win-even if it means to play dirty.

>> No.2219404

>>2219370
...Excluding Saber who appears later, he has an obvious interest in the two sisters when the story starts.
Shirou's abnormal thought process and way he interacts leads to him either not acknowledging or not really doing anything about it.
If you see all 3 routes together, small choices made can affect a lot of things (Buy meat for saber, Rin gets a harem is a joke example).

And the reason the path is last has to do with the overall focus of Shirou's path and decisions, not the heroines. It's done for the sake of presentation, not importance.

>> No.2219439

>>2219400

Yeah I suppose that's probably how it would turn it.

WTB Epilogue of Shirou putting bullets in everyone's skull.

>> No.2219487

This game is bad, very bad. Don't play it I reccommend not to do it, it makes you incommfortable all the way you play it. Along with Hitomi My stepsister, Virgin Roster and other, please don't ever play those, waste of time and very disgusting. If you want to play some good and touching games that woth it, play Crescendo, Figuress of Happiness, Kana Little Sister, Snow Sakura or even the gracious Heart de Roommate. Honest, don't play this, don't let yourself be fooled as I did.

>> No.2219489

>>2218183
Thats what I never understood. /jp/ always hypes up Mind of Steel, but this is the best non end in Heaven's Feel

>> No.2219491
File: 81 KB, 640x480, shirovsgil.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2219491

>>2219404
>small choices made can affect a lot of things

You obviously don't have any idea what you're talking about.

Let me be more clear,

in fate and UBW the reason that the route parts from each other is clear, that is, Archer is not injured by Saber,due to Shirou's use of Command spell choice, so he can go on his own agenda, which is to kill Shirou.

However, in HF, the specific choice that leads to this route, does not exist,you can choose the same choice in fate and nothing happens. It suddenly forces on us the least loved character as a main heroine.Which everyone find despicable, it is also the longest and most boring route, constantly filled with Bad ends,inflicted mostly by the said 'heroine', just for the pure reason of 'you don't love her enough,you're deadLOL'

The only redeeming value in it is that we learn the true nature of Kotomine. Without him this route would've easily become a shitfest.

>> No.2219504

>>2219491

It does, the choice is Sakura, Sakura and Sakura.

That is the trigger, Shirou's love for Sakura.

>> No.2219513

>>2219489

Well, seeing that he wins because Saber go easy on him and didn't use her Excaliber haxx, it's not that all impressive. Plus,he can not finish her off because he's dead.

>> No.2219524
File: 53 KB, 500x446, 1232679651218.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2219524

>>2219513

Excalibur is a slow attack.

The time it would've taken for it to charge would've left her vulnerable to the first strike of Overedge.

Shirou borrowed Archer's speed, remember.

>> No.2219527

>>2219504

AND you can choose sakura in fate route on your first play, but still gets fate,not HF. Which is the very much of the reason of my argument until now.

>> No.2219533

>>2219491
In, HF. the simple what if is 'What if Shirou took notice of Sakura sooner and her problems' (which exist in every route). Thus, gets closer to her, Shinji messes up faster and snowball of effects.

Also, the other 2 routes have plenty of bad ends, point is stupid and not accurate. And saying 'Least loved character' is just stupid opinion, and not the basis for writing a route either way.

And finally, the point was never on the heroines.
No matter what it seems like, the focus is always Shirou and his growth, and how people he cares about (heroines) affect that. Sakura who was a victim first and then lashed out forced a different growth then tragic hero Saber and Partner-in-asskicking Rin.

>> No.2219544

>>2219527
Nasu DOES NOT want you to view the routes in ANY order, hence why the UBW trigger can't come at first.
You do not have an option at first.
Your argumet is invalid.

>> No.2219545

>>2219527

Maybe because HF only unlocks AFTER Fate and UBW were completed?

Dumbass, you also DONT get the choice to stop Saber before Fate is completed.

>> No.2219548

>>2219533

>In, HF. the simple what if is 'What if Shirou took notice of Sakura sooner and her problems' (which exist in every route). Thus, gets closer to her, Shinji messes up faster and snowball of effects.

You can do the EXACT SAME choices in your first playthrough of the game, but it won't progress to Heaven's Feel without completing Unlimited Blade Works.

