Rate these: FSN: Tsukihime: Sharin no Kuni: G-Senjou no Maou: Clannad Ever17: Remember11: Quartett: Symphonic Rain: Umineko: Higurashi: Cross Channel: Symphonic Rain:

File: 313 KB, 1400x875, 1295795056769.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]

Anonymous Fri Feb 4 05:03:08 2011 No.6911354 [Reply] [Original]

Rate these:
FSN:
Tsukihime:
Sharin no Kuni:
G-Senjou no Maou:
Clannad
Ever17:
Remember11:
Quartett:
Symphonic Rain:
Umineko:
Higurashi:
Cross Channel:
Symphonic Rain:

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 05:06:08 2011 No.6911359 FSN:3 Tsukihime:4 Sharin no Kuni:9 G-Senjou no Maou:5 Clannad:6 Ever17:7 Remember11:7 Quartett:7 Symphonic Rain:6 Umineko:2 Higurashi:4 Cross Channel:7

Anonymous Fri Feb 4 05:08:08 2011 No.6911365

FSN: 4/10
Tsukihime: 5/10
Sharin no Kuni: 4/10
G-Senjou no Maou: 3/10
Clannad: 1/10
Ever17: 6/10
Remember11: 6/10
Quartett: 5/10
Symphonic Rain: 5/10
Umineko: 2/10
Higurashi: 2/10
Cross Channel: 4/10

The Maiden Rape Assault- Violent Semen Inferno- 10/10
Reika Bitch Training- 10/10
Musume Shimai- 10/10

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 05:10:08 2011 No.6911373 FSN:8 Tsukihime:8 Sharin no Kuni:9 G-Senjou no Maou:7 Clannad:9 Ever17:8 Remember11:6 Quartett:8 Symphonic Rain:9 Umineko:7 Higurashi:7 Cross Channel:9

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 05:12:08 2011 No.6911380 File: 8 KB, 206x190, DERP.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] what this thread amounts to

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 05:13:08 2011 No.6911383 FSN: never even completed 1 route, lol cooking Tsukihime: 4 Sharin no Kuni: 8 G-Senjou no Maou: 8 Clannad: n/a Ever17: not completed 5 Remember11: n/a Quartett: n/a Symphonic Rain: 7 Umineko: n/a Higurashi: n/a Cross Channel: 6

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 05:16:08 2011 No.6911388 File: 38 KB, 500x375, feelsgoodman.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] FSN:0/10 Tsukihime:0/10 Umineko:0/10

Anonymous Fri Feb 4 05:25:08 2011 No.6911408
File: 330 KB, 1280x720, [umee]_Shiki_-_19_[CBF773E3].mkv_snapshot_06.45_[2010.12.10_18.12.46].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]

FSN: 7/10
Tsukihime: 10/10
Sharin no Kuni: 8/10
G-Senjou no Maou: 7/10
Clannad: 7/10
Ever17: 8/10
Remember11: 6/10
Quartett: 9/10
Symphonic Rain: ?/10
Umineko: 6/10
Higurashi: 8/10
Cross Channel: 7/10
Symphonic Rain: ??/10

It's not like Tsukihime is perfect, it's just I haven't found anything better yet.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 05:39:08 2011 No.6911437 >>6911408 I've only played through tsukihime and saya no uta. Saya no uta was a lot better. But I liked tsukihime a lot too.

Anonymous Fri Feb 4 05:48:08 2011 No.6911456

FSN: 7.5/10
Tsukihime: 7/10
Sharin no Kuni: 9/10
G-Senjou no Maou: 8/10
Clannad: 9/10
Ever17: 9/10
Remember11: ?
Quartett: ?
Symphonic Rain: ?
Umineko: 6/10
Higurashi: 6/10
Cross Channel: 8/10

Umineko would be higher if episodes 6-8 weren't complete shit.

