[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/jp/ - Otaku Culture


View post   

File: 1.36 MB, 850x1473, 43059483598034.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45498988 No.45498988 [Reply] [Original]

Failed vampire hunter? Adopted orphan? Lunarian spy? It's never really cleared up or given a concrete answer beyond rumours between characters in any canon source how exactly they first met and where Sakuya is even from. Despite her claimed age to be around 17 or in her late teens in several print works its unlikely Sakuya is really that young or even close beyond looking around that age. The SDM, it's owner and likely most of their household are from the Outside World and most likely Europe, is Sakuya even from Japan, yet alone Gensokyo?

Does she even know her real name or identify? Her near unquestioning loyalty to her mistress and difficultly knowing how to act or interact around humans in the earlier games suggests either she could either have been brainwashed into cult-like subservience with a loss of any previous identify or adopted and raised to be a servant by Remilia with little if any knowledge of anything outside her daily duties and service to her mistress. If she was a vampire hunter and failed to exterminate Remilia then it would explain why she ended up brainwashed and given Remilia has a adopted and cared for a human for a short time before they fled the SDM could also hint at that as a possible origin.

What other theories are there or that could be plausible and have at least have a very basic grounding in canon? Outright headcanon isn't really welcome but other direct or loosely canonical theories are encouraged.

>> No.45499092
File: 393 KB, 2048x1844, 079102d23b4c4ce8c2ad0d966169a606ce7f2548.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45499092

Sakuya was a vampire hunter and she tried to hunt down Remi and Flan but lost to them and became their servant.
Source: I made it up.

>> No.45500567

drunk japanese man reads jojos bizarre adventure and recycles pc98 character for his latest gothic lolita game

>> No.45501362
File: 353 KB, 1169x826, 95922696_p1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45501362

Remilia was the horror of the night: the vampire. But over time people forgot the fear of dark and she lost her purpose in life. However, in 1888, Jack the Ripper (Sakuya) appeared and brought back the fear of the night. At this point Remilia met Sakuya and made her a servant, then they traveled to Gensokyo.

>> No.45501445
File: 80 KB, 1189x405, 105614.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45501445

this shit is from 2004 and so far nothing, god I hate zun

>> No.45502875

>>45499092
I love the vampire hunter Sakuya that gets buck-broken by Remilia theory, it gives them so much depth.

>> No.45502977

>>45501445
Classic ZUN alzheimer symptom

>> No.45503008
File: 287 KB, 2249x495, IMG_2004.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45503008

>>45502875
Remi did what to her?

>> No.45503122

>>45501362
I didn't know Sakuya was Jewish

>> No.45503184
File: 147 KB, 600x470, 1694888883181590.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45503184

>>45502875
>>45503122
>>>/pol/

>> No.45504963

>>45498988
my headcanon is that Sakuya was ostracized for her powers, to the point where even her parents abandoned her, and eventually Remi just found her

>> No.45505086 [DELETED] 
File: 193 KB, 570x700, bound sakuya.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45505086

>>45503008
>>45503184
*WHIP*
Remilia: "What's your name? Say it! 'Sakuya', who are ya? Say your name." *WHIP*
Girl: [cries in pain]
Remilia: "What's your name?"
Girl: 'Sakuya'.
Remilia: Ay, say it again. Say it louder so the fairy maids can hear you! What's your name?! *WHIP*
Girl: [gasping] 'Sakuya'. My name is 'Sakuya'...

