/jp/ - Otaku Culture

Why is Shkanontrice so obvious?

R07 sure puts a lot of effort into his red herrings.

Is "red herring" really a good enough explanation for the amount of evidence he presents to Shkanontrice? It's beyond a hint just being misinterpreted. Episode 6 says it again and again in terms that you can only call vague if you're in denial.

It's one thing to leave a hint that can be interpreted more obviously in a way that is false, but has another interpretation that is true. It's another entirely to scream THIS IS THE TRUTH THIS IS THE TRUTH THIS IS THE TRUTH THIS IS THE TRUTH THIS IS THE TRUTH ad neuseum for a whole episode, and scatter various hints in all others, then turn around and have all that be lies. Which is what R07 turning around and saying Shannon, Kanon and Beatrice aren't the same person would be like.

Nobody really has an explanation for the story elements of Umineko that fits better than Shkanontrice, except waving their hands and saying "red herring" or "troll". Where do the trolls and lies end? You'd have to gut a fair portion of the story for Shkanontrice to not be true.

Such a red herring man
R07 just makes up all this stuff to trick you
Since you were smart and didn't stop thinking Bern will save you in episode 7 and there will be no DID
There will be a perfect explanation for all the hints that Shkanonfags claim exist

Anyone got some good extensive evidence pictures like this?

Beatrice's true plan is to foster Kanon and Shannon's love with Jessica and George, then destroy them, making them want to destroy themselves, so she alone is left in their body, and leave only her love with Battler remaining.

She can't destroy furniture otherwise, for they're within her own body.