Anonymous Fri Feb 4 06:08:08 2011 No.6911501

FSN 84/100
Tsukihime: 84/100
Sharin no Kuni: 93/100
G-Senjou no Maou: 81/100
Clannad: 92/100
Ever17: 97/100
Remember11: 54/100
Quartett: 84/100
Symphonic Rain: 93/100
Uminekos
Episode 1:80/100
Episode 2: 75/100
Episode 3:90/100
Episode 4: 70/100
Episode 5: 76/100
Episode 6: 51/100
Episode 7: 60/100
Higurashi: 81/100 (only the question arks)
Cross Channel: 81/100
Symphonic Rain: I answered this already, why is this here two times silly OP.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 06:32:08 2011 No.6911546 FSN: 7 Tsukihime: 6 Sharin no Kuni: 9 G-Senjou no Maou: 8 Clannad: 7 Ever17: 8 Remember11: 7 Quartett: 8 Symphonic Rain: 9 Umineko: 7 Higurashi: 7 Cross Channel: 7 Symphonic Rain: 9

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 06:35:08 2011 No.6911559 FSN: 10 Tsukihime: 9 Sharin no Kuni: 8.5 G-Senjou no Maou: 8 Clannad 9 Ever17: 9 Remember11: 8 Quartett: Symphonic Rain: Umineko: 8 Higurashi: 10 Cross Channel: 8

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 06:38:08 2011 No.6911569 Let me just post my MAL account...

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 07:28:08 2011 No.6911656 FSN: Real deal Tsukihime:DISNEY Sharin no Kuni: DISNEY G-Senjou no Maou: DISNEY Clannad DISNEY Ever17: DISNEY Remember11: DISNEY Quartett: DISNEY Symphonic Rain: DISNEY Umineko: DISNEY Higurashi: DISNEY Cross Channel: DISNEY Symphonic Rain: DISNEY

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 07:50:08 2011 No.6911703 FSN: 10 Tsukihime: 4 Sharin no Kuni: 4 G-Senjou no Maou: 4 Clannad: 4 Ever17: 4 Remember11: 4 Quartett: 4 Symphonic Rain: 4 Umineko: 10 Higurashi: 4 Cross Channel: 4 Symphonic Rain: 4

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 07:53:08 2011 No.6911710 FSN:10 Tsukihime:10 Sharin no Kuni: 5 G-Senjou no Maou: 3 Clannad 2 Ever17: 4 Remember11: 5 Quartett:1 Symphonic Rain:1 Umineko:2 Higurashi:4 Cross Channel:5

Anonymous Fri Feb 4 07:56:08 2011 No.6911721

FSN: Barely came
Tsukihime: Unfappable
Sharin no Kuni: Came
G-Senjou no Maou: Came hard
Clannad: Didnt bother
Ever17: Barely came
Remember11: Barely came
Quartett: Came hard
Symphonic Rain: Didnt bother
Umineko: Didnt bother
Higurashi: Didnt bother
Cross Channel: Came

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 08:05:08 2011 No.6911744 >>6911721 I like you.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 08:14:08 2011 No.6911764 >>6911721 Best post of the century right here.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 08:18:08 2011 No.6911772 File: 36 KB, 487x350, same person.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] >>6911721 >>6911744 >>6911764

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 08:19:08 2011 No.6911774 >>6911721 >FSN: Barely came You homo?

Anonymous Fri Feb 4 08:24:08 2011 No.6911788

>>6911774
Not the poster, but I thought most of the scenes in FSN were unfappable. Saber's first scene was all PAIN and stupid Shirou, her second one was all out-of-character, Rin's scene was PAIN with tears (yeah, I don't like my girls suffering), Sakura's first scene must have been pretty bad because I don't even remember it, and Sakura's second scene I could finally fap to.