>> No.45508151

>>45498988
I never bought into the "failed vampire hunter" story. A lot of the other myths just feel like red herrings to obscure the true background of Sakuya, that Zun eludes to here and there. Perhaps Sakuya didn't start outright hating other humans until they started ostracizing her for being 'different', it's also possible
she didn't allow herself to turn "cold" towards humans until 'certain events' forced her to do so ( attempting to kill her or killing off her family). I think her bad ending in IN, her conversation with Eiki and the names of some of her spellcards heavily suggest the kind of person she may have been before
working for the vampires. So the idea of her hunting vampires on behalf of humans just seems rather contradictory given those suggestions. My own headcanon is that she may have actually sought out the Scarlets herself, after having reached her limit with humans or being on the run with no other recourse,
learning of the ability to "manipulate destiny". Hoping to bypass whatever horrible fate was in store for her or even thinking she could become a different person entirely and erase her current identity, hence being given her current name. Also noting something interesting from Mei Ling's Soku ending, Sakuya
mentioned how "lucky" Mei Ling was to be able to dream, hinting that Sakuya may not be able to for some reason. Possibly due to her powers? But could even be due to some psychological trauma or a self suggestion, forcing herself not recall her past life in her memories as she's now living a 'new' life.
One other thing I found interesting, regarding the ideas of her being from another world according to Perfect Memento, in PCC when Yukari mentions the "That the borders between the pure land and hell are fading. This place has become a lawless land of oni." Sakuya replies "Hell is not as scary as Makai.
Oni, compared to the devil, are nothing at all." Just exactly how would Sakuya know anything about Makai? Was she a human born in Makai (parallels with Yumeko)? Was Remilia originally based in Makai and that's where Sakuya was either brought to or had traveled to find her, before moving to Gensokyo?
And one more theory, that despite her contract to Remi, perhaps Sakuya never returned after her bad ending in IN, allowing her to return to her past self, never again able to lead a normal life. Additionally could've been "all in the cards" as per Remi's ability, setting Sakuya free in a new world.

>> No.45509946
File: 912 KB, 850x989, 4309583950834534.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45509946

Sakuya rejecting humans to such an extent she flees them or past experiences with them to devote herself to a mistress and by extension her sister of a species that preys on humans for food. Either Sakuya went through some real shit or that's a deep grimsokyo story even darker than Alice and the eight men who never returned from the forest. The misanthrope who dedicated her life to serving vampires.

>> No.45510248

>>45503184
No I mean really, they did DNA testing on some shit that belonged to jack the ripper and found he was actually Jewish

>> No.45510578

>>45499092
I like the idea that everyone in her household was once someone who came looking for her with the intent of killing her. Like Patchouli was once a magician who sought to rid an area of its vampiric menace and Meiling was a martial artist who sought to test her skills against the unholy strength of a vampire. They were all beaten but won over by Remilia's mercy, generosity, and charm. She offered Patchouli a library of esoteric knowledge the likes of which she had never seen and Meiling more tests of strength as a guardian, since there was no shortage of people seeking her out with malicious intent in the past.

Sakuya was just the latest addition to their household as one of the last active vampire hunters in an age that had moved on past superstitions. Maybe she managed to convince Sakuya of her desire to simply live undisturbed and offered her a place in her household. There was no longer a place in the world for people like Sakuya and she must be aware of that somewhere in the back of her mind. Once upon a time a vampire hunter may have been a respected role but that time was a very long time ago. Surely Sakuya knew what it felt like to have a world scoff at her and dismiss her as a nutjob for chasing some mythical being that only she seemed to believe in. Someone as long lived as Remilia is probably aware of the futility of trying to fight against the changing times and it could be that she convinced Sakuya of that. There was no place left in the world for a vampire hunter and killing Remilia wasn't going to change anyone's mind.

But maybe Sakuya should predate Meiling. Unless she is a particularly well traveled Chinese person or we buy into the meme that she's Scottish sinoboo, it wouldn't make sense geographically for her to have joined up before Sakuya. The real lore is probably incredibly simple anyways. I'll bet ZUN would say that Remilia straight up recruited her through a help wanted ad in the local paper or something.

>> No.45510946

>>45510578
Patchouli stands out as the one who's different of the entire SDM household beyond the two sisters. While Sakuya and Meiling are clearly servants of Remilia, Patchouli seems more like an equal or at least they mutually treat each as if they're on the same social standing. Whether this is out of respect or them having the same same social status in the Outside World (perhaps both are of noble birth). But their relationship is mutually beneficial which might also be why they'd treat each other more like equals. Despite having an enormous library, Remilia doesn't actually spend much time there in any canon or semi-canon sources. On the other hand Patchouli most of the time seems to be the one doing the heavy lifting or enabling whatever new scheme or outlandish idea Remilia just came up with because she's bored and time rich. A bored but incredibly wealthy and powerful figure and their right hand of infinite talents and abilities to make whatever they want happen is a tale as old as time and considering Patchouli's both magical abilities and extensive knowledge it's not hard to see how they've formed such a lasting partnership.

Vampire hunting as a celebrated tradition and even historic role is pretty common in traditional folklore and practices in the Balkans and Eastern Europe. Considering Zun has repeatedly suggested the Scarlet sisters are from Europe it would seem fairly likely if either Remilia either adopted or abducted Sakuya her origins and real name is probably something likely from that region.

