[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/ck/ - Food & Cooking

View post   
File: 83 KB, 1280x960, maxresdefault[1].jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9774608 No.9774608 [Reply] [Original]

Is cereal a soup?

Please reply with logic not emotion.

>> No.9774611

>>9774608
No, stop being a fag

>> No.9774613

>>9774608
Sure

>> No.9774623

>>9774608
>the basis of the shitpost is the failure to define soup
ok

>> No.9774642

Maybe

>> No.9774679

is a glass of water with ice soup? no, shut the fuck up

>> No.9774683

>>9774608
Yes, it is. It's a type of cold porridge, and porridge is grain soup.
>>9774679
No, ice water is a drink.

>> No.9774684

>>9774608
since milk is not a broth of any kind cereal is not a soup.

>> No.9774688

>>9774684
By that logic, gazspacho is not a soup since tomato juice is not a broth.

>> No.9774694

>>9774683
Porridge is not soup

>> No.9774697

>>9774608
Dude, just stop. Cereal is a type of pasta, everyone knows that. Have you not eaten a sweet pasta?

>> No.9774702

>>9774694
How is it not? You have food ingredients in a liquid. That's soup to me, bub.

>> No.9774730

>>9774702
If you eat it primarily for breakfast then it isn’t soup. Soup is a lunch and dinner dish

>> No.9774735

>>9774730
You're aware that many cultures eat soup for breakfast, right?

>> No.9774747

>>9774735
Yes and many people eat pancakes for lunch but that doesn’t make them a sandwich

>> No.9774748

>>9774747
If you put your bacon between two pancakes, then it is a sandwich.

>> No.9774752

>>9774730
the japanese soup in the mornings......

>> No.9774766

>>9774748
That’s just intentionally stretching the definition

>> No.9774772

>>9774766
It's literally a sandwich in the same way that an ice cream sandwich is a sandwich.
Sandwich.

>> No.9774783

>>9774766
t. brainlet
There's a whole world of soup and sandwiches out there that you're cutting yourself off from.

>> No.9774790

>>9774783
Because I don’t call anything in a bowl soup or anything between two other items a sandwich? Ok buddy

>> No.9774800

>>9774790
If you have food in a liquid, it's soup. If you have food between two pastries or bread, it's a sandwich.

>> No.9774804

>>9774608
>Is cereal a soup?
By itself? No.

Served in a bowl of milk or similar? Logically, it must be. Even though nobody would refer to it as soup in a casual conversation it certainly seems to meet the logical requirements for "soup".

>> No.9774808

>>9774608

No. The definition of a soup is...

>A liquid dish, typically made by boiling meat, fish, or vegetables, etc., in stock or water.

Ceviche is a soup. Gazpacho, bouillabaisse, and gumbo are all soups. Cereal is not a soup. I guess porridge is a soup, there's plenty of recipes for chicken porridge soup and whatnot. I guess the real question is, "is oatmeal soup?" If you boil oatmeal in water then it should be right?

>> No.9774810

>>9774808
You don't boil gazpacho. And yes, oatmeal is a soup. It's grain soup.

>> No.9774818

>>9774810

That's why the definition doesn't say "soup is always boiled" you silly. That's how it works.

>> No.9774826
File: 61 KB, 772x386, piccRDS0a.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9774826

>>9774818
Then where's the distinction? Grains are included in "etc". So are fruits. Pic related, fruit soup.

>> No.9774832

>>9774826
Stop

>> No.9774833

>>9774832
Not an argument.

>> No.9774844

>>9774608
No, it's cereal

>> No.9774924
File: 26 KB, 485x443, dumbwojak28.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9774924

>>9774730
So if I eat pancakes for supper they aren't pancakes anymore? After all they're a typical breakfast food.

>> No.9774926

>>9774808
>typically made by
>typically

>> No.9774935

>>9774924
No you mong, they retain their pancake distinction BECAUSE they are a typical breakfast food. It's categorized based on when people typically eat it

>> No.9774941
File: 56 KB, 645x729, dumbwojak33.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9774941

>>9774935
>what defines food is not the ingredients but rather the time of day you eat it

>> No.9774959

>>9774608
Soup:

a liquid dish, typically made by boiling meat, fish, or vegetables, etc., in stock or water.

>> No.9775026

>>9774941
He’s right and you are wrong

>> No.9775066

>>9774608
>Please reply with logic not emotion.
thats sexist

>> No.9775385
File: 139 KB, 920x948, Grover soup.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
9775385

>> No.9775442

>Breakfast cereal (or just cereal) is a soup made from processed cereal grains that is often eaten as the first meal of the day.
That settles it