/cgl/ - Cosplay & EGL

[Anonymous No.8980143]

Characters that are literally impossible to get a good cosplay of.

[Anonymous No.8980470]

That's quitter talk

[Anonymous No.8980488]

[Anonymous No.8980512]

>>8980488
I both hate this show and the character, but even I've seen some really good Peridots.

[Anonymous No.8982642]

>No chest to pull it off

[Anonymous No.8982651]

>>8980143
good lord wat does this artist even think boobs are?!

[Anonymous No.8982656]

>>8980143
your lies only hurt yourself anon

[Anonymous No.8982661]

>>8980512
Nearly all SU cosplays look bad imo though

They just don't translate well into real life

[Anonymous No.8982672]

>>8982656
Her figure is a rectangle.

[Anonymous No.8982769]

I bet it must be a huge pain in the ass to make a God Arc.

[Anonymous No.8982857]

[Anonymous No.8982879]

>>8982857
Boom.

[Anonymous No.8983172]

>>8982672
her skirt is a rectangle, figure is about as good as you're going to get short of a paid model.

[Anonymous No.8984101]

>>8980143
>tfw you will never make or see a good cosplay of your waifu

[Anonymous No.8984103]

>>8982672
>expecting anime proportions on a real person.

[Anonymous No.8984112]

>>8982879
As much as it's a passable and impressive cosplay I wouldn't call it GOOD compared to the source art. I don't anything about Persona but the way she didn't even attempt to replicate the way the cloth is attached and hangs from the sphere. The least she could do was sloppily sew some buttons on top. Then the ruffles at the top of her sleeves look miserable. And her wig doesn't match the design at all... You see how many nitpicks I can find here?

E for effort, but a passing grade isn't the same as good.

[Anonymous No.8984115]

>>8984112
You have to give it credit though, I also don't know Persona but the prop making skills are absolutely top tier. The wings, the ball itself, and the mask are fantastic. Where it is weak is definitely the cloth and the wig, but you have to give credit where it is due, anon.

[Anonymous No.8984117]

>>8984115
Okay, you have a strong point... Let's push it up to a C, but it's still not an A level cosplay.

[Anonymous No.8984125]

>>8984112
Anon you quoted there, I just posted this because while the wig is shit and the fabric part is also not true to source, the rest of it is indicative of some serious prop making skills. I just wanted to refute the "literally impossible to display correctly" part which is why I assume it was posted. Some fine tuning and it's pretty much there.

[Anonymous No.8984131]

high difficulty props thread?

[Anonymous No.8984439]

>>8984125
The longer you look at the cosplay you posted the better you see how bad the cosplay actually is.

Top isn't fitting at all and it's all wrong anyway. Mask is completely different. That lazy draping. The ball ending too early even for the art reference. That fabric color.
It's like the cosplayer looked at the reference once and never again.

So I keep Lucia and Juno still in "literally impossible to get a good cosplay of" list.

[Anonymous No.8984898]

Anything from Kancolle that's not Shimakaze

[Anonymous No.8984902]

>>8982672
>>8984103
>expecting 3d not to be pd

[Anonymous No.8984995]

>>8980143
Once we have affordable cloaking devices, John Cena will be possible.

[Anonymous No.8985051]

>>8984101
dream cosplays of cerea or papi

[Anonymous No.8985115]

>>8984103
>>8984902
It's like you've never seen anyone with a good hip to waist ratio. And she's in a thread for characters that it's impossible to get a good cosplay of. Why is it so surprising that this girl isn't good enough?

[Anonymous No.8985119]

Derivatives, yes, like the Calne Ca figurine from last year, but the original is probably impossible.

[Anonymous No.8985126]

>>8984131
the props look like shit

[Anonymous No.8985190]

>>8984995
CAN'T

[Anonymous No.8986944]

>>8984101

[Anonymous No.8986960]

My childhood would love to see this beautiful bastard done by a guy, not a fujoshit fangirl who over-feminizes him and doesn't really have the right proportions.

[Anonymous No.8986963]

>>8983172
There are plenty of girls more fit that aren't paid models. I mean she's not ugly or fat, but very Meh looking. I live in L.A. though so maybe that's why I'm used to seeing better figures

[Anonymous No.8986964]

>>8985119

[Anonymous No.8986965]

>>8982879
Not awful, but it did not translate well to real life.