But why?

>> No.2219551

>>2219545

Nothing "unlocks", though.
All the choices are the same, unlike the UBW trigger, where a new choice pops out of nowhere.

>> No.2219552

>>2219548

See

>>2219544
>>2219545

>> No.2219556

>>2219548
You really are a fucking idiot.
He doesn't WANT you to read HF yet.

>> No.2219561

>>2219556

So?

There's still no logic behind it preventing me.

You just waiving it off as an act of god does not improve my opinion of Heaven's Feel in the slightest.

>> No.2219564

>>2219533
>the other 2 routes have plenty of bad ends, point is stupid and not accurate

You DO realise that HF has more BAD ENDs than both route does, right ?

>And saying 'Least loved character' is just stupid opinion

Once again, you've shown you ignorance.

Character popularity vote, check it out ,slowfuck.

>the point was never on the heroines

Hurr Durr

>> No.2219582

>>2219564
When he wrote the route, he didn't write and focus depending on expected popularity.
Plus, more preferring the other two does not mean she is bad. Less appeal=NO appeal.
That's why your argument is retarded.
And the Bad ends of HF are 16, aka less then half total but yes, more then UBW or Fate.
But they prove nothing, really.

You have a Sakura hate that you try to push as fact.
We have seen that a lot.

>> No.2219598

>>2219561
It's a pure fucking storytelling aspect.
If it was a book, he released the Saber version first, then Rin, THEN Sakura.
You NEVER had a choice, really.
This is the stupidest think someone has argued about on /jp/, and we have had WarhammerVsTypeMoonVsTouhouvsIndex threads.

>> No.2219611

Heaven's Feel is the true route. Sakura is #1 to Shirou. Nasu agreed.

>> No.2219618

>>2219582

>more preferring the other two does not mean she is bad

Ok, now it's you who's retarded.

>Bad ends of HF are 16, aka less then half total but yes, more then UBW or Fate.
But they prove nothing, really

This is why I called you ignorant,meh.

>You have a Sakura hate that you try to push as fact

Not really, personally she's just fine as the side character.

tl;dr Sakura fanboy trying to prove his point validity, with futile results.

>> No.2219619

>>2219611
Oh dear, here we go again.

>> No.2219630

>>2219618
So, bad ends with many of them originating from other characters and that are not the main story in the end and POPULARITY are your main arguments?
Sure man.

>> No.2219631
File: 4 KB, 210x168, 1235998805542.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2219631

>>2219582
>>2219598
>>2219611

Is that some samefaggotry I smell ? I think it is.

>> No.2219636

The true route is the Ayako route that will come out in 2014 when they do a remake of the game.

>> No.2219639

>>2219598
> This is the stupidest think someone has argued about on /jp/, and we have had WarhammerVsTypeMoonVsTouhouvsIndex threads.

best definition of /jp/ I ever came accross

>> No.2219641

>>2219598

We're SUPPOSED to have a choice.

The entire story revolves around our choices, and that's what leads us to the intricate BAD ENDs.

We're Shirou's subconscious, and we're trying to make sense of why the fuck two identical processes DO have different results when one happens at a later date.

Waiving it as an act of god still does not absolve it of being inexplicable to the story.

>> No.2219642

>>2219639
Warhammer 40k>Touhou

>> No.2219643

>>2219636
>>2219636
>>2219636

>> No.2219645

>>2219582
>>2219611

And here we have /jp/ Sakura fanboys, like always.

>> No.2219653
File: 13 KB, 150x181, 1235581106809.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2219653

>>2219630

...You lose me man.

>> No.2219655

>>2219645
I'm >>2219582. And she is nowheer near my favorite character.
Your arguments are just simply retarded.
I didn't particluarly like her oute and I can't even fuucking IGNORE your bullshit.
It's bad even for /jp/ TM thread levels.

>> No.2219663

>>2219611

Well, that's why Nasu's work sucks.

>> No.2219669
File: 339 KB, 800x600, Sakura.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2219669

Senpai senpai senpai!

>> No.2219677

>>2219663
Do you truly believe everything you read on the Internet?
BTW, Nasu's favorite character is Rider.