Nasu is a hard S, making the girls bleed, hurt, suffer and cry so much, it's no wonder not everyone likes his scenes. I found Len's scene in Kagetsu Tohya and Rin's scene in FSN so bad I couldn't even fully read them because they made me sad, and sadness is the worst mood-killer there is.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 08:45:08 2011 No.6911826 Now this >>6911788 is a homo.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 10:04:08 2011 No.6911992 >>6911772 Spoilertag this shit.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 10:29:08 2011 No.6912045 FSN:7/10. Tsukihime:4/10 Sharin no Kuni:n/a G-Senjou no Maou: 9/10 Clannad:6/10 Ever17:BABIES FIRST VN along with YMK Remember11:n/a Quartett:n/a Symphonic Rain:9/10 Umineko: Question: 8/10 Chiru: 2/10 Higurashi:4/10 Cross Channel:8/10

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 10:31:08 2011 No.6912049 >>6912045 >Ever17:BABIES FIRST VN along with YMK >G-Senjou no Maou: 9/10

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 10:34:08 2011 No.6912055 FSN: 7/10 Tsukihime: 6/10 Sharin no Kuni: 4/10 G-Senjou no Maou: 7/10 Clannad: 6/10 Ever17: 8/10 Remember11: 8/10 Quartett: -/10 Symphonic Rain: 7/10 Umineko: 8/10 Higurashi: 9/10 Cross Channel: 9/10

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 10:34:08 2011 No.6912057 >>6912049 You people don't know a good VN when you see one, G-Senjou no Maou was a masterpiece.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 10:36:08 2011 No.6912064 >>6912057 Sure Mr. Troll.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 10:37:08 2011 No.6912067 >>6912057 Shit scenario full of holes, most characters are irrelevant, pacing is shit. Masterpiece my ass, you just have shit taste.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 10:37:08 2011 No.6912069 >>6912057 That doesn't change the fact that liking G-Senjou while talking down on Ever17 being "babby's first vn" is retarded, G-Senjou is like, babby's second vn.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 10:39:08 2011 No.6912071 >>6912067 I can't wait until Muramasa is translated, everyone in /a/ and /v/ plays the fuck out of it, and then /jp/ suddenly starts yapping on how shitty it actually is. Truly a day to look forward to.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 10:40:08 2011 No.6912074 >>6912071 Please don' t compare Muramasa with that.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 10:40:08 2011 No.6912075 >>6912071 G-senjou was never called a masterpiece or anything though. And who care about what the faggots here think.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 10:41:08 2011 No.6912076 File: 28 KB, 1013x381, G-Senjou is bad.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] now I know what to NOT read

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 10:42:08 2011 No.6912082 >>6912076 What's the name of this script?

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 10:43:08 2011 No.6912084 >>6912071 G-senjou was always made fun for its huge plot holes, it was true even when it was released in Japan. Heck I even remember the threads here. It's definitely not a bad VN but nobody ever thought it was a masterpiece.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 10:43:08 2011 No.6912085 >>6912076 People with shit taste forcing their opinion.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 10:45:08 2011 No.6912088 >>6912076 Just to clarify, I'm the last poster there, and I didn't mean to say that G-Senjou is bad, just that dissing ever17 because of the people who play it (and considering G-Senjou isn't much better in that field) is fucking retarded.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 10:45:08 2011 No.6912089 FSN:8/10 Tsukihime: n/a Sharin no Kuni: 8/10 G-Senjou no Maou: 7.5/10 Clannad: n/a Ever17: 8.5/10 Remember11: n/a probably 7/10 Quartett: not finished yet but 8.5/10 Symphonic Rain: 8.5/10 Umineko: 8/10 Higurashi: 8/10 Cross Channel: n/a

Anonymous Fri Feb 4 10:48:08 2011 No.6912099

>>6912049
>>6912069
I'm the guy who posted those ratings and apologize for the misunderstanding. Althought i did it with trollish intentions, I wasn't really downtalking Ever17, I was just making fun of /jp/'s idolizing of that particular VN alongside YMK.

