/cgl/ - Cosplay & EGL

>>9224977
I'll bite.
For me it's a 5, the tights and shoes throw everything off for me. I used to love PB's outfits, but those shoes always got me. The bottoms look grimy..

>>9225593
6
It's cute, but as soon as you put someone not attractive in it it'll look terrible and weeby as hell

>>9225593
5/10
Pretty balanced but too much going on for me. Plus the wig looks cheap.

>>9226382
blue hair: 5/10, it'd look scary on anyone not attractive
pink hair: 0/10 monstrosity

>>9226382
Both 8/10.
This is what jfashion is to me. Colourful hair, androgynous feel and outfit choices that push the boundaries without rules.
The girl could lose the sheer thing and get another bag but otherwise it's great.

>>9226561
9/10
She has a nice look going on all around though I feel she'd look better if she switched out the glasses for rectangle frames - same thickness. Also wanna push up her eyeball bowtie since it looks close to falling off.

>>9226567
>She has too much of that fake "chop suey glasses" look going on*
Thanks for erasing part of my sentence, phone.

>>9226581
2/10. pic quality is bad & face is being covered so it's hard to rate, but...

outfit is plain and the heart cut-out seems choppy/lazy. doesn't look very rounded off at all.

single bow ring looks like an afterthought, bag is cute tho. the blush seems like it'd be far too strong irl.

... some tights/stockings wouldn't have gone amiss, and imo that hairstyle would have looked better if it were a wig.

also those laces look super ugly and messy, i can't tell if they're just badly tied or got ruined in photo editing, and one sock is dropping noticeably.

>one of my favorite outfits is on an actual living doll

>>9226581
7/10 maybe? I don't see much besides her sweater. Accessories are cute and minimal!

>>9226594
7/10. It's cute but a little bit plain. The bonnet seems too elegant/extravagant for the rest of the look.

>>9226601
9/10, saved.
Rather than trying to be edgy with the stereotypical tartan 'punk' look (fishnets, messy hair), she keeps the outfit from looking too schoolgirlish (if she used white socks and loafers, sweet makeup) with chunky shoes and makeup right out of a horror manga. The rings and the leather band beret are also a nice touch. Polished, yet dark. I love it.

I just love it so much even though it's nothing special. I don't know why

>>9224977
Besides the shoes and the tights i really like it. 6/10

>>9225593
Would look awful and weeby if the person wearing it was bigger/unattractive. Also wig is cheap looking. But it's well balanced and it suits her.

>>9226382
I really don't like veils and shit but it looks "ok" on her although really edgy teen looking. The whole thing would look bad on someone unattractive.
As for the guy's outfit it looks awful and i don't know what's going on

>>9226561
It's pretty nice, really quirky and suits her.

>>9226581
It looks ok? Not a huge fan of this kind of look myself but it's nice.

>>9226594
Don't like the bonnet shape at all and the dress shape is too potato sack like but it works surprisingly well! Loos socks aren't really going well with her look but it's not totally out of place either. I kind of like it,kind of don't.

forgot
>>9226601
Dark and punk-ish yet polished it's pretty cool

>>9226594
I absolutely love this girl. She goes by Lulu Hashimoto. Her outfits are always simple but still very cute.

>>9226810
I found her on twitter one day! I like her style, she really does look like a life sized BJD.

>>9226799
Neck pulshie looks kinda stupid, otherwise cute despite not being my thing 7/10

>>9226810
I'm confused, is that a mask? I'm not familiar with all this living doll thingy. Outfit is 10/10 though.

>>9226810
How does she do this though? I'm confused. Outfit is 8/10 to me.

>>9226960
Damn, I hate this. The top is ugly, the skirt is just a normie skirt, red shoes that match nothing and maybe it's my bias against coloured hair but it clashes really bad with the shoes as well. 2/10 to be honest.