[Anonymous No.8987116]

>>8980143
ITT:
>I feel like this cosplay will never be done perfectly
> Someone posts picture of an imperfect cosplay, further proving the point.

What is with this /cgl/ stigma to always prove each other wrong, especially with topics of opinion?

[Anonymous No.8987172]

>>8987116
He's not trying to prove them wrong he just thinks the universe owes him a girl that has an accurate cosplay with the perfect body type that's doing this of her own free will and not a paid model. People of 4chan love to talk down anyone hot as if they ever actually had a chance with them.

[Anonymous No.8987677]

>>8985126
better than anything you've made

[Anonymous No.8987841]

>>8987677
OOOOOOOH

[Anonymous No.8988301]

Anna's hentai octopus outfit. Is there an anon that can find a cosplay of that?

[Anonymous No.8988438]

It's not meant to be cosplayed

[Anonymous No.8988439]

>>8980143
>pic not related

[Anonymous No.8988441]

>>8987116
We feel so entitled to our opinions, and that's probably the thing.

>>8987172
There were honest discussion about imperfect craft up there, not only body types and shit. That's a field where we actually proved each other wrong, so the post you replied to is right. Don't isolate your trip to 4chan to crybaby lane, perfect bodies have been the issue only once in this thread so far.

[Anonymous No.8988444]

>>8982672
>Her figure is a rectangle
So like 60% of generic white girls.

>>8984902
this too desu but complaining about 3DPD on a cosplay board seems kind of silly.

>>8986960
You may have just inspired me to do it, ive never seen one either.

>done by a guy, not a fujoshit fangirl who over-feminizes him and doesn't really have the right proportions

I hear girls say this about Ouran Highschool cosplayers a lot as well. The cosplay world is ruled by fujos, so no helping it. I live on the east coast and its tumblr lesbian centeral. They're not even diverse, they all have that shaved/dyed haircut and hipster glasses so they're easy to avoid.

[Anonymous No.8988510]

>>8986964
Honestly, this is really mediocre craftsmanship. The arm is pretty decent, but her unfinished hems and wrinkled skirt is distracting me.
Also I thought Parasite had weird metallic dog-like legs.
Her makeup is nice, thought.
>inb4 "nit pick"
The thread is "Characters that will never be cosplayed perfectly"
Not "Characters you want to see done, but can never find a cosplay of"
And technically OP is right. Nothing will be perfect, because what is perfect to someone else is still not good enough for another. Everyone has an opinion and we forget that on this god damn board.

[Anonymous No.8990129]

[Anonymous No.8990135]

>>8988441
the nitpicking for the Juno cosplay is valid. There are a lot of details missing and once you start really looking you can see bad craftmanship.
But OP's only problem with the God Eater cosplay is the girl not having a flawless, incredibly proportioned bod.

[Anonymous No.8990139]

>>8985115
oh darn, her genetics are perfect enough for you. Too bad. It's not like she's fat and there are flabs everywhere. She's a very attractive girl and she looks good in that cosplay. I'm sorry that anime has conditioned your brain to think that a perfect hip to waist ratio makes a girl worthy.

[Anonymous No.8990147]

Neopets cosplays besides the faeries

[Anonymous No.8990165]

>>8982672
Man, fuck you, that is NOT something that is easily changed.

[Anonymous No.8990176]

>>8990147
This exist?

[Anonymous No.8990222]

>>8990147
No thank you

[Anonymous No.8990244]

>>8984101
Your waifus are shit anyways, and so is that show.

[Anonymous No.8990262]

>>8990244
I'm not some degenerate. I only have one waifu. And it's really rare to see good cosplays from that show.

[Anonymous No.8990283]

>>8990262
>Monster Girl Anime
> Most girls are half animal with only 3 of 11 being mostly human
> One being a giant spider
> One being a jelly girl who is see through
> Your waifu is literally half-horse and good looking 2 armed cosplays are death nevermind 4 legged cosplays.
Yeah I wonder why the cosplays aren't that good.

[Anonymous No.8990294]

>>8990283
Yeah, and this is a thread about characters that are so hard to cosplay that there are no good ones.

[Anonymous No.8990298]

>>8988438

[Anonymous No.8990831]

>>8982656
Its obviously shooped senpai,girl looks rounder irl

[Anonymous No.8990902]

tooru hagakure from bnha