[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/jp/ - Otaku Culture


View post   

File: 280 KB, 769x862, latest-4.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16128302 No.16128302 [Reply] [Original]

Does ZUN just suck at art, or are his official drawings a conscious decision toward a unique (if unpopular) aesthetic?

I'm beginning to assume the latter. Clownpiece's sprite animations really are fluid and memorable. They took talent to create, more than what's apparent from his Deviantart-tier character portraits. What says /jp/ on the matter?

>> No.16128314

>Does ZUN just suck at art, or are his official drawings a conscious decision toward a unique (if unpopular) aesthetic?
Ask ZUN.

>> No.16128324

>>16128302
I think he likes his own style.
TD was one step away from having generic anime portraits, while DDC and LoLK went back to a more rough style and coloration.

I honestly like the way he draws, but I can see why many people think it's crappy, specially since anatomy gets wacky.

>> No.16128374
File: 657 KB, 543x800, 334.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16128374

>>16128324
In ZUN's defense style is quite the improvement over Japan's pajeet-tier art prior to American influence.

>> No.16128380

>>16128374
*his style is quite

>> No.16128389

Art is nice.
Looks like porcelain dolls.

>> No.16128438
File: 750 KB, 707x1280, Reisen.Udongein.Inaba.full.1973027.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16128438

>>16128389
You could say that. If nothing else, the style is unique and against the grain in a creatively bankrupt anime industry.

Though I will admit to patching alphes portraits into all my games. The game just feels unpolished without.

>> No.16128656

I unapologetically masturbate to ZUN's artwork.

>> No.16128987

>>16128374
Fuck off

>> No.16129342
File: 59 KB, 223x317, 1474123075733.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16129342

>>16128438
What program do you use to patch the portraits into the games?
I've searched everywhere and found only the pictures themselves.

>> No.16129648
File: 39 KB, 341x411, 1464271210916.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16129648

>>16128438
>patching alphes portraits into all my games

>> No.16129672

>>16129342
thcrap

No really, that's what it's called. It works a lot like package managers on Linux. Installation uses a command line interface but all the available options are on the screen for you.

>> No.16131392 [SPOILER] 
File: 431 KB, 640x480, 1479630731952.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16131392

ZUN's art is good.

>> No.16131407

>>16128302
He was certainly awful when he started.
I think he's better now, but he sticks with that style because it's iconic.

>>16129672
Kill yourself.

>> No.16131544

>>16131392

it's better before he colors it

>> No.16132840 [DELETED] 

>>16128302
Fag, make up your mind. Are you talking about his illustrations, or about his art?

ZUN art is amazing dumbass. Why else we enjoy Touhou if not for the art? the lore, the characters, the setting, the music, etc

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G1jSf8ydvS8

...yeah, right, ZUN art sucks.
ZUN is an unique artist. 20 years and still continue to follow his heart.

Ugrateful bastards.

>> No.16132894

>>16128302
Fag, make up your mind. Are you talking about his art, or about his drawings?

ZUN art is amazing dumbass. Why else we enjoy Touhou if not for the art? the lore, the characters, the setting, the music, etc

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=G1jSf8ydvS8 [Embed]

...yeah, right, ZUN art sucks.
ZUN is an unique artist. 20 years and still continue to follow his heart.

Ungrateful bastards.

>> No.16133759

ZUN just has his own style. Whether if his style is good or bad is up to you, but I appreciate originality.
Though I think his color palettes could use a bit of improvement, and I also feel the poses can look awkward at times. But seeing as he's been inspired from JoJo at certain times, maybe that's where he's coming from.

>> No.16134085
File: 162 KB, 431x695, maxpuke.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16134085

>>16128438
>patching alphes portraits into all my games.

I think I have never been as disgusted with another human being as I am now

>> No.16135365

>>16128302
he might have sucked before
but it's increasingly obvious that he's deliberately drawing this way at this point

like, I feel like >>16128389 nailed it
that's exactly the aesthetic ZUN art brings

>> No.16136831

Stop being so ignorant and thinking art are drawings.