Sorry for any rage attacks i may have caused. And no, G-sen is in no way a masterpiece, It was an entertaining read with some nice music.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 10:49:08 2011 No.6912101 >>6912082 http://userscripts.org/scripts/show/44327

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 10:52:08 2011 No.6912117 >>6912101 Thanks.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 11:01:08 2011 No.6912154 FSN: 8 Tsukihime: 6 Sharin no Kuni: 6 G-Senjou no Maou: 5 Clannad 8 Ever17: 7 Remember11: 7 Quartett: - Symphonic Rain: - Umineko: 7 Higurashi: 9 Cross Channel: 5

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 11:03:08 2011 No.6912159 File: 354 KB, 300x300, keep on, keeping on.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] >implying YMK and ever17 are babies first VN >implying Tsukihime and FSN aren't babies first VN >implying you aren't a babby Rude sage.

Anonymous Fri Feb 4 11:14:08 2011 No.6912193

Fuck your shitty numerical rating.
This is the true /jp/ opinions.
Summary for those not in the image.
FSN - All the heroines are sluts!
Tsukihime - Twilight lite
Umineko - Newfags first Sound Novel.
PW - FSN ripoff.
ignanock - furry disney shit
Saya no Uta - really really average
Kazoku Keikaku - "The powerlevel is over 9000", CENSORSHIP
Phantom - DVD FORMAT
Sharin no Kuni - Overrated and pretentious shit hurr durr I purposely act as if I hurt my legs, I smoke drugs NO I DONT just trolling
Kikokugai - Kill Bill the VN
Hanachirasu - Kill Bill the VN except you are playing on the side that is being hunted by the revenger
Ever17 - Archimedes and physics class
Cross Channel - pantsu jokes everywhere
YMK - hipster drug is so cool vn
Swan Song - autism the vn
kira kira - k-on the vn
wanko - furry shit
Muramasa - Mecha shit ver. A
Gekkou - furry shit
3days - Higurashi meets Naruto
11eyes - lol Bleach lol slut
Baldr Sky - Mecha shit ver. B
Little Busters, Air, Kanon - KEY AIDS
Planetarian - chobits the vn
G-senjou no Maou - lol retarded coincidence plot twist with 75% shitty heroines and fake incest
Clannad - lol lets collect dragonballs and revive my waifu
Stein's;Gate - pretentious sci-fi mumbojumbo shit
Sharnoth - copypasta shit is copypasta is copypasta
YU-NO - shit art
Sumaga - meta shit with shit protagonist
999 - Saw the VN
Muv Luv - I rather watch ESPN for real lacross or Iron chef
Sengoku Rance - glorified rape

Anonymous Fri Feb 4 11:30:08 2011 No.6912245

FSN: Dat Lancer
Tsukihime:Dat Arihiko
Sharin no Kuni: Dat Ririko
G-Senjou no Maou: Dat Hair
Clannad: -
Ever17: Dat Implied Rape
Remember11: -
Quartett: Wasn't for me.
Symphonic Rain: I don't want to finish this because I just know things that will make me feel terrible are going to happen.
Umineko: Utter Shit after 3.
Higurashi: -
Cross Channel: Wasn't for me

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 11:52:08 2011 No.6912295 FSN: 9 Tsukihime: 8 Sharin no Kuni: 6 G-Senjou no Maou: 9 Clannad: Not played Ever17: 10 Remember11: 9 Quartett: Not played Symphonic Rain: Not played Umineko: 9 Higurashi: 8 Cross Channel: 8

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 11:59:08 2011 No.6912309 FSN: n/a, watched the anime. Tsukihime: 7 Sharin no Kuni: n/a G-Senjou no Maou: 8 Clannad: n/a Ever17: 10 Remember11: n/a Quartett: Will read next week. Symphonic Rain: 11 Umineko: n/a Higurashi: n/a Cross Channel: 9

Anonymous Fri Feb 4 12:01:08 2011 No.6912313
File: 231 KB, 1440x810, 1296755457817.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]

