[ 3 / biz / cgl / ck / diy / fa / ic / jp / lit / sci / vr / vt ] [ index / top / reports ] [ become a patron ] [ status ]
2023-11: Warosu is now out of extended maintenance.

/biz/ - Business & Finance


View post   

File: 39 KB, 340x227, India1.jpg [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14380555 No.14380555 [Reply] [Original]

Is immigration necessary for economic development?

>> No.14380567

>>14380555
fuck no, higher productivity drives econ development

>> No.14380630

>>14380555
High skill immigration, yes
Miguel immigrating to pick oranges, no

>> No.14380780

>>14380555
>AI revolution imminent, rendering repetitive manual labor basically useless
>illegals work for much less than native population, keeping wages stagnant
>declining population=increase in wage due to supply and demand, but native population is being replaced
Fuck no. It’s all about them votes and power for Demonrats. You really think the left really care about them “poor and helpless immigrants”?

>> No.14380813

>>14380555
No. Even an economic illiterate could know this.

>> No.14380856

Just look at the VC money getting pumped into indoor automated farms. No need for low skilled labor

>> No.14381014

Even white collar jobs will under threat from a potential super intelligent ai. Every year, an increasing number of scientists agree that we will have it within the next 50 years. There just won't be any jobs for working class immigrants in the future. Pro immigration people need to think about this

>> No.14381185

>>14381014
>Pro immigration people need to think about this
Sure, but we do need smart immigrants. Elon Musk, Steve Jobs, and Nicola Tesla were all immigrants. Hell, you can even say Trump is an immigrant since he is second generation.

>> No.14381215

>>14380555
yes but specially selected

>> No.14381230

>>14381185
they were all white tho.
simple solution just ban all browns from immigrating.

>> No.14381244

>>14380555
Diversity is our greatest strength.

>> No.14381245

>>14380555
>Automation for low skilled jobs is a thing.
>import more people who need welfare
Nothing bad can happen from this.

>> No.14381299

The more education, skills and money you have, the easier it should be to immigrate.

Trump's H1B reform seems like a good idea because if you only let people immigrate when they're paid 140,000 USD or more, that would create upward pressure on American salaries.

>> No.14381326

>>14380567
Read no further, this is the answer.

>> No.14381370

>>14381230
“Skilled immigrants” usually means immigrants from rich countries like East Asia and Europe

>> No.14381387

>>14380555
No.

>> No.14381707

>>14381370
Skilled immigrants = "Pajeets on H1b's to undercut new CS grads"

>> No.14381975
File: 20 KB, 645x773, 1561474435794.png [View same] [iqdb] [saucenao] [google]
14381975

>>14380555
Short term: yes.
Long term: civilization dies.

Boomers think in the short run. They need money to retire, play golf, and travel, which is why they've been promoting migration to stimulate growth.

>What's the alternative?
Have more kids. Pump that cum into your waifu and get her pregnant.

>> No.14382058

>>14381185
I'm a white high skilled migrant in the US. White. Nice to meet you. I believe mass migration can destroy the country in a few generations, though when properly regulated it can be extremely beneficial.

>> No.14382114

>>14382058
Same here. Although I am a Canadian so I'm sure that some Americans hate me more than hispanic/pajeet immigrants.