Meiling is probably the most recent addition to the SDM household. She might even be native to Gensokyo despite her Chinese identify and supposed origin. Sinoboo she probably isn't cause although extremely rare there are some ethnic Han redheads that carry that gene and occasionally are born with red hair, or she is still Chinese but from the far west or borderline Central Asian countries, nomadic tribes and ethnic groups where red hair is more prevalent.

>> No.45513579

>>45510946
Patchouli is more like a live in friend who does favors in exchange for room and board. Question is, did create the library herself or did Remilia always have one and she is simply letting Patchouli use it because she would get more use out of it anyways. Might even be a bit of both and the library wasn't nearly as expansive as it is now before Patchouli began adding to it herself.

>> No.45513738
File: 1.25 MB, 854x1500, 49583908504.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45513738

>>45513579
I see the library and by extension Patchouli being a lot like an in-house R&D department for Remilia's schemes and ambitions that Patchouli can usually make happen thanks to both her presence and the library's usefulness. The library probably existed in a much smaller form as is fairly standard anyway for stately home built in a certain age to have a library of some size so it's likely the SDM had one before Patchouli arrived. That said I doubt Remilia really has the attention span or interest to use it much herself so it's more like her giving Patchouli a blank cheque to keep on expanding to it as long as it can be useful for Remilia's ambitions when needed. I suppose it's a lot like historical royals or aristocrats patronising artists, philosophers, scientists or engineers and having them resident in their court/household as long as overall they're useful to their patron they're somewhat free to pursue their own pet projects alongside fulfilling their patron's desires. Remilia and Patchouli's relationship seems a lot like that although there's probably also some close personal friendship there as well considering they address each other on familiar terms rather than like a mistress/servant.

>> No.45513881

>>45513738
>I suppose it's a lot like historical royals or aristocrats patronising artists, philosophers, scientists or engineers and having them resident in their court/household
A real John Dee type of situation. Could even be that Patchouli herself was seeking that kind of arrangement so she could have someone bankrolling her studies and magical experiments. Who better than a literal supernatural being who is already well aware of the existence of magic and what it can do?

>That said I doubt Remilia really has the attention span or interest to use it much herself
I wouldn't count her out. Even Dracula himself was known to be a sorcerer and Remilia does make use of magic herself. I'm sure she's made use of her collection in the past and has just exhausted its resources since she hasn't added to it since coming into it. That said, she's probably not an all rounded looking to master every form of magic and only looked into things that she was particularly interested in.

>> No.45513926

>>45510578
>>45510946
I think you're reading too much into Meiling's red hair dude. We know shes a Youkai, they just have weird hair sometimes. Speculating on what kind of Youkai she is would be the more interesting discussion.

>> No.45515144

>>45513881
Patchouli is well read in the supernatural and magic to be aware of a powerful young vampire and seek her out so it's possible. Maybe I wouldn't count Remilia out in future but now she is still for a vampire at least young and not fully matured. It's more than likely given more centuries to mature she could start to pay more attention to magic and start fully utilising her library to the same extent as Patchouli.

It's a shame it's unlikely ever to come out as a full canon print work or manga but would be nice to see a spinoff fill in backstory or explore the history of the characters that have been introduced over the series originally from the outside world and chronicle some of their lives and origins before arriving in Gensokyo.

>>45513926
Doesn't the character on her hat translate as 'dragon' or something similar? Perhaps some kind of guardian dragon youkai that can take on a human form and guard a certain area similar to Auun as a shrine protecting youkai.

>> No.45523649
File: 159 KB, 850x601, 349834985904.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45523649

Who would win a physical fight or wrestling match between them? Is Sakuya physically strong or just over reliant on her powers.

>> No.45523658

>>45523649
Meiling could kill and eat Sakuya if she wanted to, but she chooses not to.

>> No.45523659

>>45523649
Well you can sort of see who is winning already here

>> No.45523674
File: 153 KB, 500x573, cutehongcolorcorrected.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45523674

>>45523649
Meiling. No contest. Sakuya might be surprisingly strong for a fit, yet fairly slender woman, but Meiling has zero physical weaknesses, is a legendary master of martial arts and has mega-youkai strength to put behind it.

Of course Sakuya has a busted ability, so add that back in and things might be a little more even.