Why dicuss art if you are going to discuss just illustrations instead? discuss the whole thing he has done as you should!!

bunch of ignorants

>> No.16137142

>>16136831
get back to >>>/ic/

you d/ic/k.

>> No.16137219
File: 14 KB, 134x75, '''''aesthetic decision'''''.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16137219

He can't draw well. But he doesn't give a shit and enjoys doing what he does, which I respect.

>> No.16137667

His drawings are technically terrible and he never bothered improving. Stop giving him excuses.

>> No.16137691

To be honest, I think current ZUN art is pretty acceptable. It's nothing amazing or groundbreaking--and yes his old art was definitely awful--but I'd hardly call it bad. I can't help but wonder if the people who say it's still bad aren't just perpetuating some kind of meme.

It's pretty obvious that ZUN is not an artist by talent or trade, given how bad he was at it originally. But with enough effort he seems, at least to me, to have made big strides.

>> No.16137723

>>16136831

the only art i know of is this collection of tapes of me and your mom

>> No.16137745

>>16137219

cupping balls

>> No.16138173 [DELETED] 

>>16137667
He doesn't need them. ZUN's design is very solid and that's what's selling Touhou. For an good art he has army of fan artists.

>> No.16138186

>>16137667
He doesn't need them. ZUN's design is very solid and that's what's selling Touhou. For a good art he has army of fan artists

>> No.16138228

>>16137142
No d/ic/k would ever defend ZUN's art, I've seen people there trying to make a case for Michelangelo being shit unironically.

>> No.16138257

>>16138186
I get your point, was saying that for the people denying that ZUN have shit technical skills. Of course he's got other good points, like Ryukishi.

>> No.16138360
File: 252 KB, 256x774, eosd reimu portraits.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16138360

>>16128389
I prefer the rougher look of his earlier games than to his more recent stuff like LOLK to be honest. His more recent stuff feels more flat, I don't know whether it's because of the way he colors them now or what.

EoSD Reimu will always be my favorite. She's really adorable.

>> No.16138757

>>16137667
He shown a little knowledge about actual joints and anatomy recently, so that's an improvement.

>> No.16138831
File: 864 KB, 500x457, ZUN_SunnyMilk.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16138831

>>16128302

ZUN actually draws fine: it just doesn't translate well digitally.

>> No.16139041
File: 110 KB, 263x480, Th13Miko.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16139041

>>16128324
>TD was one step away from having generic anime portraits
No?

>> No.16139482
File: 764 KB, 578x686, PoFV_characters.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16139482

His art is cute, though usually bad in limbs.

>> No.16139724

>>16132894
>>16136831

These guys know what actual art is! not just a poser and vague term for drawings.

>> No.16140044

>>16128438
Is there any guide for doing this?

>> No.16140464

>>16138360
The one Windows game where Reimu isn't a total asshole.

>> No.16140476

>>16140464
She still is, just in a more chuuni way.

>> No.16140771
File: 733 KB, 826x826, 1470212368434.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16140771

>>16129672
>thcrap
Fuck, is there any alternative then?
thcrap stopped working for me a long time ago. Now all my shortcuts crash my laptop as soon as I attempt to play one. Anyone knows why this happens?

>> No.16140872

>>16128302

It's a unique style done on purpose with a mixture of ZUN being legitimately bad with hands and feet.

>> No.16140875

>>16140771
Because the thing is pure shit?

>> No.16143976

>>16140771
Redownload and retry?

>> No.16156062
File: 2.10 MB, 1536x5370, 05-18-omake.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16156062

>>16128302
You have to wonder how ZUN drawing skills keep getting worse everytime.

Especially when he was pretty good in pc-98. at imitating the anime/manga artstyle that was used in the 90's.

And then EOSD happened. He got better by IN, but fucked up hard again with MOF.

>> No.16156117

>>16138360
Top right Reimu still is my favorite illustration of her in the games.

>> No.16160117

>>16128302
Protip: ZUN became an alcoholic trying to draw hands for a concept art for the first 2hu.