>>9226963
nothing about this says j-fash to me. just 3edgy5you tumblr goth

>>9226960
i like how bjd tights-shoes add quirk to an otherwise simple outfit

>>9226594
>>9226810
ew

>>9226960
I hate this. 1/10. I don't like the whole bjd thing. The outfit is really normal fag beyond the bjd thing, the hair and shoes are ugly, lacking accessories.

>>9226963
8/10 I like it a lot. I think it's well balanced and pretty cute.

>>9226985
6/10. I think this is interesting but something feels off. I don't think I really like the shoes with it. I wish the hair was styled differently.

>>9226985
do you not know what rokku gyaru is?

also kinda hate this, such a pretty harness poorly styled...it looks almost like a back brace like this

>>9227010
so light and airy, all the styling fits well

>>9227029
for got to say 4/10 for the first 9/10 for the second

>ITT: Everything is "cute but plain" and "something off"


Not every jfash outfit needs to be OTT ffs.

>>9227035
The outfit I called plain just needs to decide what it's going for because the bonnet makes it seem OTT? The other outfit is just hot trash, don't see why it needs to be defended. I love simple looks.

>>9227035
two people have said plain, stop complaining and post a fucking outfit to critique or rate them yourself

>>9227040
headbow doesn't match to the rest of the outfit it is too childish in comparison. i also hate this kind of printed tights who wants a face on their leg? at least colors match 3/10

>>9226382
>>9226601
>>9226810
>>9226960
>>9226985
Liked.

>>9224977
>>9225593
>>9226561
>>9226594
>>9226799
>>9226963
>>9227010
>>9227029
>>9227040
Disliked.

pulled this from wear.jp.

>>9227040
lovely and cohesive, would wear. gorgeous colors, i like how her hair matches too. 9/10.

>>9226985
looks a bit unpolished somehow. 5/10.

>>9226960
awful and newbie-ish. would be better with a different shirt and dark shoes. 1/10.

>>9226799
love it, looks really soft and i love all the textures. 8/10.

>>9226581
i like that it's casual and fits my aesthetic, would wear. 7/10.

>>9226985
>'ew' to other coords, but you posted this
1/10 the harness ruins the outfit

>>9227133
Did you even check'd what I ew'd?

>>9227137
Yes, and no offense but they still looked better than that poorly styled harness outfit.

>>9227142
I actually like the outfit I posted but I don't think we only should post good outfits. Read the description, it just says post and rate.

All living dolls should be killed with fire I'm not even gonna argue on this.

>>9227074
cute hair/10

>>9226985
>nothing about this says j-fash to me. just 3edgy5you tumblr goth
take a look at what you just posted

>>9227924
the girl is cute but i don't like anything underneath the jacket (top or tutu). wouldn't wear outside of a club. jacket is nice and so are the accessories. would kill for her face/10.

>>9227193
the flower crown looks really out of place in this outfit, without it I'd say 6/10

>>9227924
Ahh, this is one of my favourite outfits of all time. Legitimate 10/10.

>>9227924
I would switch the tutu for shorts or a miniskirt. I like that she coordinated the colors with the coca cola bottle. 7/10

>>9227938
nice coordinate, but not very interesting as far as otome goes. the colors are very same-y and there's nothing about how it's coordinated that's grabbing my attention. it's clean and suits her, though.

7/10

>>9227924
This is perfection 10/10
>>9227938
Clean styling, I love the simplistic low hair 8/10 for not a perfect fit
>>9227944
So cute old school goth but cutsey! 9/10 not 1000% sure about the tights

>>9226601
ive had this saved on my phone for a long time, i love it! Preppy and dark without looking too edgy 10/10

>>9227935
Still more j-fash than the other one. Japanese goth always have been more cute or quirky.

>>9228236
>Still more j-fash than the other one
how can that be "more j-fash" than a rokku gyaru coord? what the heck.

>>9228236
The original one is clearly rokku, i can see about five pieces of glavil on her
How is a white girl in a harness and some urban outfitters looking shit more jfash?

>>9228236
Woops not white, looked at the picture too fast

>>9225607
She doesn't look very attractive to me. Maybe you meant "someone fat".

>>9226963
Easy. She's wearing a mask.