>> No.2219684

>>2219663

no, it sucks because he can't write a erotic scene.
where's that capture about elaborate prostitute when I need it ?

>> No.2219686
File: 12 KB, 205x174, punkfacepalmed.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2219686

>>2219655
>nowheer
>oute
>fuucking

Jesus Christ, even though you're stating some failed argument at least do it properly you fucktard.

>> No.2219693
File: 321 KB, 1024x768, Ayako.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2219693

>>2219636
>>2219643
SUPERIOR MOE

>> No.2219698

>>2219655
>nowheer

wat

L/2/spell retard.

>> No.2219699

>>2219686
Yes, cause you CLEARLY could not understand what I was talking about.
Fucktard.

>>2219684
Actually, from ALL the VNs I have read, the good sex scenes I have read are about ...6.
With 2 of them being so because they were very short.

It's a universal problem when you describe intercourse.
Few odd words are the least of the issues.

>> No.2219707
File: 248 KB, 1128x1600, 23.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2219707

>>2219693
YEEEAAAH

>> No.2219712

>>2219699

>cause

Haha, oh wow.

Gb2gaia you dumbfuck.

>> No.2219719

>>2219712
You know what, this is fucking sad.

>> No.2219730

>>2219707
That doujin made me rage at the ending.

>> No.2219734

>>2219655

>nowheer
>particluarly
>oute
>fuucking

This is the most fucking grammar FAIL I've ever seen since that nigger quote.

>> No.2219744
File: 341 KB, 1128x1600, 40.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2219744

>>2219730
It still gave promise of an AYAKO END so I was satisfied.

>> No.2219748

>>2219699

cool story ,bro.

>> No.2219749

>>2219734
It's MISTYPING.
Not wrong use of words, nor wrong spelling.
You have never hit a key twice or reversed order in your perfect internet career, I guess.

>> No.2219755
File: 73 KB, 800x600, 1235192456140.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2219755

Mind of Steel end is the best, Japan agrees.

>> No.2219765
File: 33 KB, 598x448, 1235067462479.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2219765

>>2219749

Internet is serious business LOL

>> No.2219767

I'd think that choice over if it was Rin, or pretty much anybody else.

Sakura, however, is a useless, cowardly bitch. The whole HF is about Sakura stop acting like that. She can't be used as a woman even in that sense, as she might make a good wife, but I doubt she could develop any maternal instincts or any relationship to whatever as she was during the whole HF. When she wasn't either angsting or running away, she was a crazy yandere.
And if you've read Return to the Spring, you see Sakura that can actually act as a person, given a time to fix her personality. Then you look back and say: "Wow, somehow I wonder if even such a great thing was worth THAT much trouble"

also,

[ ]Bring My arm down
[ ]...I can't do it
[x]Project Rule Breaker and bring my arm down.

>> No.2219776

As heroine i like Rin, but as a story i like Minds of Steel. So what?

>> No.2219780

>>2219767

Here we go again...

>> No.2219794
File: 144 KB, 595x841, riderayako.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2219794

>>2219744
Ayako end is impossible. She already belongs to someone.

>> No.2219797

>>2219611
You read Last Episode, anon?

>> No.2219806

>>2219794
Rider would definately share

>> No.2219812
File: 202 KB, 800x2030, GSC 1.6 -Fate HA- Sakura Matou.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2219812

>>2219645

Do you have a problem with us Sakura fans?

>> No.2219818

>>2219794
"Oh, you should imrove your diet, eat more meat, so you will be more tasty in the future"
I chuckl'd

>> No.2219833

>>2219379

This is the most appealing post in this fucking stupid thread, so I guess I will reply to this.

For Rin - Exploit her tsundere behaviours, backstab her and steal her command spell - easy modo win.

For Ilya - just kill her when she comes to play with you in shopping district. Another easy win.

Assassin&Zouken - most troublesome since Assassin can not be detected by Shirou's own skill. I guess it's time to put that command spell you stole earlier to use XD

Kotomine - no Ilya,no Sakura, no grail, no reason to fight.

