/jp/ - Otaku Culture

Guys this was my biggest lose
the knock and the letter so i will try to solve it now
if you want discuss with me thanks

my goal is find another solution for this trick instead of Everyone lied that i find strange since the great number of red truths + Lambda made this trick:
so make the situation clear
these events take place in 2 different times and 3 different locations that we call:
Before conferance-BC and 24 p.m for times
outside, dining all and 2nd floor for the locations
Erika as Kanon can join the dining hall meanwhile Erika personality is outside into the detective's thougth dimension.
this satysfay the red truths about characters locations
https://07th-expansion.fandom.com/wiki/Red_Truth
the difficult part is the knock

a simple solution is :
Kanon knocked from inside(red truth 'To knock' means someone hitting a door with their hand, this red does not specify which side),he was the closest to the door, so it wouldn't seem strange if the others, once they turned around, had already found him turned, then he pretended to find the letter he had hidden on himself.

for the letter this theory have no problems but this red truth deny this theory on the knock part:
>Let it be known that in addition to Krauss, Natsuhi, and Genji, none of those in the dining hall knocked on that door. In this sense, 'knock' includes all direct, indirect, intentional, unintentional, and coincidental events that could create a knocking sound.

Kanon was inside too into the dining hall so my theory is destroyed but another red truth contradicts the previous one
>And none of them misinterpreted a knocking sound. Krauss, Natsuhi, and Genji were not involved with the making of the knocking sound. No one else existed inside the mansion. And that knock refers to the action of standing directly in front of a door and hitting it with a hand.
>Natsuhi, and Genji were not involved with the making of the knocking sound
meanwhile in the first red truth no one in the mansion could knock at that door now only people at 2nd floor cant do it
so people at dining all are able to making of the knocking sound and this red truth give us another hint
>knock refers to the action of standing directly in front of a door and hitting it with a hand
>a door
>A DOOR NOT THAT DOOR BUT A DOOR

so thanks with all these i can formulate another theory
Kanon Knocked at another door inside the dining all and the construction of the room allows an acoustics that confuse the source of sounds so people thought the knock came from the door on the corridor, then he pretended to find the letter he had hidden on himself.

Simple becsause 2 red truth contradict each others, this level of reasoning is possible for italian anon
What do you think, everyone?"

>trust me guys Shkanontrice is the truth , everyone is the culprit 2 times is normal
fucking disguting

ERIKANTRICE EXPLAINE THE WITHCES:

humans create witches
a witch is formed by the union of stories, rumors, beliefs that humans use to explain something they can't explain.

>sure
Beatrice 2:was created by the union of the ancient legends of rokkenjima, the story about the blonde lover of kinzo and the mysterious facts that happened on the island.
beatrice 2 is innocent because the facts that were attributed to her were just forgetfulness of the servants who rather than admit their mistakes accused the witch.

Real Beatrice:was created when Yasu impersonating the witch began to scare the servants and throw them down the stairs when they insulted the witch, people began to be afraid of beatrice so she went from the innocent witch who played tricks, to a monster.

Eva-trice:for the public eva was the only one to survive the rokkenjima massacre so it was natural that stories about her guilt began, this stories created eva.beatrice.
maybe before the 3rd game tohya \ battler discovered that eva had survived and began to suspect her so ikuko wrote a story where eva seems the culprit for made battler understand that to find the truth he was supposed to go beyond appearances

Maria-trice:because of the influence of yasu maria began to seriously believe in witches and this put her in embarrassing situations at school, the other classmates began to spread rumors about how she was really a witch to bully her.
This created maria-trice

Angebeatrice: same situation of maria.
lassmates began to spread rumors about how she was really a witch to bully

featherine: the witch hunters since her stories seemed original began to believe that she was really a witch.

>maybe:

Bernkastle:after the discovery of the illicit affairs of rudolf and kyrie people started creating stories where they 2 were the real culprits of rokkenjima.
so, as in the case of evatrice, barnkastle was created from these stories.
I'm not 100% sure about this because bernkastle also appears in higurashi but there are many clues to that:
>kyrie and bern personalities are the same.
>after erika dies bern disappears into the world of abandoned pawns and only when ikuko calls her does she come out of there, so we understand from this that bern is a pawn of erika so a pawn of yasu.
>bern wanted to make people believe that the culprits of the eighth game were the battler family, after everyone accepted that bernkastle got enough power to implement his plan.

>idk
lambda:lambda remains a mystero for me.
She's always helped Battler and Beatrice, but I still haven't figured out how to classify her.

How you all think about that?

Erika best boy edition

>>22408868
ok
so you admit that the manga is fake
but ryukishi confirm it so ryukishi lied
so ryukishi could lied even on shkanontrice as true solution!!!

RED TRUTH: so is possible construct a theory with somelse other than shkanontrice as the solution of umineko!!!

Simply because umineko manga is wrong about the closed room circle, this level of reasoning is possible for Italian_Anon!

>>22346761
play umineku saku

prepare 3 cards one with written spring , one with written winter and one with written autumn.
put the spring card under the phone
put the winter card under the bed
put the autumn card under the clock
if natsuhi answers spring tell her to look under the phone
if natsuhi answers winter tell her to look under the bed
if natsuhi answers fall tell her to look under the clock

simple because natsuhi answers before finding the card, this level of reasoning is possible for italian anon!

>>22318670
Here's our true Erikanon.