/jp/ - Otaku Culture

File: 69 KB, 640x480, hands.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]

Anonymous Sat Jul 27 10:45:18 2013 No.11233871 [Reply] [Original]

Which was better, /jp/, Higurashi or Umineko?

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 10:46:34 2013 No.11233878 umineko if ep6, 7, and 8 didn't exist

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 10:51:33 2013 No.11233884 K1 better protag. Umineko better if you ignore Chiru. Higurashi has the best story chapter though. Umineko has the better motion graphics.

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 11:18:19 2013 No.11233930 File: 101 KB, 496x480, Goldsmith.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] Umineko had this guy.

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 11:49:19 2013 No.11233988 Characters: Higurashi = Umineko Setting: Umineko > Higurashi Plot: Higurashi > Umineko Story: Umineko > Higurashi Execution: Higurashi > Umineko Overall: Higurashi: 8.3 Umineko 8.2 HIGURASHI WINS

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 12:00:35 2013 No.11234011 >>11233988 That makes no sense That whole list says they're equal, where did that extra .1 come from?

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 12:05:04 2013 No.11234025 >>11234011 All it says is that the characters are as good, for the other points it just says which is rated higher, nothing about by how much. And the categories are probably not weighted equal either.

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 12:06:49 2013 No.11234027 >>11234011 I was just going to put that they're both 8s in my book, but I arbitrarily chose Higurashi to give an extra point to because of nostalgia.

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 12:21:20 2013 No.11234077 /jp/

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 12:29:36 2013 No.11234112 >>11233878 You probably mean if ep 2-8 didn't exist.

Anonymous Sat Jul 27 12:36:06 2013 No.11234141

>>11233871
Higurashi described the border between sanity and insanity like how Umineko explored what it meant for something to be known or unknown. They seem similar but are fundamentally different for me, so I don't compare them. That said, my I have more Umineko pictures/music than Higurashi pictures/music so if I had to choose, Umineko wins.

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 12:56:50 2013 No.11234198 File: 349 KB, 907x1268, 136105389154.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] Higurashi in my opinion.

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 13:27:36 2013 No.11234253 No one here has actually read Higurashi.

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 13:28:07 2013 No.11234256 >>11233988 I agree with everything. But they deserve a 9.

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 13:29:51 2013 No.11234260 >>11234253 I read the entire first episode and half of the second then stopped because I got confused as to why the store magically restarted in a different timeline when it seemed as though the story was over.

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 13:32:51 2013 No.11234269 >>11234260 Did you think they would never explain that?

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 13:34:21 2013 No.11234273 >>11234256 Yeah, they probably do atleast deserve that.

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 13:41:22 2013 No.11234301 >>11234256 They would be a 9 if they didn't have certain cringeworthy scenes. I'm talking about Irie's ridiculous speech in Matsuribayashi-hen and Erika's chopstick crap. Everything else is amazing.

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 13:52:37 2013 No.11234349 >>11234269 The Shion/Mion things was dragging on for quite a long time. I was tired of club games type stuff and just wanted more murder mystery stuff after what I previously just saw.

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 14:07:39 2013 No.11234411 Higurashi is a masterpiece, Umineko is a flawed greater masterpiece.

Anonymous Sat Jul 27 18:20:37 2013 No.11235318

Higurashi is a masterpiece and every chapter is great. Umineko has two great episodes (3 and 4) while the rest are mediocre or absolute shit. So Higurashi easily wins. Also with Higurashi you can feel the passionate doujin attitude and that Ryuukishi truly cares about the characters and the fans, whereas in Umineko he is full of himself and talks down to his readers. I guess the fame from Higurashi got to his head.

They're pretty different though so I could see someone potentially preferring Umineko. If they had shit taste.

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 18:23:22 2013 No.11235325 Higurashi

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 18:24:07 2013 No.11235328 >>11235318 >and 4 Stopped reading there.

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 22:44:41 2013 No.11236151 I thought the slice of life shit in higgy was boring, but the intrigue and plotting in umineko was a lot more interesting. Umineko in general was a lot more interesting to me.

>>	Anonymous Sat Jul 27 22:48:10 2013 No.11236169 I watched the anime and Higurashi more I liked

Reply to thread

Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action

Advanced search
Text to find
Subject [?]Search by post subject. Leave empty for any.
Username [?]Search for user name. Leave empty for any user name.
Tripcode [?]Search for tripcode. Leave empty for any.
Email [?]Search by email. Leave empty for any.
Filename [?]Search by image filename. Leave empty for any.
From Date [?]Enter what date to start searching from. Format is YYYY-MM-DD
To Date [?]Enter what date to start searching until. Format is YYYY-MM-DD
Image hash
Search in	All Posts OPs Only
Deleted posts	Show all posts Show only deleted posts Only show non-deleted posts
Internal posts	Show all posts Show only internal posts Show only archived posts
Order	New posts first Old posts first
Capcode	All Posts Only by Users Only by Mods Only by Admins Only by Developers
Results	Posts Threads
Action	[ Simple ]