/jp/ - Otaku Culture

>>35547965
Are you admitting that Umineko is not a mystery then? In a mystery you are supposed to be able to figure out the solution before it's revealed. But if you are allowed to twist the reds as much as you like then you can prove literally anything you want. Solving Umineko before the culprit is revealed becomes impossible, and the challenge to the reader near the end of EP5 was completely unwarranted.
>>35547981
You were the one trying to show that the scene justifies your interpretation of the red, and you failed to do so. Then, unless someone can show that the interpretation can be held without rendering all reds useless, my point stands.

Incompetent edition.
Old thread >>15006242