>> No.16160214

You fags don't know what art even means.
As far as I know, ZUN has created a wonderful world full of bright fiction and ideas showng what he wanted to do

>> No.16160258

>>16140044
You can patch them in with thcrap. The repo should be included in the latest download and there is a guide on the thpatch wiki. Just select the alphes portraits when you run the configurator.

>> No.16160386

>>16156062
ZUN has good taste on girls

>> No.16160850

>>16156062
Who made this originally? it's look like it's part of a series or screen-captured from a web page, but I can't find anything about it by Googling (and noone else on the web seems to have made such interesting comparisons). Also, I remember already seeing this picture (probably on /jp).

>> No.16160881

>>16160850
It's from the PC-98 games translation project, the guy included an omake with interesting info like that

>> No.16161140
File: 42 KB, 479x361, 1477521671791.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16161140

>>16156062
>Lotus Land Story comes out in summer of 1998
>Reimu cosplays as a character from a manga that doesn't exist yet

Reimu confirmed for time traveler?

>> No.16161289
File: 2.76 MB, 839x1458, ZUN art.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16161289

The art isn't even that bad in my opinion. And it's crude nature gives it a special appeal.

>> No.16161420

>>16132894
>>16136831
>>16139724
>>16160214
Everyone gets it by now.

>> No.16161566
File: 13 KB, 655x380, lil cirno.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16161566

Can I draw touhou?

>> No.16161579

>>16161566
Why do you love posting your mediocre art everywhere?

>> No.16161592 [DELETED] 
File: 22 KB, 480x360, med.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16161592

>>16161579
Mediocre?

>> No.16161609

>>16161579
i like it
it has charm

>> No.16161628

>>16161566
Draw more wriggle

>> No.16161714

>>16161566
Nobody cares

>> No.16161727

>>16161714
About my art or just me wanting to draw touhou?

>> No.16161733

>>16161727
Probably both.

I like your art though, it's cute.

>> No.16161743

>>16161733
but how can you like my art if you don't even care like everyone else

>> No.16161748

>>16161743
I meant >>16161714 and 'everyone else' doesn't care.

>> No.16162042

>>16161748
That sounded kinda mean, sorry.

Some of us like your art, don't let the naysayers put you off drawing.
I should probably stop posting now.

>> No.16162062

>>16162042
I was kinda rude to him, it's just that I got a bit miffed because he already has a Touhou fanart thread up, and he decided to post that in a thread dedicated to ZUN's art. I saw it as a bit attention whorey and called him out for it.

>> No.16162097 [DELETED] 

>>16162062
There's a fanart thread on /jp/? I've never seen one in the catalog.

>> No.16162197

>>16161727
You already have a thread up where you are posting your doodles. This thread isn't about you.

>> No.16162221

>>16162062
>>16162197

sorry then, i'll just stick to my art threads then, didn't mean to cause any drama or seek attention.

>> No.16162260

>art style kept getting better
>it tanked with mof
>it got better with sa and ufo
>it tanked again with td
>it got better with ddc and lolk
why does this keep happening? why does he keep changing his art style?

>> No.16162965

>>16161140
Well, she appears in the far-flung future of Seihou, good as new. So maybe.

>> No.16163049
File: 261 KB, 456x388, 1467589990695.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16163049

>>16128438
What the fuck, anon.

>> No.16163064

>>16140044
blowing your brains out with a shotgun

>> No.16163113

>>16163064
stay mad

>> No.16163960

>>16161289
>due to a severe digital dysplasia I was born with it took 8 surgeries to get my hands to look even this good

>> No.16164647

>>16160881
Thank you very much. I just downloaded that English patch pack (for all PC-98 episodes) and those "omake" pictures were indeed there.

For the interested, search "Touhou Project games for NEC PC-98 - Complete English Patch Pack" on Google.

>> No.16165172

>>16161579
this

pretty annoying

>> No.16165179

>>16162260
because he's a composer/programmer, not an artist

That said he had an obvious high point with his art, and I do wonder what happened.

>> No.16165191
File: 38 KB, 250x248, 1467591678781.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16165191

>>16161289
>that Sakuya

>> No.16165257
File: 264 KB, 500x500, 1453872450118.gif [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16165257

>>16165191

>> No.16165593

>>16165191
>>16165257
People always point to EoSD Sakuya as being really bad but I find her smile to be super cute! EoSD Reimu is cool too.