>> No.45523721

>>45523674
>is a legendary master of martial arts and has mega-youkai strength to put behind it.
[citation needed]

>> No.45523775

Shame Remi can't get them to settle this at the next party at the mansion. Well, with both of them getting oiled up and wearing a lot less clothes for the entertainment of the guests.

>> No.45523804
File: 185 KB, 800x710, 043853940589034.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45523804

>>45523658
She does seem to be holding back a lot considering what she's capable of in spite of their regular disagreements.

>> No.45523843

>>45523674
That's a thing I wondered about Meiling. Is she ever said to be exceptional among martial artists or do people just assume she is?

>> No.45523888

>>45523843
Yes, she is chinese.

>> No.45523914

>>45523843
According to Perfect Memento she's referred to as a "master martial artist" but is only really good at keeping ordinary humans out; as far as youkai go, she's pretty low tier.
Just being able manipulate chi and being a martial artist probably doesn't mean much in a place like Gensokyo, especially when you have freaks that can just rape reality.

>> No.45524089

>>45523914
Just a master by human standards huh? Does this mean that she does not have super strength as a baseline ability like many other youkai do?

>> No.45524416

>>45524089
>Perfect Memento: "Unlike other youkai, she does not specialize in a single ability, but is well-rounded. Because of that, she's not particularly strong compared to other youkai, but she has no blind spots when facing humans."
Strange Creators also categorizes her as more of a "physically oriented" type but in terms of measuring her raw power, there's not much info other than her abilities in Soku. She is strong against powerless humans but would likely easily get her butt kicked by the more specialized youkai.

>> No.45524723

>>45498988
But what about the most important mystery with Sakuya; does she wear bloomers or panties?

>> No.45524770
File: 75 KB, 299x1132, 1117570207188.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45524770

>>45524723

>> No.45525045

>>45524416
She never stood a chance against Yuugi after all...

Think she could still take Remilia in a purely physical confrontation or would a vampire's natural strength and speed still be too much?

>> No.45525257

>>45524416
I want to see Meiling fight 10 of the best martial artists from the human village at the same time for Remilia's amusement like some Ip Man shit.

>> No.45525300

>>45525045
>Vampires have tremendous physical abilities and magical power: they are able to uproot a thousand-year-old tree single-handedly, to run
>through the human village within the blink of an eye, to summon many devils with a single word, to turn into bats or even mist to intrude
>anywhere they please, and they can recover within a single night even when their body is blown away, so long as their head is intact.
>Some youkai have abilities to this level of power, but only vampires are known to possess all of them.
Welp.

Even compared to the strongest youkai, vamps are still broke as fuck.

>> No.45525343

>>45525045
>>45525300
Forget about normal vampire abilities, the Remis have bullhit powers. Remilia can manipulate fate so that her opponent dies before facing her and Flanfly can pop her opponent's head from a distance like it was a grape.

>> No.45525373

>>45525343
Can she? do we ever see her using this?

>> No.45525802

>>45525343
That's why he had to specify a purely physical confrontation. Once magic gets involved Meiling's chances would drop from slim to none.

>> No.45528121
File: 141 KB, 664x791, 94890348534.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45528121

Has Remi ever fed on her before?

>> No.45528132

>>45528121
Highly unlikely if the tidbit about the people vampires feed on becoming ghouls is true.

>> No.45528203
File: 542 KB, 872x647, IMG_2441.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45528203

https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=x7WzWySS0L0

>> No.45532901
File: 200 KB, 1310x1406, Luna Nights.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45532901

>>45523674
KEK, Sakuya wouldn't even need her ability to beat the likes of Meiling.

>> No.45533070

Meiling getting clowned on in this thread.

>> No.45538880
File: 208 KB, 850x1062, 3498590438534.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45538880

How does Sakuya not succumb to the temptation to use those silver daggers on her mistress?

>> No.45540142
File: 437 KB, 1586x1626, __remilia_scarlet_and_izayoi_sakuya_touhou_drawn_by_suwaneko__3c1d9200aa2782f0079a8380d79b3fef.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45540142

>>45538880
Loyalty

>> No.45547644

>>45508151
I think that stuff like abusing time manipulation is that you could kinda mess the way you act and just alienate yourself socially. But there's probably more to it.
One possibility is that due to time powers Sakuya ages way slower than humans and thus got tired of seeing everyone around her die before her, maybe even her own children.
Thus she seeks the company of vampires who will outlive her instead of the other way around.
The Makai relation might also be her for some reason seeking power getting into Makai and doing a devil's pact that gave her the power over space and time in exchange of her dreams (Though I first thought the Soku ending was just talking about slacking off).