FSN: 9
Tsukihime: 8
Sharin no Kuni: 0
G-Senjou no Maou: 0
Clannad 0
Ever17: 0
Remember11: 0
Quartett: 0
Symphonic Rain: 0
Umineko: 0
Higurashi: 0
Cross Channel: 0
Symphonic Rain: 0

Anonymous Fri Feb 4 12:28:08 2011 No.6912376
File: 1.36 MB, 1654x1223, 1295927887096.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]

FSN: 7
Tsukihime:6
Sharin no Kuni:6
G-Senjou no Maou:6
Clannad: 8
Ever17: 9
Remember11:6
Quartett: n/a
Symphonic Rain: 10
Umineko: n/a
Higurashi: 6
Cross Channel:8
Symphonic Rain:

Nanaya !yrBrqfF1Ew Fri Feb 4 12:47:08 2011 No.6912451

FSN: 8
Tsukihime: 7
Sharin no Kuni: 7
G-Senjou no Maou:7
Clannad: 6
Ever17:7
Remember11:on backlog
Quartett:n/a
Symphonic Rain:backlog
Umineko:n/a
Higurashi:n/a
Cross Channel:backlog
Symphonic Rain:you said this twice

I've got a huge backlog of VN's to read and it only gets larger. One day I may actually start to go through my backlog

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 13:13:08 2011 No.6912527 FSN:5 Tsukihime:5 Sharin no Kuni:5(+2 fuck yeah norio wakamoto !!!) G-Senjou no Maou: not played Clannad: 2 Ever17:3 Remember11:3 Quartett:7 Symphonic Rain:6 Umineko:8 Higurashi:8 Cross Channel:8 Symphonic Rain:6 (did you not get it the first time ?? )

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 13:17:08 2011 No.6912533 FSN: 7/10 Tsukihime: 7/10 Sharin no Kuni: 8/10 G-Senjou no Maou: 9/10 Clannad: N/A Ever17: 9/10 Remember11: N/A Quartett: N/A Symphonic Rain: N/A Umineko: 6/10 Higurashi: N/A Cross Channel: N/A Symphonic Rain: N/A

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 13:19:08 2011 No.6912538 >>6912527 The second Symphonic Rain is obviously for the da capo routes.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 13:20:08 2011 No.6912542 FSN: 8 Tsukihime: 9 Sharin no Kuni: ? G-Senjou no Maou: ? Clannad: ? Ever17: 10 Remember11: ? Quartett: ? Symphonic Rain: ? Umineko 1: 7 Higurashi: ? Cross Channel: ? Symphonic Rain: ?

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 13:30:08 2011 No.6912565 FSN: 3 Tsukihime: 7 Sharin no Kuni: - G-Senjou no Maou: - Clannad - Ever17: 10 Remember11: 5 Quartett: - Symphonic Rain: - Umineko: 9 for ep 1-4, 8 for Chiru Higurashi: 9 Cross Channel: 6 Symphonic Rain: -

Anonymous Fri Feb 4 13:49:08 2011 No.6912607

FSN: 1/10
Tsukihime: N/A
Sharin no Kuni: 2/10
G-Senjou no Maou: 2/10
Clannad: N/A
Ever17: 2/10
Remember11: Currently playing. 1/10 so far
Quartett: Currently playing. 2/10 so far
Symphonic Rain: 10/10
Umineko: 0/10
Higurashi: 1/10
Cross Channel: 2/10
Symphonic Rain: 10/10

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 14:02:08 2011 No.6912658 FSN:5 / Saber sux Tsukihime:9 Sharin no Kuni:10 G-Senjou no Maou:9 Clannad:8 Ever17:9 Remember11: Quartett:9 Symphonic Rain:9 Umineko:11 Higurashi: Cross Channel:10 Symphonic Rain:Wha?...