Meiling is the one that stands out as bad yo me from EoSD.

>> No.16166001

>>16138360
My favorite Reimu portrait is the right one at the center. She just seems so calm, reflexive, sensible. I always associate it with the "It's so romantic in the shrine yard at night" line in Stage 1.

>> No.16166415

>>16165593
To be quite frank, they're all bad. The quality is just poor overall and his anatomy is often all sorts of fucked up. At least he's gotten a lot better since then.

>> No.16166731

Does anyone have a good quality picture of ZUN? I want to print it out and stick it up as a picture so I can have the lord and savior overlooking my living room.

>> No.16166780
File: 362 KB, 837x439, marcia.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16166780

>>16128302
Maybe the latter?

>> No.16166825
File: 689 KB, 640x480, Royal Edoma Engine.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16166825

Why do people hold ZUN's art to higher standards than other doujin games? It's just a doujin game series. Both the art and gameplay are shitty compared to non-doujin games.

>> No.16166829
File: 152 KB, 480x678, title.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16166829

Having funny looking art just goes along with the amateur thing

>> No.16167154

>>16166825
ZUN's art is on a high standar, full of magnificent stuff.
Backgronuds, setting, wonderful music, hilarious characters and interesting references to the folklore. If one thing is shitty it's the doujinshis that focus on meme crap

>> No.16167256

>>16166731
Too big for 4chan
http://gelbooru.com/index.php?page=post&s=view&id=883043

>> No.16167310

>>16131407
Like I get this is standard behavior for /jp/ but what was so offensive about their post? I've seen the program too, that's what it's called and does what anon says it does...

>> No.16167343

>>16167154
Why are you responding to b8, m8?

>> No.16167461

>>16166780
Did zun make that illust you posted?

>> No.16168083

>>16167154
>Both the art and gameplay [of doujin games in general] are shitty compared to non-doujin games.

Just because touhou is popular doens't make it suddenly not just a doujin game made by a hobbyist.

>> No.16168381

>>16168083
What? Touhou is a doujinshi series of game made by a hobbyist, in which he shows his art

The heck, you just miserably failed to comprehend.

>> No.16174818

>>16128438
I will never understand.

>> No.16174833

>>16128438
Why? Half the charm of ZUN's character art is seeing how it changes from game to game

>> No.16179323

>>16162260
Maybe it depends on how drunk he is at the time.

>> No.16182541
File: 18 KB, 640x400, DUEL_F09.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16182541

>>16167461
Unless there is another ZUN I'm not aware of, then I suppose so. This is from The Queen of Duellist.

>> No.16184064

>>16132894
ZUN's Style is his own, you don't like it, there are mods. I personally Use Alphes for some of the older games, as a personal preference, but i usually play vanilla first to see how it looks.

>> No.16184111

>>16184064
Visuals mods won't change the art at all: the art is always there, no ZUN's work will change.

>> No.16186868
File: 39 KB, 256x128, face07sdp.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16186868

>>16128438
Is there any way to get the files downloaded manually instead of having thcrap doing it?
Half of the portraits get fucked up because of it

>> No.16187239

>TD art is bad

what the fuck are you guys on about?

>> No.16187644
File: 120 KB, 392x495, 1467872740695.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16187644

>>16128438
>alphes will never design characters for another game again

>> No.16187664

>>16187644
1- Who are you quoting?
2- Moe's art is better

>> No.16188558

>>16187644
Thank fucking GOD

>> No.16189543

Zun's art is charming.

>> No.16189725

I wish more games had fairy wars art.

>> No.16190740

>>16186868
The alphes portrait patch is made up entirely of art by dairi.

All of dairi's portraits are in his google drive (I think):
https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/0B34TvJayojX_REtldUh1alhMU2c

Check his pixiv if you cant find something:
http://www.pixiv.net/member.php?id=4920496

>> No.16191218

>>16138831
I'm pretty sure he just makes the in game character portraits look like a 14 year old on deviant art on purpose. And I'm totally okay with it as it gives the game a much more organic and hand crafted feel. Like it was made by your friend and not some soulless studio out to make max profits.