>> No.2219839
File: 395 KB, 1128x1600, 29.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
2219839

>>2219806
>>2219794
>Rider and Ayako threesome end
Oh god I'm already fapping

>> No.2219844

>>2219833
I've always wondered about what Rider will do in that one

>> No.2219847

>>2219839
BEST
END
EVAR

>> No.2219858

>>2219844

Rider can't do shit. By taking Mind of Steel Shirou has finished Sakura off earlier so no master, no problem.

>> No.2219869

>>2219833
>For Rin - Exploit her tsundere behaviours, backstab her and steal her command spell - easy modo win.

Ignore that she's a magus...

And Rin was implied to be his final opponent, as he killed her before the altar of the Grail after learning of its Angry Manju nature.

>For Ilya - just kill her when she comes to play with you in shopping district. Another easy win.

Ignore that she's also a magus with Mystic Eyes of lesser petrification.

>> No.2219908

>>2219858
That doesn't change the fact that she is a motherfucking servant, she can come in the Church ten minutes after what we've seen in the game and mop the floor with Shirou, Rin and even Kotomine. Or just take off Breaker Gorgon and go on the Borin' Mode.

Shirou can't take out Rin's Command spell as she kinda lacks servant, so it's Shirou and Rin(if Shirou isn't stupid) against Assasin. Well, enjoy the epic battle.

>> No.2219945

>>2219869

Hey, like I said, it's all about how to exploit their trust.

>> No.2219957

>>2219869
our posts are interestingly similiar.

I guess the obvious is obvious.

But I still don't get why would he do anything to Rin. She is much more of a magus than he is, and I doubt any of them would wan't to do anything other than destroying it when learning about Avenger. I am sure that the Sakura thingie wil haunt her to the end of her life, but she is a magus of Tohsaka, she has the Mind of Steel from the beginning of the game. I think she would kill Shirou if she had to even at the end of UBW.

Illay is imho out of the game already.

>> No.2219976

>>2219908

And why would they wait for her ?

Moreover, why would she want a revenge ? All we see of her in F/SN is that she's an obedient and protective figure, but not vengeful.

>> No.2219979

>>2219957

I see you skipped UWB as well ...

Serious people, why do you talk crap?

>> No.2220002

>>2219957

Kotomine explicitly predicted that Rin would go mad from grief now that her sister is dead and would do anything to obtain the grail.

>> No.2220007

Kotomine should have smuggled a gun in.

>> No.2220020

>>2219979
Well, the only moment she went easy on Shirou was in the beginning, when she didn't want to kill him(and didn't in the bad end). She went easy on him, since she didn't take the wrench guy fighting gands with a strenghtening magic seriously. She would act totally different if shw knew what he really is capable of and that he is serious. Most of all, she was the one who decided to kill Sakura. She WANTED to kill her when she was still mentally able to. That's what being magus means, and Nasu wrote quite a few pages about that in the Prologue.

Of course, she didn't kill Sakura when they fought, I admit that.

>> No.2220037

>>2220007

He said that a gun doesn't suit his taste, also remarked Kiritsugu for using it.

>> No.2220048

>>2220002
Kotomine, most of all, didn't know much about Rin, as she was always acting pretty tsun to him. Also, he could have actually wanted to grasp the Grail himself, I doubt he would TELL Shirou about that. And he wasn't really afraid of him, he actually wanted to fight Shirou all along.

And even if Rin was that fixed on the Grail, who knows what would she do, seeing the black lake, stripped loli (or alternativelly, stripped Shinji) and the void.

>> No.2220069

>>2220037
Well, it could compensate for the fact that he aged and got slower in F/SN.

>> No.2220076

>>2220048

Go play UBW and find out.

>> No.2220080

>>2220076
I don't have to do that for a third time, do I?

>> No.2220087

Now I'm confused about Kotomine's motivation. Does he want to learn the meaning of birth, find out if living life differently from other people is a crime or to find the worth of a worthless life?

>> No.2220103

>>2220087

He wants to get his jollies off seeing massacre and destruction.

Everything he said to Shirou otherwise was just theatrics.

>> No.2220128

>>2220103
Oh.

Great, I have this horrible mental image of Kotomine skullfucking Shirou while he's in magical surgery.