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 14:05:08 2011 No.6912668 FSN:10 Tsukihime:10 Sharin no Kuni:5 G-Senjou no Maou:2 Clannad:1 Ever17:8 Remember11:1 Quartett:1 Symphonic Rain:1 Umineko:10 Higurashi:10 Cross Channel:1

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 14:42:08 2011 No.6912847 Damn, most of you fags really have bad taste. Not surprising though

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:05:08 2011 No.6912967 File: 659 KB, 1680x1050, 1287824318805.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] >>6911437 >>6911437 >Saya No Uta Good Taste Detected.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:06:08 2011 No.6912979 >>6911437 >Saya no Uta Shit taste detected

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:10:08 2011 No.6912996 FSN: 7/10 Tsukihime: 7/10 Ever17: 7/10 Umineko: 7/10 All VNs seem to leave me kind of apathetic.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:11:08 2011 No.6913004 MLA: 10/10, timeless masterpiece, nothing else is worth the time.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:12:08 2011 No.6913010 Subarashiki Hibi ~Furenzoku Sonzai~: 9/10 untranslatable masterpiece that is an insurmountable wall of the ergoe medium

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:16:08 2011 No.6913030 http://amaterasu.is.moelicious.be/blog/?p=824 The new unsurmountable untranslatable wall of the eroge medium

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:19:08 2011 No.6913046 >>6913030 Ixrec sure loves the word metaphysics. I also love that "well this game is a 9, but also a 10 or 8 or 7 depending on your tastes", makes for great reviews.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:20:08 2011 No.6913048 >>6913030 No one cares about the opinions of Furryshit devs. Now if it were Moogy on the other hand saying that, well, it'd be a different story.

Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:22:08 2011 No.6913059

FSN: 8
Tsukihime: didn't finish but 7 as far as I got
Sharin no Kuni: didn't read lol
G-Senjou no Maou: didn't play lol
Clannad: didn't finish but 7 as far as I got
Ever17: didn't finish but 6 as far as I got
Remember11: didn't play lol
Quartett: didn't finish but 9 as far as I got
Symphonic Rain: didn't play lol
Umineko: didn't play lol
Higurashi: didn't play lol
Cross Channel: didn't finish but 7 as far as I got
Symphonic Rain: didn't play lol
Feels ADHD man.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:24:08 2011 No.6913067 >>6913059 >didn't finish quartett It's like 3 hours, tops.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:25:08 2011 No.6913072 >>6913048 Oh you card.

Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:28:08 2011 No.6913083

>>6913067
I went on auto with 1.5 speed, took definitely more than that to get to the first ero scene after which I stopped.
But I alt-tabbed all the time, so dunno how long it took exactly.
I'll finish it soon, since it's actually entertaining all the time.
I'll finish/play the others(and ones I didn't finish that aren't on this list) someday too... at least that's what I keep telling myself.

Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:28:08 2011 No.6913086

FSN: Never played it
Tsukihime: Never played it
Sharin no Kuni: Never played it
G-Senjou no Maou: Never played it
Clannad: Never played it
Ever 17: Got through an hour, uninstalled
Remember 11: Never played it
Quartett: Never played it
Symphonic Rain: Never played it
Umineko: Never played it
Higurashi: Never played it
Cross Channel: Never played it

I've played about 60+ VNs but I don't generally like the shit you guys do. I like moege primarily.

My favorites so far
Galaxy Angel: 10/10
Hatsukoi: 10/10
One: To the Radiant Season: 9/10
Shuffle Essence+: 9/10
Izumo 2: 9/10
Clover Point: 9/10

Some others for comparison
Tsun na Kanojo Dere na Kanojo: 6/10
Oyatsu no Jikan: 7/10 (one route only, the others, 4/10)
Princess Bride: 4/10
Koichu Koi ni Koi Suru Kata Omoi: 5/10
Hime Nochi Honey: 3/10, quite possibly the worst VN I've ever played
Da Capo: 6/10, had its moments, I liked Moe's route
Nekokawaiigari/Dote Up a Cat: 6/10, again it had its moments
Kiss Me Me!: cute, worth about a 5/10