Also Patche might be from Makai considering her being a witch at birth, would be funny if Patche and Sakuya already met each other before Remi though.
Honestly I don't know if I've seen any fanworks relating the SDM crew's past with makai.

>> No.45547783
File: 236 KB, 600x600, IO-0265 (1).jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45547783

>>45499092
fact
source: i was there, i saw it

>> No.45549193

>>45525343
Remi and Flan is like a walking Death Note with no restriction.

>> No.45550786

>>45547644
Patche is more likely from the Outside World due to the nature of her relationship with Remi that suggests they've known each other far longer than they've been in Gensokyo. It's likely for a library to grow to that size with hand-written spells and books she's probably been working away on it at least a century or more which would place her arrival at the SDM well before arriving before the Vampire Incident.

>> No.45558190

>>45550786
Being a natural born magician I expected her to be from Makai. Especially since her more than being older than a hundred years sounds like she was born later than the Barrier, but I guess technically she could be older than Remi.
Wish we had a bit more of info about Makai, since excluding Akyuu's descriptions devils and youkai seem to be kinda different.

>> No.45558746
File: 462 KB, 850x385, 45908390543.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45558746

>> No.45567451

>>45500567
good summary

>> No.45567503

>>45500567
Of all things touhou, lards that try to push their chuuni headcanons on EoSD cast I understand the least.

>> No.45579223
File: 957 KB, 1200x800, __remilia_scarlet_izayoi_sakuya_flandre_scarlet_and_cirno_touhou_drawn_by_juuni_05__64639c629533abd8a5d41973d08fbec9.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45579223

>> No.45579243

>>45567503
It has vampires, a chuuni favorite.

>> No.45583568
File: 123 KB, 850x1200, __izayoi_sakuya_touhou_drawn_by_sinkai__sample-a79350ac14f44f8e55560e9046e56932.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45583568

as someone who ERPs as Sakuya from time to time I like to imagine her as a ex-stripper which Remilia was fond of, thanks to Sinkai's art of her.

>> No.45583598

>>45583568
Jack the Stripper?

>> No.45583610

>>45583598
pretty much yea

>> No.45583684
File: 741 KB, 2110x1734, 1700851772869.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45583684

I subscribe to the theory that she was brainwashed.

>> No.45587804

>>45499092
I believe it.

>> No.45600984

>>45500567
ZUN is NOT this shallow

>> No.45601739
File: 429 KB, 850x728, 5094859045.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45601739

Will Sakuya ever find a better alternative to pads?

>> No.45601897

>>45601739
Will memefags ever find a better alternative to humor?

>> No.45605871
File: 1.05 MB, 1017x1600, 1703486872702.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45605871

>>45498988
She's a pedophile.

>> No.45618021

>>45605871
I have no chance...

>> No.45619659
File: 1.03 MB, 1008x1920, 1703497568261.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45619659

It may be crazy, but probably "Raul Seixas" predicted Sakuya Izayoi in his song "O Dia em que a Terra parou". What do you think?

>> No.45620276

>>45619659
Y'all too slow.

>> No.45620992
File: 240 KB, 384x384, when she sees a pedo.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45620992

>>45605871

>> No.45621790
File: 248 KB, 833x1080, 5d9ab9c288059b5df10b35eb5fd43f8d.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45621790

>>45498988
For all you know it may have been a classic boy meets girl story. Who's the boy and who's the girl, both biologically, and by roles, is up to you to figure out.
But that's a rather lewd take!

>> No.45628028

Remilia puts out an ad for a maid in the paper, Sakuya shows up with her resume and then goes through two rounds of interviews, gets a call back later with an offer of employment then she fills out Forms W-4, and I-9 and reads through the scarlet mansion employee handbook.

>> No.45628048

>>45605871
I wish I was Sakuya so I could worship Remilia's cold dead child feet!

>> No.45628132
File: 347 KB, 850x1120, 1db1e2a5ce47d86990497cfb1e1b5ad.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
45628132

>>45499092
t. akyuu

>>
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action