/jp/ - Otaku Culture

>>17109705
100% inaccurate because the only official source of heights is a vague excerpt from PCB days.

>>17109705
Short Eiki tells me immediately that this is inaccurate.

>>17109823
While this is true, ZUN works pretty closely with Tasofro on the fighting games, and the sizes there tend to match up decently well with ZUN's vague descriptions. I would say that a good priority list for size discrepancies in canon works would be as follows.
ZUN's word > Tasofro's art > Manga art > Other official art > ZUN art
Only because ZUN can't draw for shit.

>>17110668
He had somewhat of a talent on the pixel drawing back on the PC-98 games. I want to see how good he is on drawing 16-bit instead of those lanky-kong bodyparts.

>>17110740
>He had somewhat of a talent on the pixel drawing back on the PC-98 games

Most of the PC-98 art was traced

>>17110744
>traced
Even better.

-Nitori of late should be Remilia or Suwako size.
-Marisa should be a hair above her, in line with Rinnosuke's pouch thing just about
-I think Yuuka would be taller if anything. A hair below Komachi, around Kanako size.
-Shiki Eiki should be taller, where Komachi's chin is maybe. Short Eiki has no basis and more evidence in favor of tall.
-Nue should be taller. It just looks like she's semi-tall in FS
-Yukari should be smaller. I'd say Alice size

>>17110816
Why would Yukari be short? ZUN's height statements list her as one of the tallest, and she's a European.
Ran is who should be toned down. She should be about the same size as Yuyuko according to the same statements.

>>17110816
HM puts Eiki at Komachi's height, actually.
And Marisa is a bit taller than Nitori/Remi/Suwako in the fighting games and in most of the manga, the only exception being that meme image from one of the manga that I know is influencing you here.
And Yukari was pretty consistently tall, and her being taller than Alice makes sense.

>>17110878
Because I forgot what ZUN said about it. If he said she's in the "Fairly Tall" category or whatever he called it, fair enough. His word goes. Similarly I thought he said Ran was in the Tall category.

But in FS or WaHH she doesn't appear that tall to me, which was my basis.

In any case, the level I put her at with Alice, or Reimu, or Reisen doesn't make her 'short' by any means. Just shorter than she is now.

Also

>shes's a European

What.

>>17110970
He's implying that Yukari and Maribel are the same person I'm guessing.

>>17110970
Maribel is a European. Yukari is Maribel. Unless them being based on Lafcadio Hearn is just a red herring.

>>17109705
I'd argue there is more problems with some not being small enough like Marisa and Nitori, we know for a fact Marisa is a complete midget in almost all her depictions and Nitori is even shorter than she is.

The fairies should also be quite a bit shorter as well in almost all canon depictions they're small enough that Marisa/Reimu could pick them up like a child with one hand. But they're not that much shorter here.

>>17110668
>Short Eiki tells me immediately that this is inaccurate.
But Eiki isn't short here?

She's about the same height as Reimu and Yuuka here.