I've played a SHIT TON of moege though. Currently playing Imouto Smile, it's not great. Will wait to apply judgment.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:34:08 2011 No.6913103 >>6913086 You shouldn't call other people's tastes "shit". Especially when moege are often considered "shit" by many.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:34:08 2011 No.6913104 FSN: 6 Tsukihime: 5 Sharin no Kuni: 8 G-Senjou no Maou: 7 Clannad: 10, even though the pacing was painful Ever17: 7 Remember11: 6 Quartett: 6 Symphonic Rain: 7 Umineko: 6 Higurashi: 5 Cross Channel: 8 Symphonic Rain: 7, durr

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:36:08 2011 No.6913110 >>6913103 Not this guy. But anyone who consider moege shit by default have no business reading eroge

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:37:08 2011 No.6913122 >>6913103 The way he used the word shit there wasn't disparaging. Is english not your native language?

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:38:08 2011 No.6913127 >>6913103 > Especially when moege are often considered "shit" by many. I sure love me some sheep thinking.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:40:08 2011 No.6913137 FSN: 6 Tsukihime: 8 Sharin no Kuni: 7 G-Senjou no Maou: N/A Clannad: 10 Ever17: 8 Remember11: N/A Quartett: N/A Symphonic Rain: 9 Umineko: 4 Higurashi: 6 Cross Channel: 9 To me, 6 and above is enjoyable and definitely worth my time.

>>	Shameimaru Aya is my girlfriend !3y3mjHUKjI Fri Feb 4 15:41:08 2011 No.6913142 File: 157 KB, 896x716, 3743110.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] >>6913127 Don't mind me. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e0mx5ERj1eI

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:44:08 2011 No.6913148 File: 110 KB, 600x600, 27b65db57809649d7f68ba106625c8fl.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google] >>6913142 >Cake

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:49:08 2011 No.6913169 A translation seems to drop /jp/'s general opinion of a title by several points.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 15:55:08 2011 No.6913208 FSN: 6 Tsukihime: 4 Sharin no Kuni: 7 G-Senjou no Maou: 9 Clannad: 10 Ever17: 5 Remember11: 6 Quartett: Havent played Symphonic Rain: 9 Umineko: Havent played Higurashi: Havent played Cross Channel: 7

Anonymous Fri Feb 4 16:06:08 2011 No.6913269

FSN: 8
Tsukihime: 7
Sharin no Kuni: 8
G-Senjou no Maou: 7
Clannad: Nope
Ever17: 9
Remember11: Will read someday
Quartett: 6
Symphonic Rain: 7
Umineko: Currently at ep3
Higurashi: Not played yet
Cross Channel: 7

I give 6 to things i enjoy. 7 to things i deem actually good.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 16:08:08 2011 No.6913276 >>6913110 This.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 16:10:08 2011 No.6913287 >>6913103 I was saying shit, like, stuff; you know, not shit as like, shit.

>>	Anonymous Fri Feb 4 16:10:08 2011 No.6913293 >>6913103 This guy probably came from /a/, just ignore him.

Reply to thread

Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action

Advanced search
Text to find
Subject [?]Search by post subject. Leave empty for any.
Username [?]Search for user name. Leave empty for any user name.
Tripcode [?]Search for tripcode. Leave empty for any.
Email [?]Search by email. Leave empty for any.
Filename [?]Search by image filename. Leave empty for any.
From Date [?]Enter what date to start searching from. Format is YYYY-MM-DD
To Date [?]Enter what date to start searching until. Format is YYYY-MM-DD
Image hash
Search in	All Posts OPs Only
Deleted posts	Show all posts Show only deleted posts Only show non-deleted posts
Internal posts	Show all posts Show only internal posts Show only archived posts
Order	New posts first Old posts first
Capcode	All Posts Only by Users Only by Mods Only by Admins Only by Developers
Results	Posts Threads
Action	[ Simple ]

/jp/ - Otaku Culture