>> No.16191850
File: 333 KB, 692x708, Th135_Futo1.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16191850

>>16187644
alphes doesn't design characters, ZUN does that. He just draws ZUN's designs in his style.

And shut up, not only do we not know if he's been permanently replaced, but it'd be a good thing if he did.

>> No.16191858
File: 348 KB, 614x718, Th145Futo.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16191858

>>16191850
>if he did
if he was

Could have been a ULiL-only thing, we don't know. Hopefully it's not, Harukawa's art is incredible.

>> No.16192030

My personal theory is that he is a natural lefty but was encouraged to use his right hand.

I had a similar problem with seemingly unending suck before I switched to my naturally dominant hand.

>> No.16192557

>>16128302
I think he draws shitty portraits on purpose because he knows that's what the fan base expects

>> No.16193215

How is liking alphes' """"style"""" even POSSIBLE

>> No.16193247

>>16193215
The guy from Tasfro who drew them titty monsters on their site (who apparently didn't draw for the game stuff) was their only good artist.

>> No.16193446
File: 447 KB, 1000x1000, e1S3uqq.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16193446

>>16182541
I refuse to believe this.

>> No.16194782

>>16166780
Is that supposed to look good? Because it's much worse than Touhou art.

>> No.16194837

>>16128302
It's a unique style because nobody else would want their drawings to look that bad.

I don't know how ZUN can be so talented at everything else but not improve his drawing skills after so much time. Maybe that's just the compromise.

>> No.16194858

>>16193215
It doesn't even feel like a style to me, even when he didn't draw with shit anatomy and fucked up color palettes his drawings looked like bland 2D stock images or something.

>> No.16195045

>>16128302
ZUNs art is nice though. I prfer it to the generic anime girl 18383628 style that all the fanart is.

>> No.16195615
File: 202 KB, 477x480, Th105Tenshi.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16195615

>>16194858
Same. If it wasn't for ZUN's great character designs, the drawings would be generic as fuck.

>> No.16195868

>>16194858
>shit anatomy and fucked up color palettes
i´m gonna need some proofs

I thought his style was a nice breather from the usual noodle legs and weird faces, like a more proper portrayal of ZUN´s girls

>> No.16195919

>>16194837
>It's a unique style because nobody else would want their drawings to look that bad.
What about UTG-Software's artists? Provided they make Touhou games typically, they even go so far as to make it lewd with their artstyles.

>> No.16195949

>>16195615
>Zun's great character design
Get out of jaypee

>> No.16195974

>still thinking art is drawing

>> No.16196654

>>16195949
>hating ZUN's character design
The fuck are you doing?

>> No.16196663

>>16195949
>dislikes ZUN's designs on /jp/

Aren't you the out of place one?

>> No.16196788

>>16128438
You should be banned for this

>> No.16196835

>>16195949
>Zun
Get out of /jp/.

>> No.16196938
File: 132 KB, 392x409, 2506272.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16196938

>>16128438
>>16195949
Kill yourselves

>> No.16197047

>>16195949
>>16128438
Meido should get you both killed

>> No.16197173
File: 34 KB, 617x462, Fuck you.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16197173

>>16128438
>>16195949
Hey buddy you got the wrong board, the pleb club is three doors down.

>> No.16197440
File: 460 KB, 999x1000, f432a191d03b486f8d0d2523e9032ceb.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16197440

>>16195949

>> No.16197538

>>16194858
I actually liked how he tried to make his art to look more ZUNish in HM. Shame it didn't go too well.

>> No.16197691

>>16139482

Their faces all look like peeled potatoes.

>> No.16198416
File: 319 KB, 672x620, Th135_Koishi1.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
16198416

>>16197173
FUCK YOU

>> No.16198740

>>16197173
get out of that jabroni outfit

>> No.16198855

I don't really see the problem with alphes' art. Both alphes and harukawa seem pretty good.

>>
Name
E-mail
Subject
Comment
Action