[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/jp/ - Otaku Culture


View post   

File: 42 KB, 365x600, 6a023dd5015b0c266db138c721c8499c.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
37013989 No.37013989 [Reply] [Original]

Why is Alice in Wonderland so popular in japan compared to every other classic books?

>> No.37014509

>>37013989
What other classic books do you think should be popular?

>> No.37014535

Alice!

>> No.37014587

>>37013989
Why do you think Nabokov's "Lolita" is popular in Japan?

>> No.37014904

>>37013989
Cute little girl being a cute little girl in weird scenarios of a wacky setting
Very nice and comfortable surreal story
Congenial individual in a strange world with ambiguous inconsistent rules

>> No.37014911

>>37013989
cunny

>> No.37014960
File: 1.62 MB, 1722x1722, __alice_margatroid_and_alice_margatroid_touhou_and_1_more_drawn_by_futami_yayoi__b4d04f4fd6ee37b2430a9fab561b0f19.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
37014960

have you read the book? it's amazing, all the characters are crazzys, and alice are a very charismatic protagonist. compared with all same boring light novel for teens otakus with the cliche characters and situacions, a book like AiWL it's very fun to read

>> No.37015087

>>37014960
>have you read the book?
Yes, I did.
> it's amazing
Not really.
>and alice are a very charismatic protagonist
Not really. Just admit that you've read it because you're a weeb and a lolicon.

>> No.37015120
File: 102 KB, 728x1200, ce36c18505fb3a7982210afd1ea86ce9.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
37015120

>>37014960
She's such a cute and hilariously autistic retard. Making her a teen/adult or lewd just loses a lot of her charm, which is childhood retardation.

>> No.37015149

>>37015087
Imagine being filtered by Alice in Wonderland.

>> No.37015243

>>37015149
Imagine using the hackneyed construction with the word "imagine" to passive-aggressively attack people on a weeb imageboard because they called you out on being a weeb and a lolicon.

>> No.37015310

>>37015243
Imagine replying to that.

>> No.37015319

>>37015310
Imagine replying to that reply.

>> No.37015650

>>37015087
>admit that you've read it because you're a weeb and a lolicon
Apparently I was a weeb and a lolicon before I've even watched animus or seen loli

>> No.37015684

>>37015087
i don't want fuck alice. i just wanna give her my love...

>> No.37015922

It's a good book but when will Japan recognize the amazing literature in the United States? What about Stephen King?

>> No.37015947

>>37014509
Of Mice and Men

>> No.37015963
File: 484 KB, 671x420, 1628200210482.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
37015963

>>37013989
I'm going to Alice.

>> No.37015973

>>37015922
Japs can't read English, they just jerk off on a cover

>> No.37015985

ZUN is a big fan of Agatha Christie but what other authors does he like?

>> No.37016062

>>37015985
Hirohiko Araki

>> No.37016069

>>37014509
Faust

>> No.37016115
File: 160 KB, 970x1072, EF256040-9E6C-452D-96D8-5F72424B4534.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
37016115

>>37015684

>> No.37016460

>>37016069
That book or concepts of the idea get referenced enough

>> No.37022631

>>37013989
Disney

>> No.37023963

>>37022631
Why do japs love Disney so much?

>> No.37024057

>>37014509
A Confederacy of Dunces

>> No.37032086

>>37014509
The House on the Borderland

>> No.37032141
File: 91 KB, 600x944, Alice.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
37032141

Young girl that is frilly and cute

>> No.37036274
File: 341 KB, 1000x1750, 78f23c3e57a62e11324b46c3883083a7.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
37036274

how many Arisu exist?
also. why Arisu it's a common name in japan?

>> No.37036603
File: 400 KB, 800x537, アリス.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
37036603

>>37036274
>how many Arisu exist?
Literally countless derivations at this point, even if you just narrow it down to Alice in Wonderland-esque characters.
>why Arisu it's a common name in japan?
It's not common at all among Japanese first names, if that's what you mean. Even including kanji transcriptions1:
https://www.meijiyasuda.co.jp/enjoy/ranking/best100/girl.html
https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/アリス

As the Wikipedia article states, Alice is one of several common placeholder names in the West for a girl, like say Mary, Jill, etc. For whatever reason, it became a very common name for a generic female foreign character in Japanese culture, particularly in textbooks. One factor could be that "arisu" fits well with Japanese phonology, but that's just conjecture.
That, along with the cultural footprint of Alice in Wonderland, likely accounts for its representation in otaku works.

>> No.37036637
File: 106 KB, 619x960, Akutagawa_Ryunosuke_photo2.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
37036637

>>37015985
Akutagawa Ryuunosuke seems to be one.
ZUN also seems to be a fan of folklore as well, given his references to Sasaki Kizen's works and other spiritual/mythological literary references.

>> No.37036677

>>37032086
Imagine if weebs got into The Night Land.

>> No.37036694

I had assumed it wasn't the book that was popular, but the Disney adaptation. Yknow blah blah Bambi blah blah anime inspiration.

>> No.37036729

>>37015985
>>37036637
When he was asked what books on folklore he'd recommend he said just read Toono Monogatari.

>> No.37036773

>>37015947
Of Mice and Men is incredibly popular. Steinbeck is about as much of a cornerstone of American literature as Lewis Carroll is of British literature, and unlike his other works it is short and straightforward enough to be a common book to read for students.
>>37015922
>but when will Japan recognize the amazing literature in the United States? What about Stephen King?
He is known and AFAIK has most of his popular works translated into Japanese, but really most text-only authors in English and Japanese have little presence overseas. You might consider the comparison a disservice, but even a super-popular light novel author like NISIOISIN only has had some of his works officially published in English, and without the anime adaptations I would suspect much fewer would have been for lack of perceived audience.
It's not like Westerners who like to read avoid translated works by Japanese authors, but from what I've seen on /lit/ and more serious sites, people generally go for the most critically acclaimed Japanese literature, and I wouldn't be surprised if that mentality isn't at least somewhat similar in Japan for Western literature.

>> No.37036783

>>37036729
Yeah, that was written by Sasaki Kizen.

>> No.37036809

>>37036677
Never read that work, just Borderlands. I'll give it a look in the future.

>> No.37036845

>>37036637
Fun relevant fact: Akutagawa Ryuunosuke's translation of Alice in Wonderland was released a few months after his suicide after being finished by Kikuchi Kan.

>> No.37036899

>>37036783
It was written by Yanagita Kunio based on stories told to him by Sasaki.

>> No.37039488
File: 312 KB, 530x320, Walk_Away.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
37039488

>>37036899
Well I was wrong.
Thanks for correcting me.

>>
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action