>> No.2220140

>>2220087
Well, most of all, he want to help himself, everything he does is because of that. He wants to find his answer, solve his problem, call it whatever you want. His problem was, that he couldn't be happy. Nowadays, that's common. He, however, found out that he IS able to enjoy some things, but most of them are wrong. He wondered when did it began. And found out, that he was like that for all his life, he was just born thinking the wrong way. And after understanding that he can't get an answer why did that happen by normal means, he thought that the best way to see if it was dependable was to observe the birth of someone who, as he was, was supossed to be evil by concept.

Also, he wanted to have fun, as Angra Maniyu could bring him quite a lot of enjoyment. Relate to Kefka if you want.

>> No.2220155

>>2220103
It would be theatrics if he said that to Shirou only, but it was said in the Interlude, his feelings and motivation too. Vaguely, though, but it did prove that he did not said crap to Shirou to confuse him or somehting.

>> No.2220156

>>2219957

I disagree, Rin failed the MIND OF STEEL when she brought Shirou back to life. Also note she didn't kill Sakura until Shirou gave his consent, she's pretty soft at heart.

>> No.2220160

>>2220140

Uh,no. He also realised that the moment Angra Manyu come to this world he would be killed, so the part about him enjoying is not true.

>> No.2220168

>>2220156
Damn, ressing Shirou is a good argument.

Sad thing is, Rin dropped a rank for me.

>> No.2220170

>>2220140
Wait, let me get this straight: By witnessing the birth of Angra Mainyu, he can figure out why he was born wrong?

>> No.2220180

>>2220160
I meant that for Fate, as Avenger was supposedly not coming out in that one, so he had a motivation as simple as that.

>> No.2220207

>>2220020

Not getting the point?

She saved Shirou for one reason, that Sakura would cry ... Rin always had weak spot in Sakura.

But its not only in there, in UBW she freezes when she sees the effects of the Blood Fort ... Rin despite all her bravado is still unexperienced.

Rin was not "taking it easy" with Shirou, she simply did not wanted for him to be hurt for several reasons, none actually related of him being a "second rate magnus".

>> No.2220209

>>2220170
There were some semantics about that in the game, I agree that it sounds like bullshit. He, however, wasn't the one pulling Avenger out. And in his infamous qoute about the two madmen, he stated that it was all bullshit himself.

It's just "It's supposed to be evil, but you can't take it's right for a living. You don't know if it won't refuse it's nature. I did, for the most part"
Also, that's one of basic ideas of Hollow Ataraxia.

>> No.2220224

>>2220209

I think what it mean was "you cannot presume something that is not even born yet to be evil".

>> No.2220229

>>2220209
So in the end, it all boils down to "I can only feel pleasure in the pain of others, so let's give everybody a lot of pain"?

>> No.2220257

>>2220229
What is wrong about that is, as some Anon pointed out before me, he was wanting to cause pain in Fate, but in HF he was going to die when Avenger was hatching(well, at that point, he really was dead already, but whatever) and it wasn't him who was supposed to take his power. He didn't really have reason to fight anyone, as he wasn't the one causing the pain, so no pleasure included. So his fight, if it wasn't just fighting Shirou because he was THE Emiya and because it would amuse him if he failed in the end, his last fight HAD to be ideological in some way.

>> No.2220272

>>2220257
Actually, Kotomine stated that since both of them were going to die anyways, he was going to take out his anger on Shirou.

>> No.2220286

>>2220257
>He didn't really have reason to fight anyone, as he wasn't the one causing the pain, so no pleasure included.

He was following the exact logic of Kiritsugu's method.

By preventing Shirou from destroying Angra Mainyu and Angra Mainyu killing billions, he was killing billions.
"No pleasure" indeed.

>> No.2220287

>>2220272
One wonders what was he angry about if he didn't have anything to lose and was a masochist, so pain didn't mean anything for him.

>> No.2220303

>>2220286
well, I can live with that

oh, wait.

>> No.2220311

>>2220286
What? No. Kotomine wasn't protecting Angra Mainyu to kill anybody. He was protecting it because it was his "answer", and he didn't know how to do anything but seek it.

>> No.2221969

I think the part about him being unable to enjoy life is bullshit, seeing how he eagerly ate those hot-as-hell Mapo Tofu.

>>
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action